Can We Not Over React to This One Game??

[mrcompletely11]

33 minutes ago, Ricky Prickles said:

Perhaps I'm just dumb but I don't see one Bryce stand. I see some people saying he played better than usual which is true but still doesn't cut it long term and he would have to step it up further to be the guy moving forward. I think where you are mistaken is where people are saying he deserves some more games to see what he can do. I can go along with that idea because it's a throw away season where we have to see what we have form many players. We invested way too much to get Bryce so here in the second half of the season we might as well give him his last go at it and see if he can improve week by week while showing he has the mindset and aggressive downfield attack he needs to have if he wants to start next season. Will be be able to? I seriously doubt it but we might as well with nothing to lose this season and if he underperforms as I believe he will then trade him for whatever we can in the off-season and move on.

 

[Gapanthersfan]

The majority of huddlers by and large are fair and objective, even the people that want Bryce out. I don’t see anyone that ‘hates’ Bryce.

So fair is fair. Objective. 

Bryce has been canned ass all season. Saints are terrible, but we are terrible-er. 

Yesterday he played a clean game. The third and long pickup to XL was the best throw I’ve seen him throw. He looked like he wanted to play. He walked the sidelines and engaged teammates. His decision making was improved. 

His lack of arm strength was apparent on a few throws yesterday, some passes should have been picked. All QBs have those, so ok. His long throws were better but need more oomph. 

I think Andy has been very good for him. 

Bryce is still a galaxy away from what we need, but yesterday was a big improvement. 
 

 

[Bear Hands]

I don’t see anything THAT reactive this week. 

We got a win, feels nice. Maybe we can get a third before the year ends. 

 

[NAS]

Yes this place loves to overreact. They were thinking playoffs when we beat the Raiders with Andy.

Agree with your assessment, encouraging but a long ways to go and he needs to prove he can keep getting better. 

[Khyber53]

It was a win, something rare, let's just enjoy it for a bit, pat some backs and say "good job". We all remember how to do that, right? It has been sooo long.

Give it a day or two then we can go back to picking the carcass.

[kungfoodude]

This wouldn't the Huddle without knee-jerk overreacting.

[Dave Gettleman's Shorts]

not overreacting but its always feels amazing beating the saints and cam Jordan especially knowing how bad we are

[ImfromClayton]

Man I feel like objectively Bryce is developing. QB's typically do not develop overnight. The ones that do are freaks. I think it's also fair to say that Bryce's ceiling is a lot lower than we thought it was.  Yesterday was one of his better games. His two best throws were not completed, but some of his poor throws got good results too. 

The saints not even considering throwing it to Jaycee's side of the field was freaking awesome. Not sure even Josh Norman ever got that treatment. 

Coker and XL will be part of the long term solution here. We have some solid young pieces. 

Must get a pass rush somehow. That is a dire circumstance at the moment. 

[SmokinwithWilly]

14 minutes ago, ImfromClayton said:

Man I feel like objectively Bryce is developing. QB's typically do not develop overnight. The ones that do are freaks. I think it's also fair to say that Bryce's ceiling is a lot lower than we thought it was.  Yesterday was one of his better games. His two best throws were not completed, but some of his poor throws got good results too. 

The saints not even considering throwing it to Jaycee's side of the field was freaking awesome. Not sure even Josh Norman ever got that treatment. 

Coker and XL will be part of the long term solution here. We have some solid young pieces. 

Must get a pass rush somehow. That is a dire circumstance at the moment. 

Even before the draft, BY was supposed to have the highest floor but had the lowest ceiling of the top 3. Just turned out that Stroud's floor was higher than Young's ceiling from the start. 

[jtm]

Mondays on the Huddle after a win or loss are always an overreaction and super entertaining.  

[Joe Bear]

I'm not overreacting when I say that the Panthers are winning out and Bryce Young's Super Bowl MVP trophy is being developed as we speak.

[mrcompletely11]

24 minutes ago, SmokinwithWilly said:

Even before the draft, BY was supposed to have the highest floor but had the lowest ceiling of the top 3. Just turned out that Stroud's floor was higher than Young's ceiling from the start. 

Most nfl ready qb since luck

[L-TownCat]

1 hour ago, kungfoodude said:

This wouldn't the Huddle without knee-jerk overreacting.

[Mr. Scot]

The fact that you have to ask this question is kind of an answer in itself.