Official American Idol thread.

[Dpantherman]

UGH!! If Sinatra were alive he would have shot Casey James in the F**king head!

[Dpantherman]

that SUCKED!!!! miserably. worst performance by anyone all season long

[Dpantherman]

Even when Crystal gives a C effort, its still better than the competition. its wasn't my favorite, but shes still Crystal. and btw, shes knows shes the front runner and shes gotten very arrogant (my opinion)

[Dpantherman]

Michael Lynche just stole this night. that was fantastic. reminds me of Ruben, best vocal of the night by FAR

[Darth Biscuit]

Even when Crystal gives a C effort, its still better than the competition. its wasn't my favorite, but shes still Crystal. and btw, shes knows shes the front runner and shes gotten very arrogant (my opinion)

Yeah, she's great... and she looked fantastic tonight too...

[Dpantherman]

Lee impresses again, and to me, He has passed Crystal. My Rankings (as a whole, all shows included after tonight)

1) Lee

2)Crystal

3) Big Mike

4) Aaron

5) Casey

[Pumpkin King]

Meh. I think crystal sounded the best tonight.

And I don't think she's arrogant. She's just the only one who stands up for herself. She sang great and the judges didn't like her because her performance wasn't amazing.

[Dpantherman]

Meh. I think crystal sounded the best tonight.

And I don't think she's arrogant. She's just the only one who stands up for herself. She sang great and the judges didn't like her because her performance wasn't amazing.

It doesn't have to be negative. i still think shes arrogant. hell why not be? but anyway. to me its not just tonight. i think that Lee has been on her tail all season, hes the only one good enough to even challenge her, and tonight he had the better performance, maybe i jumped the gun, but either way, right now both are in the finals (barring a major performance by some under them. and i do mean MAJOR)

[Samuel L. Jackson]

I don't think she's arrogant, but she tries to talk back too much...

Take your criticism in stride and come back stronger...

Lee is going to win it, with Crystal in second...

[Dpantherman]

I don't think she's arrogant, but she tries to talk back too much...

Take your criticism in stride and come back stronger...

Lee is going to win it, with Crystal in second...

dangit!!! so i chose the wrong word. Whats the word im looking for--- ( i still think she has a smigit of arrogance deep down). cocky?? snappy? eh. but anyway, Id like to her to shut it at least once after the judges criticize her. getting annoying a bit

[Samuel L. Jackson]

lol no worries dude! I agree pretty much...

If anyone is arrogant, it is Mike... he annoys the hell out of me...

[Dpantherman]

lol no worries dude! I agree pretty much...

If anyone is arrogant, it is Mike... he annoys the hell out of me...

ive noticed that too. hes top 3 by default. its a 2 person race this year.

[SmootsDaddy89]

Why the hell does Harry Connick Jr say bro so much?

[Zaximus]

I skipped this episode, couldn't handle a full hour of Sinatra songs + Connick Jr. I don't really understand it, they want singers to sound current, then make them sing songs that haven't been current in 30 years and, are about impossible to make current.