It’s beyond time to bench Bryce.

[jopie87]

He is by far the worst QB we've had start games since Pickles. Every other QB to start a game in the past 13 years has been better. If he wasn't the number 1 pick he would be on the practice squad right now. He cannot make NFL throws. His team knew it too. If he throws at the combine, he doesn't go 1st. He probably doesn't go top 10.

[Wanderlai]

The Bryce experiment is finished. He will start next year and barring a friggin intervention from God he will be gone in 25. The only reason he has not been benched is because Tepper sold the farm for the #1 pick and is forcing him out there. 

Edited December 4, 2023 by Wanderlai

[jopie87]

Just now, Wanderlai said:

The Bryce experiment is finished. He will start next year and barring a friggin intervention from God he will be gone in 25. 

Draft whoever is there in round 2 and let them see who is the better QB in camp. It won't be Bryce. Don't waste another year.

[Mage]

Why?

Let him guide us to a No. 1 Overall Pick in 2024.  There is no point in benching him for Andy Dalton.  Bryce will either get better or he will continue to doom us.  

[WelshPanther]

I kind of felt a little worried on that Monday night football game in what, game three? But it is now a burning fuging fire for the franchise how bad he is. That lateral in this game was probably the final nail, like a fifth grader out there.

Not even third choice back up level poo

[jopie87]

35 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

The receivers usually had 3-4 yards of separation and the OL gave him time. People talk about Bama being "down" his final year, but a down Bama is still a top 10 college roster. This narrative that Bryce was making chicken salad out of chicken poo at ALA-fuging-BAMA was always absurd.

Turns out it was a down year...because of the QB. If you can't win championships Alabama, you're probably not a great QB.

[CRA]

13 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

If he's not ready it's because he's never gonna be ready. It's not like he was some raw talent upside pick. His draft value was based on being a plug and play super processor while the knock on him was that he might already be at his physical ceiling based on his talent.

I just don't understand how folks can see it elsewhere, but ignore it at Bama. Guys like Stetson Bennett and Jake Fromm are seen for what they are - really good college QBs who probably won't translate to the NFL and are largely products of the surrounding talent and systems. Yet with Bryce folks convinced themselves that this 5'10" noodle arm was making chicken salad out of chicken poo at Alabama like he was playing at ECU or something. GTFO of here. This dude fooled everyone.

Well, he didn't fool me. I took a lot of heat last off-season for warning that this guy has marginal NFL physical talent.

Yeah, people talk about OSU QBs but Bama QBs are basically the same but worse. 

[Wanderlai]

7 minutes ago, Mage said:

Why?

Let him guide us to a No. 1 Overall Pick in 2024.  There is no point in benching him for Andy Dalton.  Bryce will either get better or he will continue to doom us.  

I can see it shaking down like this. Bryce sucks next year…gets yanked at the halfway mark when we should continue the suck for a new QB…vet QB wins enough games to put us out of the top pick …lol…Panthers 

Edited December 4, 2023 by Wanderlai

[Johnstonny]

2 hours ago, hepcat said:

We have seen enough. Whatever the reason, the roster isn’t good enough, the coaching and scheme are terrible, or Bryce himself is just not any good or too small for the NFL game, enough it’s enough. How many crap performances can a QB turn in, get a head coach fired, and continue to start games? This is insanity. 

how many times do you have to try to fit the square peg in the round hole before you change any fugging thing...

[Hoenheim]

I'm sick of watching him 

[Panther53521]

Just please don’t have some mistake that he will be remembered for … like the butt fumble

[45catfan]

2 hours ago, hepcat said:

We have seen enough. Whatever the reason, the roster isn’t good enough, the coaching and scheme are terrible, or Bryce himself is just not any good or too small for the NFL game, enough it’s enough. How many crap performances can a QB turn in, get a head coach fired, and continue to start games? This is insanity. 

Why?  The season is wrapped, so at this point he's either going to get better or collapse.  If he folds, we need to take a QB at #33 in April and not waste another season on this dude.

Edited December 4, 2023 by 45catfan

[CRA]

3 minutes ago, jopie87 said:

Turns out it was a down year...because of the QB. If you can't win championships Alabama, you're probably not a great QB.

I mean, if you get 2 years at Bama….and you don’t win? It’s pretty much a QB issue.  Because it doesn’t even take great talent to win at Bama. 

[*FreeFua*]

3 minutes ago, Hoenheim said:

I'm sick of watching him 

I’m at that point too 

Its all so bad but so is he