Yasinskas' best and worst draft classes in NFC South History

[Dpantherman]

By Pat Yasinskas

...By NFC South history, I mean that literally. I’m looking only at the drafts that have come since the NFC South started play in 2002. Yeah, I know you could argue that Tampa Bay’s 1995 class, featuring Warren Sapp and Derrick Brooks, might be one of the best in the history of the league. I also know the Falcons, Bucs and Saints did their part to have some incredibly bad drafts back in the 1970s. But I wasn’t old enough to really know the ins and outs of those drafts.

So we’re going to start with the 2002 draft and work forward. I’m also going to leave the 2009 class out of this because one season isn’t enough to judge a draft. With that in mind, here’s my winner for the best draft class in NFC South history.

1. 2006 by the New Orleans Saints. It’s not even close. This class eventually could end up in the same conversation with the Sapp and Brooks class. Forget No. 2 overall pick Reggie Bush for just a second. The Saints found Jahri Evans in the fourth round and receiver Marques Colston with their second of two seventh-round picks. Evans is the best guard in the league and Colston is an outstanding receiver. Bush maybe hasn’t lived up to the hype, but he’s been a productive player and second-round choice Roman Harper has developed into a solid safety. Offensive lineman Zach Strief, also a seventh-round pick, has been a valuable backup.

2. 2008 by the Atlanta Falcons. Yes, I’m giving Matt Ryan the benefit of the doubt here. A lot of people say he took a step back in his second season. I’m not one of them and I think Ryan will take a huge step forward in his second season. Anyway, I’d take what Ryan did last season and be reasonably content with it. At worst, he’s a solid starter. At best, he’s a franchise guy. What the Falcons did in this draft was get the quarterback of their offense and they also got the quarterback of their defense, taking linebacker Curtis Lofton in the second round. Left tackle Sam Baker was taken late in the first round and there are some questions about his durability. But the Falcons also found some other players, like receiver Harry Douglas and safety Thomas DeCoud later in this draft.

3. 2006 by Carolina. We’re giving the Panthers extra credit for hitting on DeAngelo Williams with the 27th overall pick. It’s easy to get it right in the top 10, but there are no sure things late in the first round. Williams has turned into a very good all-purpose back and the Panthers got starting cornerback Richard Marshall in the second round. Fifth-round choice Jeff King has been a decent starter at tight end and linebacker James Anderson has a chance to claim a starting role this season.

I’ll be back with the three worst draft classes in NFC South history in a bit.

http://espn.go.com/blog/nfcsouth/post/_/id/9426/best-draft-class-in-nfc-south-history

[The Saltman]

evans the best guard in the league? I dunno bout that

[KillerKat]

why did he put up an article he's not even finished with yet?

[CharlotteBeer.com]

I think our 2008 draft was better as a whole.

[Swarly]

I think our 2008 draft was better as a whole.

Yup. Don't know how he thinks 2006 was better than 2008.

Otah, Stewart, Dan Connor, Gary Barnidge, Bernadeau, Schwartz..

Saints draft was definitely a good one though.

[Dpantherman]

Worst:

1. 2007 by Tampa Bay. As I debated the demerits of what Atlanta and Tampa Bay did in this draft, it really came down to the fact that the Bucs hit the trifecta with their first three picks. They took Gaines Adams, Aaron Sears and Sabby Piscitelli. You can’t really argue with that. Adams was a non-factor before the Bucs traded him to Chicago, Sears couldn’t play last year because of personal issues and Piscitelli showed last year that he can’t play. Safety Tanard Jackson, a fourth-round pick, has been a bright spot, but not enough to pull the Bucs out of the top spot.

2. 2007 by Atlanta. When the Bucs took Adams, they passed over Jamaal Anderson and the Falcons pounced on him with the No. 8 overall pick. If you don’t hit on a top 10 pick, you’ve got a problem. The Falcons have gotten nothing out of Anderson. They did get a solid starter in guard Justin Blalock in the second round and fourth-round pick Stephen Nicholas became a starter at linebacker last year. But Bobby Petrino and Rich McKay also gave the Falcons cornerback Chris Houston in the second round and receiver Laurent Robinson in the third. Houston started a lot of games for the Falcons, but the current Atlanta regime was thrilled to trade him to Detroit this year. Robinson never came close to being a factor.

3. 2003 by Tampa Bay. Speaking of Petrino, he played a major role in building what almost was the third-worst draft class in NFC South history. I gave very strong consideration to Carolina’s class of 2005. Louisville products Eric Shelton and Stefan LeFors were tremendous busts. Atiyyah Ellison and Jovan Haye showed they can play in the league, but only after they left the Panthers. But I couldn’t quite put Carolina in this slot because first-round pick Thomas Davis has worked out. If you want to see a class that truly flopped from top to bottom look back at the 2003 Bucs. They were without a first-round pick because it was used to help get coach Jon Gruden out of Oakland. But the Bucs jumped in after that and gave you this collection of draft picks – Dewayne White, Chris Simms, Lance Nimmo, Austin King, Sean Mahan and Torrie Cox. Sad part is Cox, the last pick of the bunch, probably did the most of this group.

http://espn.go.com/blog/nfcsouth/post/_/id/9432/worst-draft-class-in-nfc-south-history

[SmootsDaddy89]

I'd even put 2007 over 2006.

[Brokenbad]

Lol...I thought he said Kenny Lofton....here we go with the ultimate Saints nuthugging.....one more thing, you noticed last year the Falcons were SOO overhyped at the begining? I guess everyone is off their jocks now...

[CatMan72]

1. 2006 by the New Orleans Saints. It’s not even close. This class eventually could end up in the same conversation with the Sapp and Brooks class. Forget No. 2 overall pick Reggie Bush for just a second. The Saints found Jahri Evans in the fourth round and receiver Marques Colston with their second of two seventh-round picks. Evans is the best guard in the league and Colston is an outstanding receiver. Bush maybe hasn’t lived up to the hype, but he’s been a productive player and second-round choice Roman Harper has developed into a solid safety. Offensive lineman Zach Strief, also a seventh-round pick, has been a valuable backup.

LOL, he's easy to forget.

[X-Clown]

evans the best guard in the league? I dunno bout that

30,000 word essay from Saint J is forthcoming...

[The Saltman]

***

[DaveThePanther2008]

2008 was a sweet class of us. Bush is a bust. He hasn't really been anything to the hype he had coming out of college. The overall #2 pick should be lights out awesome. 2009 was his best year. 4 years after being drafted he finally shows some value.

[JeramiahCopperfield]

What about 2001? That draft was sick

[SmootsDaddy89]

What about 2001? That draft was sick

NFC South didn't exist.