If Penix is there at 33

[BrisbanePanther]

8 hours ago, Shotgun said:

 

Why not trade Young to that desperate team and take Penix?

I love this idea. Then when Penix also fails here, we can put the spotlight where it belongs: on our woeful franchise's broken front office and philosophy.

[Panther8989]

He will be 24 next season. When have QB's come out that late and truly succeeded? I suppose it's possible. Just risky.

It would be a very risky deal for us. However, what about trading Bryce for Jordan Love? Picks would need to be involved.

 

Edited January 5 by Panther8989

[Carolina Mike]

4 hours ago, CamWhoaaCam said:

So you're blaming his Oline because he's a great QB?

 

Make it make sense!

Go back and look at the games he was getting hit or rushed… it was a big difference. You can see what you want. I’m just giving you my opinion from a perspective of someone who wants UW to win but also the Carolina Panthers too.

[Bear Hands]

On 1/2/2024 at 7:43 AM, Bear Hands said:

Brugler spoke on him on Prospect to Pros some weeks back.  The interest seems lukewarm on the scouting front but some teams do like him.  Personally, I've been a fan and have followed him, but think he's more in the Bo Nix/Cameron Ward tier than JJ McCarthy.  

The arm strength is just good, not great.  The injury history is there.  Age is up there (although that seems to be about every QB these days being 23+).  His accuracy has greatly improved but he still has to work on timed & layered throws.  He's got some gamer in him though and is a fun dude to root for.  

 

Following up on this, there was an updated Prospects to Pros pod and Brugler reiterated a lot of this again.

He no doubt made NFL caliber throws in the semifinal but he still doesn’t throw in the middle of the field sub 20 yarders. Has greatly improved his accuracy but there’s stuff that he simply doesn’t do that are question marks.

I sense him 2nd rounder absolute highest, just don’t see a 1st.

1. Maye

2. Williams

3. Daniels

Tier Drop

4. JJ 

Tier Drop

5. Penix

6. Nix

7. Pratt

8. Ward

-

The rest aren’t meh

(Assuming Ewers returns)

[FuFuLamePoo]

9 hours ago, BrisbanePanther said:

I love this idea. Then when Penix also fails here, we can put the spotlight where it belongs: on our woeful franchise's broken front office and philosophy.

Preach 

[Htarnation4.0]

I believe we really need to take another QB in this draft. Minimally we need the competition.