Brandon Aiyuk trade

[Panthers Fan 69]

8 minutes ago, strato said:

I am a big whatever on your criticism. Keep chirping I don’t care. We have how many draft rounds invested there right now? 3 years in a row one per year. 2nd, 2nd, 1st all vying for number 3 WR

It ain’t guitar collecting, WRs do not get more valuable hanging on the wall not being used. 

Maybe we develop the overflowing WR room and maybe then WE can get some picks coming our way for once.

 

 

Cool. 

[jb2288]

2 hours ago, mrcompletely11 said:

How are you going to pay him and are you willing to risk giving up a top 5 possible top 2 pick for him?

Paying him would be a non issue. Giving up the 1st would be off the table for me tho 

[DeAngelo Beason]

6 hours ago, Panthers Fan 69 said:

Why? Aiyuk Xavier and Adam Thielen automatically be one of the top five receiving corps in the NFL and y’all Bryce nut huggers that love Bryce Young wouldn’t that make him better as well?

MAYBE top 15.  

[SOJA]

Wouldn't do it for a first but pretty much anything other than that within reason I would. Aiyuk is a special WR. If Bryce pans out wonderful. If he doesn't you want to give the next guy weapons. 

This league has turned into an offense- pass driven league. If you can't put up points and yards in the passing game you aren't winning a superbowl 

[Panthro]

Any stellar Cs out there to be had

[strato]

I see what y’all are saying but new staff and they haven’t even had a good look at these guys . Mingo last year. Legette this year. Plus how many OCs QBs and HCs has Marshall had now? I’m not saying they are anything certain but they are so young and the coaching has been inconsistent, lots of change and it hurts young players. We have a WR/QB specialist OC and HC, I am looking forward to them getting to work on them and see what they can make of it. 

I wouldn’t mind having a stacked bunch of quality WRs, naturally. But I don’t think the timing is right for sending picks and spending a huge contract. We might even need to sign a QB next year. I’d personally make small adjustments and go with who we keep. 

 

[PleaseCutStewart]

8 hours ago, Panthers Fan 69 said:

Why? Aiyuk Xavier and Adam Thielen automatically be one of the top five receiving corps in the NFL and y’all Bryce nut huggers that love Bryce Young wouldn’t that make him better as well?

What assets do we have that SF would want from us outside of draft picks? And if we are giving away draft picks being a bottom 5 team, then we are truly that retarded and deserve to be a poverty franchise 

[Panthers Fan 69]

Hey!  We have a chance to get a true 1! Panthers Huddle…. “Nah, we wanna be mediocre”. This group will never change. 

[Aussie Tank]

Yes do it. Dolphins and Bills are proof of what you need to do to unlock “Bust” QBs 

[Johnstonny]

Panthers don't know what to do with good players. The ones we had we just gave away... so whats the use. Keep building thru the draft and pray dipper has patience to see it thru. 

[catnip]

I would not give up any draft capital at this time , Our first rounder next year will probably be a top 10 pick ,  If we are to spend more cap space lets put it on a CB such as Gilmore .  We need to see what we have on our young WR core and beef up our defense a little more . 

[strato]

He was a late 1st. I haven’t really kept up but it looks to me like he can’t get his money from SF for whatever reason. And wants top dollar.

We just spent a late 1st and don’t know what he is, but that is the way to get these guys. Or in the 2nd. Or 3rd. Look at the guys people have found even last year. 

Again, we just are getting started, like step 1, with a HC that was hired in large part because of his work with QBs and he came up doing WRs. His OC is a WR guy. I am just thinking we need to let them work and evaluate. 

Edited July 18, 2024 by strato

[RumHam]

i don't see how this guy will thrive outside of Shanahan's system.

[TLGPanthersFan]

11 hours ago, Panthers Fan 69 said:

Hey!  We have a chance to get a true 1! Panthers Huddle…. “Nah, we wanna be mediocre”. This group will never change. 

We don’t need to trade another first and this year isn’t about playoffs or Super Bowl. It is about evaluation. We need that first round pick and after Bryce I never want to see another first round pick traded ever again.

Edited July 18, 2024 by TLGPanthersFan