Bryce Young Cannot Make Basic NFL Throws

[PantherFanInPhilly]

The Bryce supporters remind me of the Cam supporters after it was obvious his shoulder was shot. 

[Soul Rebel]

Mannnnnn, there are gonna be a lot of receipts in a couple of years depending on how this goes. A lot to walk-back and some delicious crow to eat.

Should be interesting.

 

 

[PantherFanInPhilly]

5 minutes ago, Soul Rebel said:

Mannnnnn, there are gonna be a lot of receipts in a couple of years depending on how this goes. A lot to walk-back and some delicious crow to eat.

Should be interesting.

 

 

God, what a fuging delight that would be. I TRULY hope, wish and pray Bryce makes all of his "haters" eat crow.  I pray I'm wrong. 

Edited December 13, 2023 by PantherFanInPhilly

[BenjaminBreeg]

26 minutes ago, PantherFanInPhilly said:

God, what a fuging delight that would be. I TRULY hope, wish and pray Bryce makes all of his "haters" eat crow.  I pray I'm wrong. 

 

32 minutes ago, Soul Rebel said:

Mannnnnn, there are gonna be a lot of receipts in a couple of years depending on how this goes. A lot to walk-back and some delicious crow to eat.

Should be interesting.

 

 

 

If you choose to die on this raggedy little dirt heap, so be it. 

 

 

[frankw]

56 minutes ago, PantherFanInPhilly said:

God, what a fuging delight that would be. I TRULY hope, wish and pray Bryce makes all of his "haters" eat crow.  I pray I'm wrong. 

Right. If my options are to either watch this trade go down in flames as one of the worst in league history or eat crow I'll eat crow 10 times out of 10.

Just to be clear if it were to happen it would be one of the most miraculous turnarounds in league history. So we're right back to praying for him to be an outlier amongst outliers. Might as well hope for a winning lotto ticket while we're at it.

[fanpanther]

I wish someone on here knew some of the players in real life to get their real opinions on him.  Wouldnt want names of players but would be interesting to know if the entire team has the same opinion most fans have of BY

[Mr Mojo Risin]

23 minutes ago, frankw said:

Right. If my options are to either watch this trade go down in flames as one of the worst in league history or eat crow I'll eat crow 10 times out of 10.

Just to be clear if it were to happen it would be one of the most miraculous turnarounds in league history. So we're right back to praying for him to be an outlier amongst outliers. Might as well hope for a winning lotto ticket while we're at it.

Nah. If Bryce does turn it around it will be because of the new HC hire and those around him making him look better than what he truly is, calling it now. At least that's what the fine folks of the Carolina Huddle will say anyway

Edited December 13, 2023 by Mr Mojo Risin

[mrcompletely11]

 

 

The kid is shot mentally.  And he looks like he is around 180 at best.

 

Panther pr please clean this kid up a bit.  It would take 2 hours of relistening to old pressers and working with him.  Its not hard

[Seltzer]

Everyone from Bill Belichick to Bill O'Brien to Nick Saban and a whole litany of NFL guys like Rodgers & multiple NFL coaches have all said this kid can play and was worthy to be #1, but sure, let's give a platform to all these armchair "experts."

Cam getting blasted for having an opinion as a former MVP by people who have never played the sport is a good microcosm of what has happened to this board.  

It's so on the nose it's almost hard to believe.  Perfect timing, and those of us who were here for the Cam Era remember this nonstop nonsense for the most part.  For a lot of people, Cam was never good enough.

2015 was the only year that Cam bashing wasn't a prominent feature here, regardless of the revisionist history.  As good as Cam is and was, I think we would have broken him mentally had he been the rookie QB on this team.  

The fact that Bryce has not been broken physically (and hopefully mentally) by this season is remarkable.  Anyone who thinks otherwise has never played or coached competitve sports IMHO.

And anyone who wants to equate the 2011 cast of Cam Newton, Steve Smith, Greg Olsen, Jordan Gross, Ryan Kalil, Deangelo Williams, Jonathan Stewart, etc. to this 2023 cast of misfits is either stupid or ignorant.

This whole season has been a disaster.  Blaming Bryce is so effing lazy and just factually wrong for the most part.  He's missed some throws, made some incredible ones that weren't caught, and generally been the victim of incredible mismanagement.

He's going to be here next year, hopefully with a competent staff and players.  Trading up was 10000% a mistake, but not b/c of Bryce.  We would be in this same situation with any rookie QB playing in this dysfunction, regardless of what you need to tell yourself.  2015 Cam wouldn't be able to elevate this squad.  There's too much dysfunction across the board, and almost every drop back has multiple offensive lineman losing almost immediately.

I rarely even come here anymore because the trolling and hyperbole are just too much to take.  If y'all hate Bryce that bad, now really is the time to jump ship.

I've watched the NFL my entire life, and the thing that makes a QB good over time is accuracy.  Of all the inane complaints about Bryce, no one ever mentions that b/c it's not grounded in reality.

The truth is that Bryce has made good throws when he's had a clean pocket, which is next to never.  Again, for people who don't understand football or watch film, a good QB can navigate the pocket, maybe even if one guy gets beat.  

But when multiple guys are getting beat, there's little to no separation, and guys are dropping perfect passes... any of you guys standing in that pocket and making "NFL quality throws?"

Which is more likely, that Bryce forgot how to play football after playing it at the highest level in college, or that the multi-year dysfunction of this organization is to blame?

I would like to believe in the collective IQ of this board, but every single time I come here anymore I'm bombarded with these nonsensical threads... please just find another team!!

 

[Basbear]

1 hour ago, fanpanther said:

I wish someone on here knew some of the players in real life to get their real opinions on him.  Wouldnt want names of players but would be interesting to know if the entire team has the same opinion most fans have of BY

Given all the podcasts and x, just a huge pool of ex/player voices.......No one has came out and said" Bcye Young IS TRRRRAAASSSSSH". 

Hell CMC moms got a fuging podcast....

[thunderraiden]

2 hours ago, Soul Rebel said:

Mannnnnn, there are gonna be a lot of receipts in a couple of years depending on how this goes. A lot to walk-back and some delicious crow to eat.

Should be interesting.

 

 

Its wild to me so many people are ready to close the door year 1 on a player that OBVIOUSLY was gonna take more than a year to find out what they got. I was all aboard CJ Stroud at #1 (honestly i was fine with anyone at #3) but that was because CJ could have came in close to his ceiling. Bryce has the mental to be a Brees but even Brees wasnt Brees until Year 4.

[Seltzer]

1 hour ago, fanpanther said:

I wish someone on here knew some of the players in real life to get their real opinions on him.  Wouldnt want names of players but would be interesting to know if the entire team has the same opinion most fans have of BY

Every single player that has ever played with Bryce would give you their opinion, and they're all positive.

Again, what is more likely.... that all these coaches and players that have played the game all say Bryce has what it takes, or the hot-take artist on this board or elsewhere are right?

The hate for this kid is effing unreal...

I'm as big of a Panthers fan as there is, but there's part of me now (just like with Cam) that I just want to see Bryce go elsewhere (hopefully the AFC) and ball out just like everyone else that leaves this dysfunction.

Eventually, even the biggest trolls and haters here will hopefully open their eyes to the fact this franchise is the problem, not the players you so desperately want to blame.  And I don't say this lightly.

There is an infinitely better chance Bryce would be successful in Houston (or anywhere else) than for another QB being more successful here under the current conditions.

Self-delusion is a helluva drug... but I guess in fairness what else does a lot of this fanbase have left... 

Winning is the only solution

[thunderraiden]

1 hour ago, frankw said:

Right. If my options are to either watch this trade go down in flames as one of the worst in league history or eat crow I'll eat crow 10 times out of 10.

Just to be clear if it were to happen it would be one of the most miraculous turnarounds in league history. So we're right back to praying for him to be an outlier amongst outliers. Might as well hope for a winning lotto ticket while we're at it.

Bryce year 1 stats are identical to Brees year 3 stats.. so not that miraculous . 

[frankw]

Comparing him to Cam in any way shape or form is ridiculous. It shouldn't need to be said but I guess that's where we're at.