Delhomme will be starting next week!!!!

[Mesmer]

They are both awful. This argument seems pointless now. We don't have an option at QB that gives us a very good chance to win, thus we are below par.

[panthers55]

They are both awful. This argument seems pointless now. We don't have an option at QB that gives us a very good chance to win, thus we are below par.

But the choice remains we have to pick one for the next 3 games so who do you choose and why??

[CharlotteBeer.com]

The defense has only played decently for one game that Jake has started? Even if that were true (it's not), maybe there's a correlation there. It's a novel concept, but maybe the defense plays better when it's not constantly on the field?

[MadHatter]

But the choice remains we have to pick one for the next 3 games so who do you choose and why??

Easy....Moore shoudl start. Season is over and the only possible upside over the next 3 games is to get a better read on Moore's possible future. Even if Jake plays well, what do we get....a slightly better shitty record.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

Moore was handed that game and had to do very little to win it.

Which of the four games the Panthers won under Jake would you say he contributed largely to the win?

Maybe the Atlanta win, but that's all I'd give him.

[KillerKat]

Moore was handed that game and had to do very little to win it.

That is such utter bullsh*t because you would never say anything like that about Delhomme. And if someone else did, you would always try to spew your nonsense on to them.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

That is such utter bullsh*t because you would never say anything like that about Delhomme. And if someone else did, you would always try to spew your nonsense on to them.

Delhomme was essentially handed the Buffalo game. What did he do? He handed it right back. Four times.

[Neylus]

Can John Fox be fired today please.

[KillerKat]

Delhomme was essentially handed the Buffalo game. What did he do? He handed it right back. Four times.

sorry, i quoted someone else and didn't erase the whole user's name lol

[AceMan]

Delhomme was essentially handed the Buffalo game. What did he do? He handed it right back. Four times.

Delhomme is a very generous man

[mav1234]

-We had several of great defensive performances in games Jake played in. Look over the numbers - Jake generated more points for opposing defenses than our defense gave up alone in half the games it seemed like. Even if that is not LITERALLY true, our defense held teams consistently, and set Jake up very well, but he would just toss the ball to the opponents - over and over. All you have to do is compare the turnovers this team has had under Moore to under Delhomme.

-Moore is still a young starter. I did not see him looking "lost," but I did see some chemistry/communication issues. I also saw him making deep throws (albeit not very pretty ones:() more accurately than we have seen Jake do this season.

-Moore does not lose games for the Panthers - or hasn't yet. Unfortunately, he has yet to win them, either. =|

-Moore has tremendous upside. We do not know all of what he can do yet. We have had glimpses but judging him outright is premature.

These are the primary reasons I'd go with Moore. He was not terrible in either of his two games. He was not great, no, but not terrible. We're not fighting for the playoffs anymore... wins are important, but Jake has not shown he CAN win.

Start Moore for the rest of the season. Worse that happens is we lose 3 games... best that happens is we know what we have with him one way or the other...

EDIT: The Panthers had the game where they wanted it until the roughing the kicker penalty, too... I honestly think if that hadn't happened this game would have ended up tied again... but I'm also an eternal optimist.

[CharlotteBeer.com]

sorry, i quoted someone else and didn't erase the whole user's name lol

Nah, I was agreeing with you. Everything the critics say about Moore could be applied to Delhomme ten-fold. It's laughable that people are cherry-picking games to try to paint Delhomme as a better option.

Moore's played two games, and we've got three more meaningless games to go (I know we're not officially out, but c'mon man). Let him play them.

[KillerKat]

Nah, I was agree with you. Everything the critics say about Moore could be applied to Delhomme ten-fold. It's laughable that people are cherry-picking games to try to paint Delhomme as a better option.

Moore's played two games, and we've got three more meaningless games to go (I know we're not officially out, but c'mon man). Let him play them.

Yeah, saw what you were saying, just thought I should point that out

Yeah it's amazing to me that those that have defended Delhomme to no end are now being unfair to Moore and are still blind to the fact that Delhomme is finished. He is not bouncing back. He is not going to return to form. He is done.

[CRA]

How was Tampa improved with 5 Ints and a fumble for 6 turnovers and a passer rating of 36 for Freeman versus I int and a passer rating of 67.5 the first time with Johnson.

did you watch football? Tampa was a better team when we faced them the 2nd time. That is why they shredded the defense this time.....we got lucky bending so much and getting all those redzone picks. Jake gave them some offense in that last game. Moore gave them nothing.

but if you want to be bias call them the same level of horrible in both matchups....I am fine with that. Moore still played better than Jake against the one common opponent.