is Troy Aikman overrated? in your Top 10 (who is?)

[Dpantherman]

I know some of you might think im nuts, but Im not saying hes a scrub or anything like that. but when we are talking greatest QBs of all time. where does he rank. I have to think about my top 10 for a while.

[PhillyB]

i thought you were deleting your profile

[Dpantherman]

i thought you were deleting your profile

i was being a smart ass. pretty dumb huh?

[PhillyB]

i was being a smart ass. pretty dumb huh?

little bit

[Dpantherman]

little bit

alot....

anyway here's my top 10. its probably out of whack I'll keep updating as I hear suggestions:

1. Joe Montanna

2. Johnny Unitas

3. Steve Young

4. Peyton Manning

5. Tom Brady

6. John Elway

7. Dan Marino

8. Dan Fouts

9. Kurt Warner

10. Jim Kelly

[tommy gun]

nah, i don't think aikman was over rated. he was a really good qb on a really good team. being a giants fan i always hated the cowboys. but i always give credit where credit is due. he was very accurate and i would have loved to have him in ny. i don't know if he is top 10, but top 15 for sure.

[pantherfan82]

cant put aikman in top ten. i can think of at least 10 that are better

[Claws]

I got Aikman in my top 5

[Mage]

Depends.

Anybody who has him in their top ten, yes he is overrated. If their reasoning is because he won a lot of Super Bowls, a team accomplishment, yes he is overrated. But people who say he absolutely sucks and everything, then he is underrated.

[OneBadassCat]

If he wears the star then he's overrated.

[PanthersFanInGA]

alot....

anyway here's my top 10. its probably out of whack:

1. Joe Montanna

2. Johnny Unitas

3. Steve Young

4. Dan Marino

5. John Elway

6. Peyton Manning

7. Tom Brady

8. Dan Fouts

9. Kurt Warner

10. Jim Kelly

I always hated Troy Aikman along with his Dallas Cowboys. I don't see Kurt Warner as a top 10 QB. I'd put Brett Favre in there over him.

[PanthersFanInGA]

Peyton Manning at the top. No telling what this guys numbers are gonna look like by the time he retires. He's my number 1 by far.

[Dpantherman]

Peyton Manning at the top. No telling what this guys numbers are gonna look like by the time he retires. He's my number 1 by far.

there is no doubt in my mind he'll be 1 when hes over. im doing as it stands right now. i can't put him up there yet. he moves up a couple if he has a big day sunday

[csx]

I'm curious what logic you used to put Steve Young over Payton Manning.