Best and worst PFF grades from Panthers' Week 10 win over Giants

[fanpanther]

13 hours ago, Mage said:

I seriously doubt this.  PFF doesn't just throw 90s around.

I was curious so looked up a few below is the 49ers from week 10, I did find it interesting herbert for chargers had a 91.6

[t96]

8 minutes ago, fanpanther said:

I was curious so looked up a few below is the 49ers from week 10, I did find it interesting herbert for chargers had a 91.6

PFF sells themselves as being some super objective data based evaluation science but in reality it is extremely subjective and varies significantly based on who there is grading each player. And I don’t believe they really take into account the play calls/design. It’s an interesting piece of information but I still prefer the eye test. Which honestly it does usually sync up with but not always. I think in 2013 they ranked Luke as being average or some nonsense.

[strato]

Yeah I rewatch some of these games and they take points off of people that did good things in the game and I don't really get it. But I don't watch the play 11 times to see each guy individually.

Edited November 13 by strato

[PNW_PantherMan]

6 hours ago, t96 said:

PFF sells themselves as being some super objective data based evaluation science but in reality it is extremely subjective and varies significantly based on who there is grading each player. And I don’t believe they really take into account the play calls/design. It’s an interesting piece of information but I still prefer the eye test. Which honestly it does usually sync up with but not always. I think in 2013 they ranked Luke as being average or some nonsense.

It's still the eye test.  They're just putting a number on it.