Donovan McNabb

[engine9]

and you know what's something? the one time McNabb DID have a reliable receiver (loud mouthed as he is), they went to the SB.

The Eagles receivers today looked like a bunch of Carters and Colberts.

[Darth Hater]

The Eagles receivers today looked like a bunch of Carters and Colberts.

They could all be #1's in Chicago.....sad but true.

[Peppers90 NC]

spare me the "McNabb is great" tributes. next week you'll want his head when he sucks up the field. Also, he should be thanking mr westbrook. Donovan did nothing against the vikings. The D and 1 westbrook screen won that game.

he is mr. excuse..... i threw up during the superbowl... the pats cheated, blah blah blah. Donovan could have been great. But his inconsistant play, lack of game knowledge(didnt know a game could end in a tie), and his lack of a great wide receiver will keep him from ever ranking in the elite qb status.

If what you say is true, there are two "elite" qb's in the league right now: Brady and Manning.

[Darth Hater]

McNabb Is better than Eli and does it with far less talent around him.

[jdl]

McNabb Is better than Eli and does it with far less talent around him.

far less talent? The giants dont have a superstar running back. They dont have a superstar wide receiver. Where is this magic talent the giants have over the eagles? I'll take westbrook over the giants RB's, and any of there receivers over any of the giants.

But i wouldnt take mcnabb over eli.

eli is no great qb, he is barely above average. he is a game manager and does well when his team is ahead and plays well in the NY style offense. He has lost some big games and has also won the big one against one of the best teams in NFL history.

The NY offense isnt a big strike team, never has been.

[X-Clown]

far less talent? The giants dont have a superstar running back.

No, but they arguably have the best offensive line in the league, and have Brandon Jacobs who is an absolute monster. Derrick Ward is a stud too, and likely is going to get a big payday from another team.

They dont have a superstar wide receiver.

They did, but he shot himself in the leg and made other numerous mistakes off the field. And when that happened the whole team changed, which is why they lost to the Eagles twice in a row, and to a pitiful Cowboys team.

Where is this magic talent the giants have over the eagles?

Offensive line, overall running game, defensive line, pass rush. And that's even with arguably their best defensive player (Osi U) missing the whole season.

I'll take westbrook over the giants RB's, and any of there receivers over any of the giants.

But i wouldnt take mcnabb over eli.

eli is no great qb, he is barely above average. he is a game manager and does well when his team is ahead and plays well in the NY style offense. He has lost some big games and has also won the big one against one of the best teams in NFL history.

The NY offense isnt a big strike team, never has been.

The Giants defense would not have given up 32 against the Cardinals yesterday. Eli would not have been able to dig his team out of an 18 point hole in the second half.