Schefter: McNabb to Skins; compensation unknown

[CharlotteBeer.com]

I hate to say I called it, but I did call it.

[ncbobcat]

Oh hell no. Donavan used to be one of my favorite non-Panther players. But not as a Skin. Eww.

Actually, If Dan Snyder sells the Skins', I would follow them more closely. Snyder has always reminded me of a yuppie version of Jerry Jones. Yeah, Skins' fan pre-Panthers.

[Mesmer]

Yet another bad move for the Redskins. Donovan is a marginal improvement, but he wasn't worth giving up picks for. They have other needs.

[ncbobcat]

Again, Snyder reminds me of Jerry Jones...I highly doubt this was purely a Shenahan move.

[God]

Campbell for a 4th/5th make it happen.

[SOJA]

Actually I like the move for the Redskins. Not only will McNabb jerseys sell like hotcakes, but it adds an excellent player to a position they really need to address. Campbell has never worked there, not saying his career is done, but he needs a change of scenery. Now the skins can use their first round pick on a quality player instead of blowing it on Clausen.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

I think this is one of the best moves the Redskins could make. They're looking pretty good on defense -- imagine how much better they'll look with a competent offense?

I think McNabb's got several more productive years in him, and Campbell -- should they decide to keep him -- could benefit from learning under him.

Call me crazy, but I think they could win the division next year.

[stirs]

Shanahan needed a QB that could run the west coast offense. Since their current QB could not quite grasp the last offense, it is hard to believe he could step right in and run the complicated WC.

Giving up a second for McNabb is more than a fair price. McNabb is older and will be there for only a short time. Two to three years. If Campbell can learn it, fine. If not, look for him to be gone after this coming season.

Left tackle should be on board at the 4th pick.

This just moved some QB's down the board.

Washington and Seattle now have less need. Should be some good ones available mid second round.

[ChucktownK]

Duuuuuuumb dumb dumb dumb DUUUUUUUUMMMMMB!!!

[SOJA]

Actually the more I think about it. This was a great move for both sides assuming two things:

One: The Redskins get another playmaker on offense to help out Mcnabb (although for a couple years in Philly he had zero wide-recievers)

Two: Kevin Kolb is as legit as all of Philly thinks he is

If that fact about Philly having five picks in the first three rounds is right, they could seriously do some damage next year assuming premise two is sound.

[necroplasm]

3rd/4th next year? o_O

[pantherclaw]

Instant contender!

[Dpantherman]

WHOA folks. don't forget Campbell has a first round tender on him. so unless the Skins get the sudden urge to give him away for a 3rd or something, then forget it

[ncbobcat]

Philly first three rounds 5 of the top 87 picks:

1st-24

2nd-37 (Washington)

-55

3rd-70 (Seattle)

-87

Not too Shabby...