Official American Idol thread.

[g5jamz]

You missed some good music.

[Dpantherman]

24) Allison Iraheta

23) Diana DeGarmo

22) Danny Gokey

21) Willam Hung

20) Kimberly Locke

19) Taylor Hicks

18) Blake Lewis

17) Bo Bice

16) Katherine McPhee

15) Elliot Yamin

14) Josh Gracin

13) Jennifer Hudson

12) Adam Lambert

11) Kris Allen

10) Rube Studdard

9) Fantasia

8) David Archuleta

7) Kellie Pickler

6) Clay Aiken

5) David Cook

4) Jordin Sparks

3) Chris Daughtry

2) Carrie Underwood

1) Kelly Clarkson

explanation of pics and more: http://www.billboard.com/#/features/top-24-american-idols-of-all-time-1004088662.story

who's too high and who's too low???

[Samuel L. Jackson]

Switch #3 and #1 with each other, and I pretty much agree...

[Dpantherman]

Switch #3 and #1 with each other, and I pretty much agree...

that, and move J-hud higher

[necroplasm]

Latoya London could out sing most of them. Why she not on that list?

She should have won season 3.

[Pumpkin King]

Switch #3 and #1 with each other, and I pretty much agree...

Really?

I can't stand Daughtry. He's way overrated, and he sings in one tone the whole time. Gets annoying.

[Dpantherman]

Latoya London could out sing most of them. Why she not on that list?

She should have won season 3.

no success after idol

[necroplasm]

no success after idol

That was only due to her personal life problems. She still had some success.

Really?

I can't stand Daughtry. He's way overrated, and he sings in one tone the whole time. Gets annoying.

I deeply agree

[Dpantherman]

That was only due to her personal life problems. She still had some success.

what kind?

[Dpantherman]

on a personal note. Don't care for Daughtry. I think this list is based on album sales. I think Sales and success outside of music should count as well.

[necroplasm]

what kind?

Well she released an album.... appeared on Soul Train, Larry King Live, The Tom Joyner Show, etc.

That is not amazingly successful but she got pretty well known and has made some money and has fans.

She was too good to be voted off when she did.

[SmootsDaddy89]

Four North Carolinians on that list. In the top 10 at that.

Also Casey should go home this week. What a giant turd he laid last night.

[Dpantherman]

Well she released an album.... appeared on Soul Train, Larry King Live, The Tom Joyner Show, etc.

That is not amazingly successful but she got pretty well known and has made some money and has fans.

She was too good to be voted off when she did.

She was in the bottom the same night Fantasia and Jennifer Hudson were in. the top 3 should have been those three, but somehow that season Hudson and London were screwed. No denying that. talent is def. there.

Four North Carolinians on that list. In the top 10 at that.

Also Casey should go home this week. What a giant turd he laid last night.

A BIG giant one!!! if anyone but him leaves this show is corrupt. I always hate him, last night proved I had good reason

[Dpantherman]

Well she released an album.... appeared on Soul Train, Larry King Live, The Tom Joyner Show, etc.

That is not amazingly successful but she got pretty well known and has made some money and has fans.

She was too good to be voted off when she did.

She was in the bottom the same night Fantasia and Jennifer Hudson were in. the top 3 should have been those three, but somehow that season Hudson and London were screwed. No denying that. talent is def. there.

Four North Carolinians on that list. In the top 10 at that.

Also Casey should go home this week. What a giant turd he laid last night.

A BIG giant one!!! if anyone but him leaves this show is even more corrupt than I think. I always hate him, last night proved I had good reason