So Kyler Murray gets praised as the best little QB...

[CRA]

Just now, Aussie Tank said:

You can quote drop percentage but what i see is the WRs keep dropping TD passes and deep balls. You can talk scheme but until we stop trotting JAGs out at WR who really knows what any of this offense is capable of.

I'd say the same thing if we traded Bryce in the offseason and went in a different direction 

I think defenses have been sitting on our pass game since early last season.  While we need some improved weapons….if your playcaller and QB can’t and don’t back a team off….life is just hard. 

I don’t think Tepper from day 1 has ever had a vision for Bryce.  Frank nor Dave really are the creative types needed for a Bryce.  Every O Canales has been around has featured a chunk ball gambler downfield. 

[Aussie Tank]

3 hours ago, CRA said:

I think defenses have been sitting on our pass game since early last season.  While we need some improved weapons….if your playcaller and QB can’t and don’t back a team off….life is just hard. 

I don’t think Tepper from day 1 has ever had a vision for Bryce.  Frank nor Dave really are the creative types needed for a Bryce.  Every O Canales has been around has featured a chunk ball gambler downfield. 

They sit on our pass game because our best receiver is a mid 30 year old  Adam Thielen. Even if we had Josh Allen what make other teams play off? 

[carolinanimal]

55 minutes ago, Aussie Tank said:

They sit on our pass game because our best receiver is a mid 30 year old  Adam Thielen. Even if we had Josh Allen what make other teams play off? 

Its also because I don't think they are scared of his arm. He throws a moon ball and most of those throws are under thrown, that's why he needs his "super power" anticipation. 

[Aussie Tank]

1 hour ago, carolinanimal said:

Its also because I don't think they are scared of his arm. He throws a moon ball and most of those throws are under thrown, that's why he needs his "super power" anticipation. 

It plays apart for sure but I also seen him uncork a lot at Alabama to JWill because he's a true deep threat 

[Mr. Scot]

On 12/22/2024 at 11:21 PM, CRA said:

 Even if you cherry pick Bryce post benching and ignore everything else and project it out over a full season…..

there is no statistical argument Kyler has ever been worse even cheating the argument toward Bryce post benching

I’m no Murray fan as I agree he is more athlete than QB.   And I’m open to Bryce improving and support us continuing to develop him as this point.   But just being an athlete, Murray has been better overall to date 

Disagree.

Murray's going nowhere fast. Bryce still at least has potential.

[CRA]

16 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Disagree.

Murray's going nowhere fast. Bryce still at least has potential.

Yeah, but the stats and production I referenced is just a statement of fact.  Bryce isn’t on that level of production yet.  Even cherry picked in his favor.  

and arguing future potential going forward from today between the 2 is a different conversation entirely 

if trying to win a game today, Kyler is the easy answer because his ceiling as a playmaker is substantially higher because his tools are better for this level. 

[CamWhoaaCam]

4 minutes ago, CRA said:

Yeah, but the stats and production I referenced is just a statement of fact.  Bryce isn’t on that level of production yet.  Even cherry picked in his favor.  

and arguing future potential going forward from today between the 2 is a different conversation entirely 

if trying to win a game today, Kyler is the easy answer because his ceiling as a playmaker is substantially higher because his tools are better for this level. 

Bryce already beat that bum with a lesser team. You can have Kyler.

 

I'm sticking with my QB. It's what Panthers fans do...

[Mr. Scot]

40 minutes ago, CRA said:

Yeah, but the stats and production I referenced is just a statement of fact.  Bryce isn’t on that level of production yet.  Even cherry picked in his favor.  

and arguing future potential going forward from today between the 2 is a different conversation entirely 

if trying to win a game today, Kyler is the easy answer because his ceiling as a playmaker is substantially higher because his tools are better for this level. 

Don't care about stats. Football has always had too many variables for statistical analysis to be a go-to approach. 

As far as tools, maybe his physical tools...or if you're talking about winning at Call of Duty rather than pro football.

[CRA]

1 hour ago, CamWhoaaCam said:

Bryce already beat that bum with a lesser team. You can have Kyler.

 

I'm sticking with my QB. It's what Panthers fans do...

Yeah, Kyler and Bryce never share a field together.  The Panthers did beat Cardinals.  

Cam Newton wasn’t a better overall QB than Tom Brady despite his teams beating the Patriots.  That’s never been how it works. 

it’s not about being a Panther fan if you are just supposed to be having a discussion of where 2 random QBs stack up today 

[CRA]

43 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Don't care about stats. Football has always had too many variables for statistical analysis to be a go-to approach. 

As far as tools, maybe his physical tools...or if you're talking about winning at Call of Duty rather than pro football.

I mean there is no maybe.  Murray has much better pure physical tools than Young.  Even suggesting it’s close is just silliness. 

which is why Murray has consistently one man showed it to much higher offensive production than even the cherry picked Bryce numbers 

people way too in their feelings over their QB (insert TO gif if that’s my QB) 

[OneBadCat]

2 minutes ago, CRA said:

Yeah, Kyler and Bryce never share a field together.  The Panthers did beat Cardinals.  

Cam Newton wasn’t a better overall QB than Tom Brady despite his teams beating the Patriots.  That’s never been how it works. 

it’s not about being a Panther fan if you are just supposed to be having a discussion of where 2 random QBs stack up today 

Peak Cam is goated. Take that back. 

[Ricky Prickles]

I think they are both cute little bastards but my loyalties stay with Bryce since he is our QB.

[CRA]

1 minute ago, OneBadCat said:

Peak Cam is goated. Take that back. 

Peak Cam is my favorite player to watch  of all time.  But he still wasn’t a better QB than Tom Brady.  

[CamWhoaaCam]

3 minutes ago, CRA said:

Yeah, Kyler and Bryce never share a field together.  The Panthers did beat Cardinals.  

Cam Newton wasn’t a better overall QB than Tom Brady despite his teams beating the Patriots.  That’s never been how it works. 

it’s not about being a Panther fan if you are just supposed to be having a discussion of where 2 random QBs stack up today 

Im telling you Bryce is better. He has a lesser roster. If they switched teams the Cardinals are in the playoffs.