CMC Trade, et all

[BY9Franchise]

21 minutes ago, Shocker said:

There were many Huddlers that wanted to trade CMC but how Fitty keeps his job after that trade I have no idea.  CMC could possibly make the Hall of Fame and we got literally nothing to show for it.  Fitty can’t possibly be here going forward right?

Pretty much the entire huddle wanted CMC gone because "overpaid running back" "lost a step" and various other idiotic takes.....

 

The best of which was the "injury prone" nah bro they were intentionally limiting the wear and tear during lost seasons he would have played all but 2-3 of those if the panthers had been in contention... just like Cam with the Patriots I can't root for him hate the fugging nines. Wish he went to the Bills

[BY9Franchise]

18 minutes ago, FugginPoo said:

CMC sucked his last two years here, we literally improved greatly when he left last year.  He’s great in the right system, he’s not an MVP or anything crazy like that

Lol he didn't suck they kept him sidelined to limit wear during lost campaigns 

[Shocker]

10 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

It certainly was based on what we turned the haul into. The 2nd was a minor part of the trade for #1 for Bryce. The 3rd and 4th we turned into DJ Johnson via trade up. We still have a 5th next year. That better be a Sam Howell level 5th rounder.

No…there is absolutely nothing about trading CMC for anything that did not include multiple firsts wasn’t a wrong move.  The salary cap doesn’t matter when you have a superstar player like him,  I disagree completely 

Edited November 28, 2023 by Shocker

[frankw]

Not losing sleep over McCaffrey. We don't have the 49ers offensive line or a coach like Kyle Shanahan.

The bigger blunder is trading a top 10 WR in his prime by the name of DJ Moore.

[frankw]

Do you own a 49ers McCaffrey jersey?

[BY9Franchise]

7 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

It certainly was based on what we turned the haul into. The 2nd was a minor part of the trade for #1 for Bryce. The 3rd and 4th we turned into DJ Johnson via trade up. We still have a 5th next year. That better be a Sam Howell level 5th rounder.

I'd kill for Sam Howell he's what Baker Mayfield was supposed to be (a gunslinger) 

[BY9Franchise]

1 minute ago, frankw said:

Not losing sleep over McCaffrey. We don't have the 49ers offensive line or a coach like Kyle Shanahan.

The bigger blunder is trading a top 10 WR in his prime by the name of DJ Moore.

Bet if we search back to trade say you were all for it.

[Shocker]

8 minutes ago, tukafan21 said:

Exactly, I was always against trading CMC because his injuries were just bad luck things (like when the guy rolled up on his ankle as he was going into the end zone and gave him the high ankle sprain) and not a bunch of non contact injuries that pile up year after year (like Horn).  Plus, he 100% could have and would have played at the end of both seasons if we were in even the slightest contention, so he missed more games than necessary because there was no point in throwing him back out there to risk injury or hurting draft position in a lost season.

But even if we were to trade him, we get a TERRIBLE package in return.

I understand how the chart works and how all the picks added up to a first round value, but that's basically like saying you're good taking 100 $1 items and hoping you can sell every single one for the dollar and make the same $100 that you could have gotten in return from 1 item.

Trading CMC for anything less than a first, let alone a late 2nd rounder being the best pick in the trade, was beyond atrocious

It was clear when they did it…this isn’t 20/20 talk.  That was always a ridiculous trade by ridiculous people 

[LinvilleGorge]

4 minutes ago, Shocker said:

No…there is absolutely nothing about trading CMC for anything that did not include multiple firsts was a wrong move.  The salary cap doesn’t matter when you have a superstar player like him,  I disagree completely 

I honestly wouldn't be surprised if he wasn't lobbying to GTFO of here. He and the team say he wasn't but all the sitting out with relatively minor nagging injuries and then getting traded for not a great return to a contender and then suddenly getting a lot more durable (like I predicted)? It all just adds up to feeling like he forced his way out of here.

For the record, I was 100% onboard with trading CMC. We needed a QB and we needed draft capital. We just fuged it up like we have everything else under Tepper.

[pantherj]

CMC was basically the best thing about watching the Panthers play. The soul sucking vortex of doom and apathy the was Sam Darnold w could be somewhat counteracted by CMC. I was all for trading CMC with the idea that we had a clear plan in place and had a great QB in mind to draft. Instead we drafted a tiny QB who is a long shot to make it in the NFL (any tiny QB is a long shot), and we have no plan in place whatsoever. We're just tossing players out there and whatever happens, happens. No vision. No nothing. We're lucky to have won one game. If THAT is what we're doing, then I'd rather have kept CMC and just focused on enjoying his running on Sundays. Now I have nothing to enjoy.

[frankw]

Just now, BY9Franchise said:

Bet if we search back to trade say you were all for it.

@TrevorLaurenceTime22 you swore off this team and this board when we traded CMC you are welcome to see yourself right back on out the door

[frankw]

1 minute ago, LinvilleGorge said:

I honestly wouldn't be surprised is he wasn't lobbying to GTFO of here.

His mom basically said so in an interview post trade. They wanted him on the west coast. Is it a coincidence suddenly he's not perpetually banged up anymore?

[BY9Franchise]

1 minute ago, frankw said:

@TrevorLaurenceTime22 you swore off this team and this board when we traded CMC you are welcome to see yourself right back on out the door

Chuck you are doubly incorrect.... 

*going to find your trade with Chicago posts*

[tukafan21]

5 minutes ago, frankw said:

His mom basically said so in an interview post trade. They wanted him on the west coast. Is it a coincidence suddenly he's not perpetually banged up anymore?

He was never perpetually banged up, 2 years in a row of getting hurt for a few weeks and then being shelved because you're a star player on a team already eliminated from the playoffs doesn't equate to being "perpetually banged up"

Again, the first year injury was a player falling on his ankle while trying to tackle him as he dragged the guy into the end zone and he got a high ankle from it.  I don't remember the injury the second year off the top of my head, but even if it was a non contact muscle pull, that would make it one time in his career, not an ongoing thing like it is with Horn or other actually injury prone players.

He's played in every game of the season in 5 of his 7 seasons in the league, but sure, he's perpetually banged up

Edited November 28, 2023 by tukafan21