Panthers trying to trade Corral?

[PootieNunu]

Damn some of you guys act like Howell is already a proven starter. He has started one real NFL game and passed for less than 200 yards. MoRon is more than likely going to stink it up again and will be fired after their upcoming abysmal season. 

[shaqattaq]

I had an epiphany in the shower and wasn't sure where to post it. I didn't want to start a new thread or hijack 1 of the cut threads. It's so simple that I cannot believe that another huddle GM hasn't come up with yet, we can solve our QB3 and our power back in 1 glorious move! Since he'd be qb3, he wouldn't count in our 46 gameday limit, AND he's already said that he would back up Young. It's a win, win, win! Bringing him back for the 3rd time could be the charm!

[Jon Snow]

16 minutes ago, shaqattaq said:

I had an epiphany in the shower and wasn't sure where to post it. I didn't want to start a new thread or hijack 1 of the cut threads. It's so simple that I cannot believe that another huddle GM hasn't come up with yet, we can solve our QB3 and our power back in 1 glorious move! Since he'd be qb3, he wouldn't count in our 46 gameday limit, AND he's already said that he would back up Young. It's a win, win, win! Bringing him back for the 3rd time could be the charm!

[shaqattaq]

24 minutes ago, Jon Snow said:

[CRA]

Send him to NE for. 7th.  They just cut all their QBs

[Mr. Scot]

2 minutes ago, CRA said:

Send him to NE for. 7th.  They just cut all their QBs

Brought up that possibility in another thread.

You'd have to think O'Brien would be at least somewhat familiar with him from his time as Alabama OC.

[tukafan21]

9 minutes ago, CRA said:

Send him to NE for. 7th.  They just cut all their QBs

In no world is a 7th rounder worth giving up on Corral at this point.

He's not really tradable for me right now, if Lance is getting a 4th round pick in return, there isn't anything someone is going to be willing to give us for Corral right now that will make it worth giving up on him already.

He's far more valuable to us to be our scout team QB than a 7th round pick is to us.

I might take a 4th for him (which nobody is giving for him anyways), but anything 5th or later and I just think it's worth hanging onto him for now.

Edited August 29, 2023 by tukafan21

[CRA]

14 minutes ago, tukafan21 said:

In no world is a 7th rounder worth giving up on Corral at this point.

He's not really tradable for me right now, if Lance is getting a 4th round pick in return, there isn't anything someone is going to be willing to give us for Corral right now that will make it worth giving up on him already.

He's far more valuable to us to be our scout team QB than a 7th round pick is to us.

I might take a 4th for him (which nobody is giving for him anyways), but anything 5th or later and I just think it's worth hanging onto him for now.

if you were considering him and liked him for a 3rd/4th ish in 2022…..why wouldn’t he be worth a 7th to you today?   He is essentially a developmental rookie QB with a preseason to his name.  

I would assume Corral politely wants out of here.  And I factor that in.  There is nothing for Corral here.  All sides see that.  Corral is too young to be content being present day Andy Dalton for the next decade for us and holding a clipboard. 

[tukafan21]

8 minutes ago, CRA said:

if you were considering him and liked him for a 3rd/4th ish in 2022…..why wouldn’t he be worth a 7th to you today?  

I would assume Corral politely wants out of here.  And I factor that in.  There is nothing for Corral here.  All sides see that.  Corral is too young to be content being present day Andy Dalton for the next decade for us and holding a clipboard. 

I actually didn't like trading away the picks we did to draft him last year.

But since we did and he's now on our team, I think he's more valuable to us as the scout team QB to help prepare out defense each week than a future 7th round pick would be.  He's got to be better than the scout team QB on any other team right now, plus he has mobility that can help our defense prepare for any mobile QB's we'll be facing this year.

[Wundrbread33]

14 minutes ago, CRA said:

if you were considering him and liked him for a 3rd/4th ish in 2022…..why wouldn’t he be worth a 7th to you today?   He is essentially a developmental rookie QB with a preseason to his name.  

I would assume Corral politely wants out of here.  And I factor that in.  There is nothing for Corral here.  All sides see that.  Corral is too young to be content being present day Andy Dalton for the next decade for us and holding a clipboard. 

The poster thinks he’s worth more than what we could get in trade right now. 

 

I’m sure you are correct that a team would give a 7th for him, but the poster doesn’t think that’s enough. 

[tukafan21]

I'm also not convinced Dalton has anything left in the tank after what we've seen from him in camp videos and in the preseason game he played.

He's here as a mentor to Bryce, if he ever needs to step on the field, we're screwed.

Wouldn't shock me if he's only here this one season in the end, and if that's the case, Corral on his rookie contract might make more sense as our backup next year than paying a few million for a more legitimate backup.

I also think there is a distinct possibility that by the end of this season, Corral ends up as the #2 on game days with Dalton designated as the 3rd string emergency QB.  I think Dalton is going to be worth every penny we're paying him just to be the mentor for Bryce off the field, but from what I've seen from him in camp, he looks completely washed up as an actual QB on the field.

[CRA]

6 minutes ago, Wundrbread33 said:

The poster thinks he’s worth more than what we could get in trade right now. 

 

I’m sure you are correct that a team would give a 7th for him, but the poster doesn’t think that’s enough. 

Well, the entire league knows we got a young QB that doesn’t want to be here.  And doesn’t fit in with where we are as a franchise. 

that drives his value down.   League negotiates knowing all that. 

Trey Lance once went for a billion dollars and could now be had for a dirty nickel.  Life moves fast in the NFL.  And he essentially is not much different at either price tag. 

[Mr. Scot]

I'd happily take a 6th or a 7th for Corral.

If we got more than that, I'd be thrilled.

[tukafan21]

10 minutes ago, CRA said:

Well, the entire league knows we got a young QB that doesn’t want to be here.  And doesn’t fit in with where we are as a franchise. 

that drives his value down.   League negotiates knowing all that. 

Trey Lance once went for a billion dollars and could now be had for a dirty nickel.  Life moves fast in the NFL.  And he essentially is not much different at either price tag. 

I don't think that's at all remotely true.  I think Corral absolutely wants to stay in Carolina, and frankly, he should.

First, he's not going to be given a starting job anywhere this year, at best he could hope to be the #2 for someone (and as I just said, I think before the end of this season, he'll be our #2 on game days anyways).

Second, since he isn't going to start anywhere, his main focus for this season should be on improving his game, and there probably isn't a clear cut better staff in the league right now for him to do that.  To work with the staff we put together for Bryce's development, might be the best situation in the league for him as well.

Third, no matter what you thought about Bryce pre-draft, there is no denying that his size is a legitimate concern for durability in this league.  If I know I'm currently a backup QB in this league, being on a team with a starting QB of Bryce's size would be something I'd want.

Him being the current #3 as opposed to #2 is about the only reason he might want out of Carolina at this moment, but beyond that, I think he has ever reason to want to stay here for this season.