Writers picking sides in QB debate

[Fiz]

it's okay we're raising it catholic

[Saint J]

lol

[Udogg]

its gantt's constant nut hugging of fox and jake along with his smug attitude that makes him an idiot. He acts as though everyone else is stupid and that his opinion is the best. Stating an opinion is fine. But doing it while pissing on everyone else's opinion is what i got a problem with.

rofl

[Jangler]

i also love how he uses QB rating for his argument (as we all know is useless and a pointless rating). he's essentially saying jake is up there with Joe Montana, Steve Young, Peyton Manning etc.

No poo the QB rating is usless. look at these stats...

23att 26comp 88.5% 267yds 10.3avg 4td 0int 0sck 0sckyrds qbr149.0

149.0??? How, with those stats is that not a perfect QB rating???

:out: BS

BTW, Brady last week against the Jacksonville.

[jramsey4]

No poo the QB rating is usless. look at these stats...

23att 26comp 88.5% 267yds 10.3avg 4td 0int 0sck 0sckyrds qbr149.0

149.0??? How, with those stats is that not a perfect QB rating???

:out: BS

BTW, Brady last week against the Jacksonville.

If you got those stats on Madden you would get a 158.3 (highest). Weird? Would think they had the same calculation method.

[Matt Foley]

I hope my Rams get Jake. He's been David Carred in Carolina at this point. Get him a fresh start and his best qualities (leadership, poise) would do wonders for St. Louis.

[jramsey4]

I hope my Rams get Jake. He's been David Carred in Carolina at this point. Get him a fresh start and his best qualities (leadership, poise) would do wonders for St. Louis.

HAHAHAHAH.......oh wait are you serious?

[Matt Foley]

HAHAHAHAH.......oh wait are you serious?

Yes I am. Very serious. When a quarterback gets bludgeoned the way Jake has the past 12 months, it's almost impossible for him to get his mojo back in that city. History is lined with quarterbacks who were run out of one town only to get it back in the next. Jim Plunkett won two Super Bowls with Oakland. Kerry Collins went to a Super Bowl in New York, then led the Titans to the best record in the League last year. Jake just needs a new team and he'll be fine. Not saying his best years are ahead of him, but he could lead the Rams to the playoffs with the talent they are assembling.

[Zod]

Meat has a history with Jake that clouds his reason.

Meat is John Fox.

[jramsey4]

Yes I am. Very serious. When a quarterback gets bludgeoned the way Jake has the past 12 months, it's almost impossible for him to get his mojo back in that city. History is lined with quarterbacks who were run out of one town only to get it back in the next. Jim Plunkett won two Super Bowls with Oakland. Kerry Collins went to a Super Bowl in New York, then led the Titans to the best record in the League last year. Jake just needs a new team and he'll be fine. Not saying his best years are ahead of him, but he could lead the Rams to the playoffs with the talent they are assembling.

The team that he has been so called "bludgeoned" on is now, minus Williams, Otah, and Gross (three of the best in the league at there positions) has produced two back to back 3 tds 0 ints performances against 2 good D's.

So in other words you can have him.

[Matt Foley]

The team that he has been so called "bludgeoned" on is now, minus Williams, Otah, and Gross (three of the best in the league at there positions) has produced two back to back 3 tds 0 ints performances against 2 good D's.

So in other words you can have him.

I'm not disagreeing with your first paragraph. Jake in Carolina doesn't work any more. Similarly, Jim Plunkett was trash his last year in New England.

With Jake, you're not talking about Jeff George, physically gifted but nothing upstairs. You're talking about a natural leader. Get him away from a situation where one interception has the stadium booing him and his confidence will come back.

[Zod]

With Jake, you're not talking about Jeff George, physically gifted but nothing upstairs. You're talking about a natural leader. Get him away from a situation where one interception has the stadium booing him and his confidence will come back.

Any team that signs Jake is going to catch much hell from the fans of that team.

He will be booed on his first INT anywhere, because they know whats coming next... another INT.

[Matt Foley]

Any team that signs Jake is going to catch much hell from the fans of that team.

He will be booed on his first INT anywhere, because they know whats coming next... another INT.

Nah. Panthers fans accepted David Carr at first.

[jramsey4]

I'm not disagreeing with your first paragraph. Jake in Carolina doesn't work any more. Similarly, Jim Plunkett was trash his last year in New England.

With Jake, you're not talking about Jeff George, physically gifted but nothing upstairs. You're talking about a natural leader. Get him away from a situation where one interception has the stadium booing him and his confidence will come back.

Good luck with that then.

BTW who other then Jackson and Avery is even on the rams O. I can't name a single starter. So with a more porous Oline and same if not less receiver talent you expect to him to succeed where here he failed.