Rank the players

[Ricky Spanish]

Matt Moore

Matt Moore

Matt Moore

so on

so forth...

Just kidding, they'd pick jake over and over again, he'd give them the best chance to win...

[Ricky Spanish]

But my real list:

Peppers

Smith

Beason

Gross

Williams

Davis

Kalil

Stewart

Otah

Gamble

[Kakarot]

1. Peppers

2. Beason

3. Smith

4. Stewart

5. Williams

6. Gross

7. Davis

8. Otah

9. Gamble

10. Wharton

[Pimpdaddy]

He's worth every penny...

Ask any GM in the league... Pep on his worst day is better than most star DEs on their best...

It isn't about sacks and stats... It's about the attention he receives and the ability he has to make other plays both in pursuit and in coverage...

...yea, right, yea right babe...thats why we still have him...because everybody thinks he's great...

[Saint J]

1.) Beason

2.) Kalil

3.) Davis

4.) Gross

5) Williams

6.) Wharton

7.) Smith

8.) Otah

9.) Peppers

10.) Gamble

[ZedLeppelin]

1. Peppers (pass rush, some coach would probably think they could turn him into LT)

2. Gross (All pro LT, would probably be #1 if not for injury)

3. Smith (elite game breaker WR)

4. Beason (all pro MLB but I don't think he has quite the game breaker impact the guys above him have, would be #1 on a lot of teams)

5. Williams (elite RB but RB is probably the last position teams would fill there are lots of options at RB)

6. Gamble (I think hes viewed as a top 10 CB around the league, I would probably choose him 9th if I was GM)

7. Stewart (very good young RB with a very high ceiling but teams would probably question if he could carry the load all season)

8. Davis (If he didn't get hurt he would probably be #6)

9. Otah (good young OT)

10. Wharton (versatile OL)

[CarolinaPanthers8789]

No one has kemo in the top ten???

[nosuchthingasapanther]

No one has kemo in the top ten???

kemo isn't the only one missing.

imo, it's tough to rank the list by player, but it would definitely be dominated by olinemen first then defensive players. RBs, WRs, and QBs would fall in behind them in that order, but not in the top 10.

[rico6]

Now.

1. Beason

2. Williams

3. Gross

4.Wharton

5. Otah

6.Peppers

7.Davis

8.Gamble

9. Smith

10.Matt

Smith so low because of his obvious age, and expected decline, Matt because of his sudden burst unto the scene.

[Wither]

Matt wouldn't be on that list and as a side note, the Panthers don't have that many bad players, hence why it's hard to rank them.