Onsides rule need to be changed!!!

[Hairless Cat]

Ballsy call-

Saints deserve this win.

[KillerKat]

And you tend to commit back too. You sure you don't have a secret mancrush, but won't admit it here? Beside, I seen you reply back to other many times on the same subject like I do to you so surely they must've like females as well like you said.

I have no idea what the hell you just said. You just quoted me 3 times in 3 different threads. You do it all the time and say the samething over and over again after the subject has already been explained to you. Either you really are so dumb that you can't grasp what Im telling you or you're in love with me. Im not getting into another silly debate with you and Im not giving you my number. So might as well give up.

[Munch4455]

The thing that makes the onsides kick a bullshit call is that any team during any week of the season could do it and make it work. Every team turns and covers kicks, its almost like an unspoken agreement not to do it because it would shaft one team per game. Out of respect for the game teams dont do it, except for the saints who would kick their own mother in the teeth for a win. GJ saints, all stars.

[Scutty]

How can an onside kick be a "bullshit call" when it's in the laws of the game???

That took nads to call that on the games biggest stage and to have it pay off.

This thread wouldn't exsist if it hadn't come off. That much I know. And I'll bet you whatever if the Colts had done it there would be those lauding it as the playcall of the year

[TAZZ]

Must be missing something

Saint's pull off a gutsy onsides kick

Which most teams could do during the season and make it work

Really

If they could make it work every team in the league would do it

Problem is if it does not work,the receving team is in excellent scoring position

THAT was a guttsy call considering MANNING

To say they did it B/C their coach had no faith in SAINT's D

Is also a JOKE

How many points did Manning put on the board the rest of the 2nd half ?

Or did the Saint's defense get the 2nd half off after the onsides ?

[CharlotteBeer.com]

Yeah, those onside kicks are so easy to execute. A team could theoretically never punt the ball away.

[Swarly]

I'm one of the few who think it was a downright stupid play call to go for the onside kick. I don't think it was cheap in any way, because it's just them being tricky and that's apart of football, but you just DON'T risk giving Manning that good field position. If Hank Baskett wasn't an idiot with bad hands, he'd have caught that ball and it'd be colts ball on the Saints 40.

It's basically the bill belichick call against the colts during regular season. Going for it on 4th and short with 2 minutes left and on the colts 40. You get the 1st down, you're a genius- you miss it, and you're a dumbass.

Payton got lucky with that call, but there is no doubting that it took major guts and I give him props for it.

[err456]

Shawn has to have balls to make that call.

The only problem I have is there was a clear shot of a colt lying on the ground

with possession of the ball with a saint's leg touching him but after 20 guys jumped on him the saints come up with it.

It happens all the time.

There was even a saint in plain clothes from the sideline on the field pulling guys out of the pile.

[Darth Biscuit]

Wow, a new low has been reached on the huddle... this thread is a big fail.

The Saints took a calculated risk and it paid off big time... can't blame them for that. Gutsy call.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

Wow, a new low has been reached on the huddle... this thread is a big fail.

This sums up my reaction after reading some of these post-Super Bowl threads.

It's like a Saints Super Bowl win dropped the Huddle's collective IQ about 50 points.

I mean, in just a few hours, we've learned that the game was rigged, the Colts need a new coach, and someone needs to change the rules for onside kicks.

It's funny -- this was the first onside kick not in a Super Bowl's fourth quarter. Somehow I don't think teams were reluctant to kick one in the first three quarters because they are "cheap and easy."

[MadHatter]

As we know the saints will play dirty football anyway they can. That onsides kick by the saints is just another example of how cheap and crappy their team is. I give props to the saints offense. But the special teams and the D of the saints is cheap and easy. I think the league needs to change of the rule to where there can be no onsides kick until 4th quarter. That onside kick just shows you how crappy the saints D is and how Payton does not trust his D one bit Saints does not deserve to win. The rule needs to be changed. Hell why not change the rule. Everytime you turn around a new rule is put in are one is change for some reason are another. Mind aswell make where no team can do onsides until the 4th quarter. Point blank.

One of the dumbest threads I have ever seen in the Huddle....and that is saying alot.

I would have loved to see the Saints lose this game. But, that was not cheap and crappy football. The Saints played a good game in all three aspects of football....they deserved the win.

[Kingpatecu]

I couldn't disagree more. The onside kick is a risk/reward type of move. If they don't cover it the Colts have great field position and could really deflate the Saints. Its not like the Colts didn't have a shot at the ball, Baskett just choked on the recovery.

[Guild]

I think this thread was supposed to be sarcastic.

[TbTeRRoR]

Didn't the Titans do an onsides kickoff on the opening kickoff agaisnt us a few years ago?

They squib kicked and recoverd it in 03' it was our first loss that year- not a traditional squib - a little floater over the first line of the panthers blockers