Tuck or Pep?

[ChucktownK]

Heres the deal to me.

Who holds the ball longer...McNabb

Who is the better QB at recognizing pressure....Warner

Who's O line is protecting better.....AZ

I am just saying that Tuck has a better chance at sacks, which is all the media cares about from a DE. Peppers is a much better DE, either rushing, or passing situations.

Your are right but at this point as of late I have seen Warner throw the ball late and I think Mcnabb is better at moving around and getting the ball out. Just my opinion though.

[NewEnglandAFChamps]

No offense to Tuck he is good. But Peppers is great. Better athlete and more of a freak

[ChucktownK]

NO WAY!!!! We actually have a Patriots fan here. Crazy!!!! Welcome (grits teeth)

[thefuzz]

NO WAY!!!! We actually have a Patriots fan here. Crazy!!!! Welcome (grits teeth)

He's a pretty good one, has a ton of respect for our beloved Panthers.

[Urrymonster]

Guys seriously. He was not saying Tuck is better, just that he had a better chance of making an impact due to Warners very quick release and brilliance at picking up where people were coming from. I repeat, he was NOT saying Tuck was better.

To those who say Peppers does not play as hard is a fool. Watch the Ravens DL, who are incredible. They move all over the place BUT, they play disciplined and watch for the run first before letting loose on the QB. ONLY when they know it is definately a pass (situation and distance) do they just go hell for leather - just like Peppers. Peppers plays hard, but he also plays disciplined which is what you want from an elite player.

[ChucktownK]

No offense to Tuck he is good. But Peppers is great. Better athlete and more of a freak

It's actually nice to hear it from other fans because peeps were so down on him last year we thought the entire league felt he was a bust. Thx tho

[CarolinaPride74]

Tuck is a very good player but he is not the monster that Peppers is and he never will be which is why we have to re-sign him even if that means letting Gross walk.