Official American Idol thread.

[g5jamz]

He didn't get voted off...he received the least votes but was saved.

[SmootsDaddy89]

Yeah I know, but I didn't see him getting the least amount of votes period.

[Darth Biscuit]

It's a little surprising, but his song this week was not very good... he's one of the only two (him and Crystal) that I knew the judges would save. Now I just hope that Crystal doesn't get the votes she needs one week... she's really the only one IMO that is even close to being a real performer.

[Hawk]

that was a bit of a surprise. This was a strong week for many of them...will be interesting to see two of them getting punted next week

[Samuel L. Jackson]

They shouldn't have saved him...

I don't agree that he should have gone before some of the others, but the show is called American Idol, not Judges Idol...

Ah well, Crystal, Lee, Casey, or Katie are gonna win it all... and I would lean towards Crystal or Lee...

[j2sgam]

The save is an absolutely stupid addition to an otherwise decent show. If theyre good enough, they get a contract anyway..Daughtry anyone? There are others, but I more watch it for the hot females..McPhee ensured that I will continue to watch...

[SmootsDaddy89]

I wonder if Katie will take me to HER prom if I vote for her the most.

Or is that creepy?

[j2sgam]

Creepy as hell...Get her parents permissi, er, consent before you book that hotel...and PAY CASH...

[Hawk]

I kind of like the save....guy like Big Mike can sing and has lots of talent...gives him a chance to make up for a bad week

[SmootsDaddy89]

Age of consent in Massachusetts is 16

[SmootsDaddy89]

I kind of like the save....guy like Big Mike can sing and has lots of talent...gives him a chance to make up for a bad week

I didn't even really think it was bad at all personally. Oh well. Glad they saved him.

[g5jamz]

Yeah I know, but I didn't see him getting the least amount of votes period.

Me neither...how Andrew Garcia is still in it..I haven't a clue.

[SmootsDaddy89]

I like Andrew, but he's way, way too inconsistent.

[Samuel L. Jackson]

The thing with Mike is that, while his confidence may come off as playful and all, he sings with an arrogance...

His voice isn't all that great, and while he may have good range and control, his voice isn't unique... He thinks he can do any song he wants, and get away with it... I just hope, for his sake, that this week has humbled him a little, or else he might just find himself there again pretty soon...