TNF: Rams/Niners

[Aussie Tank]

1 hour ago, electro's horse said:

That’s probably the end of this iteration of the 49ers. 

lots of hard choices coming. 

Yep there might be a regime change coming and some bloated contracts being shipped off 

[CamWhoaaCam]

Cam tried to warn y'all Purdy was a game manager. Y'all decided to make him the villain. Looks like he was right all along. No way I pay that kid 60mil he would have to come down to 40mil to get me at the table.

 

Hell I would rather go with Rodgers then overpay Purdy. 

[rayzor]

[SmokinwithWilly]

9 hours ago, electro's horse said:

That’s probably the end of this iteration of the 49ers. 

lots of hard choices coming. 

We're seeing more and more the importance of high impact rookies on those cheap contracts. Having to pay Purdy anywhere near top 10 QB money is going to create some problems with that roster. 

[fanpanther]

48 minutes ago, CamWhoaaCam said:

Cam tried to warn y'all Purdy was a game manager. Y'all decided to make him the villain. Looks like he was right all along. No way I pay that kid 60mil he would have to come down to 40mil to get me at the table.

 

Hell I would rather go with Rodgers then overpay Purdy. 

Purdy is 8th in qbr for 2024 and tenth in total yards missing a ton of people all year long and 2 games due to injury.  Last night it was terrible weather rams qb had 160 yards passing 0tds with 2 of the best wr in football.  Purdy has 142 and an int he shouldnt have thrown but the wr also should have at least attempted to catch it.  He also had a td dropped by debo.  I would put him somewhere between 5 to 10 in nfl but hopefully takes a hometown discount.  The team played horrible when he missed those 2 games this year.

[CamWhoaaCam]

11 minutes ago, fanpanther said:

Purdy is 8th in qbr for 2024 and tenth in total yards missing a ton of people all year long and 2 games due to injury.  Last night it was terrible weather rams qb had 160 yards passing 0tds with 2 of the best wr in football.  Purdy has 142 and an int he shouldnt have thrown but the wr also should have at least attempted to catch it.  He also had a td dropped by debo.  I would put him somewhere between 5 to 10 in nfl but hopefully takes a hometown discount.  The team played horrible when he missed those 2 games this year.

5-10 lol

 

More like 11-20.

Place him on a lesser team he's off the radar imo. Jimmy G also looked elite with this 49ers roster. He wasn't anything once he left.

 

See how Burrow is still elite even if his team overall sucks?

 

Purdy isn't that kind of QB. He needs a team around him to succeed. Once you take away some of his weapons he's a non factor.

[Jon Snow]

3 hours ago, rayzor said:

Mr. Bean is him.

[outlaw4]

49ers had the right idea with their team. Problem is that they ended up facing the Chiefs in the Super Bowl twice, a unit that had defeated other teams with much better QBs like Josh Allen and Joe Burrow. Just a bad draw of opponent.

As for Purdy, it's less of a problem with him and more that this league, frankly, overvalues QBs in terms of how much they get paid, especially if they're not a top tier guy. Kirk Cousins got around 100k in guaranteed money with the Falcons. Sam Darnold might end up being paid in the same ballpark. Even Daniel Jones got a similar amount of guaranteed money. Basically, one shows mere conpetence and you get a ton of money at the expense of everyone else. 

[LinvilleGorge]

22 minutes ago, outlaw4 said:

49ers had the right idea with their team. Problem is that they ended up facing the Chiefs in the Super Bowl twice, a unit that had defeated other teams with much better QBs like Josh Allen and Joe Burrow. Just a bad draw of opponent.

As for Purdy, it's less of a problem with him and more that this league, frankly, overvalues QBs in terms of how much they get paid, especially if they're not a top tier guy. Kirk Cousins got around 100k in guaranteed money with the Falcons. Sam Darnold might end up being paid in the same ballpark. Even Daniel Jones got a similar amount of guaranteed money. Basically, one shows mere conpetence and you get a ton of money at the expense of everyone else. 

Yep, the Niners built a great team around a solid QB on a rookie contract. The Chiefs are just a dynasty right now.

The NFL has to learn that you can't pay average to above average starting QBs like they're franchise QBs. You just can't. You pay franchise QBs to carry your team. Those guys a step or two or three behind can't do that but paying them forces them to get and the results aren't pretty. You got a let them walk.

[fanpanther]

4 hours ago, CamWhoaaCam said:

5-10 lol

 

More like 11-20.

Place him on a lesser team he's off the radar imo. Jimmy G also looked elite with this 49ers roster. He wasn't anything once he left.

 

See how Burrow is still elite even if his team overall sucks?

 

Purdy isn't that kind of QB. He needs a team around him to succeed. Once you take away some of his weapons he's a non 

They have been ravaged by injuries and he still has put up really good numbers.  He has 4th string rb.  Debo and jennings at wr and debo has been terrible his dropped td cost them the game last night.  He is still a young player developing and is already really elite.  He gets alot of hate bc he is not athletic and flashy.  Burrow has had better weopons then purdy has this year on offense chase and higgens and a better rb as the 49ers have had cmac miss almost entire season.  He is 4 and 2 in playoffs and this is his 3rd year playing career qbrating of 104.9  higher than burrows 100.5 but i still think burrow is better just dont think people realize the number purdy has as last pic in the draft such a young career. 

[CamWhoaaCam]

1 minute ago, fanpanther said:

They have been ravaged by injuries and he still has put up really good numbers.  He has 4th string rb.  Debo and jennings at wr and debo has been terrible his dropped td cost them the game last night.  He is still a young player developing and is already really elite.  He gets alot of hate bc he is not athletic and flashy.  Burrow has had better weopons then purdy has this year on offense chase and higgens and a better rb as the 49ers have had cmac miss almost entire season.  He is 4 and 2 in playoffs and this is his 3rd year playing career qbrating of 104.9  higher than burrows 100.5 but i still think burrow is better just dont think people realize the number purdy has as last pic in the draft such a young career. 

If you have to make excuses and blame injuries as to why your QB is struggling that tells me all I need to know. Last I check Kittle and Jennings are still one of the better TEs and WRs in the league. Even with guys like CMC and Trent injured they still have more weapons than we currently have.

 

What Bryce is doing is more impressive than what Purdy is doing. Keep in mind the rosters of both QBs. 

 

 

[LinvilleGorge]

I don't care about arbitrary passer ratings that are completely derived from stats. When I watch them play there's a lot of guys I would take over Purdy.

Mahomes, Allen, Lamar, Burrow, Stafford, Goff, Love, Herbert, Hurts, resurgent Wilson, it's early but I've seen enough from Daniels and Maye to take them over Purdy and push come to shove is probably take Nix too. I mean, yeah... he's basically a middle of the pack type starting QB.

[CamWhoaaCam]

Who does Shanahan blame now?

 

 

[SmokinwithWilly]

37 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Yep, the Niners built a great team around a solid QB on a rookie contract. The Chiefs are just a dynasty right now.

The NFL has to learn that you can't pay average to above average starting QBs like they're franchise QBs. You just can't. You pay franchise QBs to carry your team. Those guys a step or two or three behind can't do that but paying them forces them to get and the results aren't pretty. You got a let them walk.

It's the rookie salary cap all over again.