is there any doubt that peyton manning is the goat now?

[John Fox]

he wins the super bowl... there is no argument

[MVP23]

...I would still rather have Brady..

[Stickman2]

Mattt Montana anyone

[Miaoww]

Was there before?

[Davidson Deac II]

The Goat? I thought being the Goat was a bad thing. As in the one who gets blamed for a loss.

[Jangler]

Manning is Buffalo Bill?

[rico6]

No doubt, and he still looks like he can go for 4-5 more years.

[SorthNarolina]

Yeah he's pretty close, it's pretty hard to name a GOAT. It's more the Greatest of his Era/Generation.

Brady is pretty good but manning is just better in everyway. Yeah he struggled early in big games but Brady hasn't really been that great lately.

I think Brady rides on the genius of Belichik while Dungy/Caldwell ride on the genius of manning.

[capfolly]

The Goat? I thought being the Goat was a bad thing. As in the one who gets blamed for a loss.

I think it stands for greatest of all time.

[Jangler]

1. the goat

The act of a man tucking his wang and sack between his legs and bending over so that it can be seen from behind resembling the head of a goat.

- Sometimes used in the *** Game or the Nut Game.

Tim is well endowed, he was able to pull off the goat!

[Davidson Deac II]

I think it stands for greatest of all time.

Well, if thats the case, then I will take Montana.

[charlotte49er]

Well, if thats the case, then I will take Montana.

All time, I have to go with Montana as well!

But for the last few years, I have to go with Peyton. If it weren't for Bilichek/Brady then who knows. The 2004 Colts team was the best team, except them ran into the Patriots in Foxboro.

Here's a scarey thought. Eli may actually eclipse his older Brother!

[Miaoww]

Eli's not on the same level as Payton.

[thejimmy]

Not even in the same solar system.