Rank the players

[Matt Foley]

Rank the top 10 Panthers players that you think would go first if the League made everybody a free agent and GMs got to choose in one big roto draft. Factor in age, motor, productivity, salary, everything...

1. Beason

2. Williams

3. Smith

4. Stewart

5. Gross

6. Otah

7. Kalil

8. Gamble

9. Davis

10. Peppers

[CharlotteBeer.com]

1. Beason

2. Gross

3. Williams

4. Smith

5. Stewart

6. Peppers

7. Otah

8. Davis

9. Brown

10. Gamble

[Matt Foley]

1. Beason

2. Gross

3. Williams

4. Smith

5. Stewart

6. Peppers

7. Otah

8. Davis

9. Brown

10. Gamble

Pretty close to mine. I would argue that Ryan Kalil is one of the top five centers in the game.

[Sloth]

1. Beason

2. Williams

3. Smith

4. Gross

5. Davis

6. Stewart

7. Peppers

8. Otah

9. Kalil

10. Wharton

[Mekeritrig]

1. Peppers

2. Beason

3. Williams

4. Smith

5. Gamble

6. Gross

7. Kalil

8. Davis

9. Stewart

10. Wharton

Getting your pass rush on in is the trendy thing to do in the NFL these days, so I'd say Peppers would go first. other than that, Offensive Lineman are always in big demand, with some skill position players mixed in.

[Samuel L. Jackson]

1. Peppers

2. Beason

3. Stewart

4. Williams

5. Smith

6. Davis

7. Otah

8. Gross

9. Gamble

10. Harris

[unicar15]

1. Beason

2. Williams

3. Gross

4. Pep

5. Smith

6. Stewart

7. Gamble

8. Otah

9. Davis

10. Wharton

[OneBadassCat]

1. Steve Smith

2. Beason

3. Peppers

4. Kalil

5. Deangelo

6. Thomas Davis

7. Gross

8. Gamble

9. Dante Rosario

10. Toss up between Matt Moore and T. Wharton. Got have a QB some time fellas.

[Matt Foley]

I ranked Pep 10th because of his salary.

[o803oVaDeR]

1. Williams

2. Smith

3. Beason

4. Peppers

5. Gross

6. Stewart

7. Davis

8. Wharton

9. Gamble

10. Otah

There is no way if there was a draft of all NFL players anyone on Carolina would be picked before Williams.

[Samuel L. Jackson]

It was hard for me to pick between Stewart and DeAngelo for spot #3... Stewart got the nod because of his youth (youngest guy on the team if you didn't know, even younger than our rooks this year) and his ability being at worst equal to DWill...

That said, if you were the GM that selected Stewart, you would do so knowing his punishing style will considerably shorten his career compared to DWill's style...

Stewart has emerged this season as one of my most favorite Panthers of all time... He's humble, doesn't mind sharing the load or being second string, and runs with a fire at least 3/4 of the starting RBs in the league don't have...

[Samuel L. Jackson]

I ranked Pep 10th because of his salary.

He's worth every penny...

Ask any GM in the league... Pep on his worst day is better than most star DEs on their best...

It isn't about sacks and stats... It's about the attention he receives and the ability he has to make other plays both in pursuit and in coverage...

[Lout]

1. Peppers

2. Gross

3. Smith

4. Beason

5. Williams

6. Gamble

7. Davis

8. Otah

9. Stewart

10. Wharton

Peppers is highly thought of around the league, and the most freakishly athletic player in the league. Tons of head coaches will think they can motivate him to peak potential.

With the exception of this year, Gross has been an iron man of sorts. He is a rare bookend who will anchor the line for the next 7 years.

[Squirrel]

1. Beason

2. Smith

3. Otah

4. Gross

5. Kalil

6. Gamble

7. Davis

8. Stewart

9. Williams

10. Peppers

With a great oline you dont have to worry to much about rb as long as they hold onto the ball. Even though I both and Stewart is a very nice bruiser.