Smitty vs. Fitzgerald

[Dry Heat]

This thread is fun. Should move it to the Smack Talk category, quit talking stats and intangibles, and really have some fun.

[cardsfanmd]

You forgot the part where we're 12-4 and you're 9-7 (10-7 now).

And Pro Bowl is nothing but a popularity contest and a terrible measurement of what player is better.

Agreed, but it is slightly telling that the team with the smallest fan ollowing in the league still had it's two guys at the top of the list while your player who gets much more exposure is below them. I also dont see how their records have anything to do with it. I am gonna stop now because this whole convo is semi-irrelevent since Andre Johnson is better than either one of them.

[cardsfanmd]

This thread is fun. Should move it to the Smack Talk category, quit talking stats and intangibles, and really have some fun.

i saw your mother playing backgammon with a sea turtle

[89=#1]

cardsfan you are a ****** moron!!!! Im sorry bro but sitting here looking at your bs posts has pissed me off, so let me tell you. Smith will be the best reciever on the field on saturday night. He has the best stats of any reciever in the postseason of all time. Of course fitz and boldin cant really do much about that since they dont ever get their!!!

Points to tear apart your fitz and boldin stats are better that smith bs:

1. fitz had 10 more yds than smith on the season but smith played two less games he is actually the only THE ONLY reciever to avg over 100 yds a game this season

2. smith also leads the league in yds per catch far exceeding fitz

3. smith gets thrown to way less than fitz considering we are a very run heavy team

4. if their were a clutch catch stat category lol... which theirs not he would lead that too... everyone knows that

5. smith has won a triple crown only third guy to do it ever... when fitz or boldin does that then talk to me

6. your argument that you have three great/good recievers to throw to, which you do, for reasoning why fitz doesnt have more yards just retarted...

WHY YOU ASK? because you pass the ball nearly twice as much as the panthers do and also the panthers do throw the ball to a #2 quite oftern moose had 65 catches and a near 1k recieving season.... so this argument is not one it is just an excuse

IN CONCLUSION: fitz is a great i mean great reciever and so is boldin but until he makes some postseason runs and makes huge clutch catches in divisional and championship games he is not steve smith. Until he wins a triple crown he is not steve smith. until he comes back from near career ending injuries to shine he is not steve smith. It is a good comparison but fitz has a lot of work to do!!!

[Jgigs]

They are both great. But I'd prob give the edge to fitz.

[cardsfanmd]

cardsfan you are a ****** moron!!!! Im sorry bro, but sitting here looking at your bs posts has pissed me off, so let me tell you. Smith will be the best reciever on the field on saturday night. He has the best stats of any reciever in the postseason of all time. Of course fitz and boldin cant really do much about that since they dont ever get their!!!

Points to tear apart your fitz and boldin stats are better that smith bs:

1. fitz had 10 more yds than smith on the season but smith played two less games he is actually the only THE ONLY reciever to avg over 100 yds a game this season

2. smith also leads the league in yds per catch far exceeding fitz

3. smith gets thrown to way less than fitz considering we are a very run heavy team

4. if their were a clutch catch stat category lol... which theirs not he would lead that too... everyone knows that

5. smith has won a triple crown only third guy to do it ever... when fitz or boldin does that then talk to me

6. your argument that you have three great/good recievers to throw to, which you do, for reasoning why fitz doesnt have more yards just retarted...

What's worse, my argument or that fact that you cant even spell retarDed you moron?

WHY YOU ASK? because you pass the ball nearly twice as much as the panthers do and also the panthers do throw the ball to a #2 quite oftern moose had 65 catches and a near 1k recieving season.... so this argument is not one it is just an excuse

IN CONCLUSION: fitz is a great i mean great reciever and so is boldin but until he makes some postseason runs and makes huge clutch catches in divisional and championship games he is not steve smith. Until he wins a triple crown he is not steve smith. until he comes back from near career ending injuries to shine he is not steve smith. It is a good comparison but fitz has a lot of work to do!!!

Hey douchebag, maybe you should learn how to spell before you go around calling people morons. You have about the worst sentence structure and lack of proper punctuation I have ever seen. My God, didn't your mother ever tell you that an "I" all alone needs to be capitalized? My bad, I guess she was too busy in the back room with her dad. Oh wait, I guess he's your Dad too. What do you guys call him? You need to get out of your sister's underwear drawer and go back to school you little inbred. I started to fix them (in red the best color there is of course) but it would have taken all damn day.

I have been treated well on this board and respect and appreciate the vast majority of the posters here but you are nothing but an ignorant idiot.

More to the idiot, THE IS NO TRIPLE CROWN IN FOOTBALL!!!! That is horse racing you genius. Also, if Fitz can be blamed for his team not making the playoffs, then how is Smith so damn clutch while his little baby fingers are so bare!!!!!!!!! Where are the rings?????

Finally, I will finish this post with a great quote that seems fitting:

"Nowhere in your rambling incoherent reponse did you even aproach anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points and may God have mercy on your soul." -Brian, Billy Madison

[89=#1]

hey cardsfan this is not english 101 i am not writing a paper for your class, so *** you pussy. you are a bitch and the only reason you run that ****** mouth is because you know im not around here for me to beat your bitch ass. so you keep grading papers you fine young male. if you wanna do something let me know. are you coming to charlotte this weekend? if so let me know well meet up b it ch

[1BADAZCARDSFAN]

You may be right, but I'd never bet against Smitty on anything... he's just way too savy... Not sure how he does it, but he always does... Imagine having Smitty on one side and Fitz on the other.... How would you stop that?

That would be similar to what's going on in AZ now!....INJURIES would be the only thing,Oh and SALARY CAP!

[1BADAZCARDSFAN]

gotta go with smith.

Most dangerous wr in the league. Maybe the most dangerous player in the league period.

yeah, he is awfully violent,but so was rae carruth !!!

[1BADAZCARDSFAN]

i was wondering if anyone was gonna bring up fitz beating a girl up. Maybe that should be another contest, we'll let him and larry johnson go at that one

did not one of your recievers kill a baby before it was born and the mother ?

[AZCardsForLife]

did not one of your recievers kill a baby before it was born and the mother ?

Yup! That and their cheerleaders are carpet munchers. Not that there is anything wrong with that.

[Dry Heat]

cardsfan you are a ****** moron!!!! Im sorry bro but sitting here looking at your bs posts has pissed me off, so let me tell you. Smith will be the best reciever on the field on saturday night. He has the best stats of any reciever in the postseason of all time. Of course fitz and boldin cant really do much about that since they dont ever get their!!!

Points to tear apart your fitz and boldin stats are better that smith bs:

1. fitz had 10 more yds than smith on the season but smith played two less games he is actually the only THE ONLY reciever to avg over 100 yds a game this season

2. smith also leads the league in yds per catch far exceeding fitz

3. smith gets thrown to way less than fitz considering we are a very run heavy team

4. if their were a clutch catch stat category lol... which theirs not he would lead that too... everyone knows that

5. smith has won a triple crown only third guy to do it ever... when fitz or boldin does that then talk to me

6. your argument that you have three great/good recievers to throw to, which you do, for reasoning why fitz doesnt have more yards just retarted...

WHY YOU ASK? because you pass the ball nearly twice as much as the panthers do and also the panthers do throw the ball to a #2 quite oftern moose had 65 catches and a near 1k recieving season.... so this argument is not one it is just an excuse

IN CONCLUSION: fitz is a great i mean great reciever and so is boldin but until he makes some postseason runs and makes huge clutch catches in divisional and championship games he is not steve smith. Until he wins a triple crown he is not steve smith. until he comes back from near career ending injuries to shine he is not steve smith. It is a good comparison but fitz has a lot of work to do!!!

This is a great fan board and the vast majority of commenters here are intelligent and know their football. Both the Carolina fans and us Cards fans are of couse a bit of homers for our teams and players. But this guy who starts all his comments with "Bro" is the exception to the rule here. You guys should flame him off the board. He's been coming to our board with the most foolish drivel, and is currently a laughing stock. I recognized him by the "bro", and verified the identity by the 3rd grade writing skills and poor arguementation. I'm not going to respond to anything the "bro" writes from here on...he's a waste of space on both our boards.

But Bro, Fitz in 5 years has 5975 yards and 46 TD's. Smith in 8 years has 7348 yards and 43 TD's. Smith has 30 more games that Fitz. Fitz is 4 1/2 years younger than Smith. You use stats from this year for yards/game, but over their carreers Fitz averages 79 yards and Smith averages 69. If in the next three seasons OR the next 30 games he plays in Fitz gets less than 1375 yards and somehow scores -3 TD's, I'll find my way back here an apologize to you.

[cardsfanmd]

hey cardsfan this is not english 101 i am not writing a paper for your class, so *** you pussy. you are a bitch and the only reason you run that ****** mouth is because you know im not around here for me to beat your bitch ass. so you keep grading papers you fine young male. if you wanna do something let me know. are you coming to charlotte this weekend? if so let me know well meet up b it ch

You should really get your picture off the web you little e-gangster.

[OneBadassCat]

This is a great fan board and the vast majority of commenters here are intelligent and know their football. Both the Carolina fans and us Cards fans are of couse a bit of homers for our teams and players. But this guy who starts all his comments with "Bro" is the exception to the rule here. You guys should flame him off the board. He's been coming to our board with the most foolish drivel, and is currently a laughing stock. I recognized him by the "bro", and verified the identity by the 3rd grade writing skills and poor arguementation. I'm not going to respond to anything the "bro" writes from here on...he's a waste of space on both our boards.

But Bro, Fitz in 5 years has 5975 yards and 46 TD's. Smith in 8 years has 7348 yards and 43 TD's. Smith has 30 more games that Fitz. Fitz is 4 1/2 years younger than Smith. You use stats from this year for yards/game, but over their carreers Fitz averages 79 yards and Smith averages 69. If in the next three seasons OR the next 30 games he plays in Fitz gets less than 1375 yards and somehow scores -3 TD's, I'll find my way back here an apologize to you.

Smith came into the league as a punt returner not a WR. He was virtually not existent as a receiving threat his rookie year. Then he broke his leg in 04. Thats 2 years where where the stats are basically invalid.