Ranking the NFCS Rosters

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

11 minutes ago, CamWhoaaCam said:

Who is underrating Atlanta's roster?

 

They have been getting praise all offseason for their moves and draft. Their only weakness is QB. They literally have the skill positions on offense. They improved that defense tremendously.

This article says its worse than New Orleans lol

[Varking]

26 minutes ago, CamWhoaaCam said:

Who is underrating Atlanta's roster?

 

They have been getting praise all offseason for their moves and draft. Their only weakness is QB. They literally have the skill positions on offense. They improved that defense tremendously.

The article linked at the beginning of the thread. 

[ForJimmy]

39 minutes ago, Sean Payton's Vicodin said:

I think Atlantas roster is heavily underrated. If their QB is halfway decent (big ask), they won't compete with the 49ers or Eagles but they will be in that 2nd tier of NFC teams with the Giants, Seahawks etc.

Tampa and NO rosters are old and bad.

Atlanta has some great skill players, but how are they in the trenches? The OL and run defense was pretty bad last year. They do have the 2nd best coaching staff IMO outside of us.

[Gerry Green]

9 minutes ago, Varking said:

The article linked at the beginning of the thread. 

 

I mean to be fair, that was 2 whole pages ago. lol

Edited May 10, 2023 by Gerry Green

[CamWhoaaCam]

43 minutes ago, Sean Payton's Vicodin said:

This article says its worse than New Orleans lol

Shame on me for only reading the title.smh

 

[Stuart Smith]

2 hours ago, Smithers said:

I don’t agree.  Tampa’s O-line is trash.  They lost their top RB.  Their pass rush is below average.  And they have the worst QB in the division.

Any team with Vita Vea on the defensive line is formidable. 

[Davidson Deac II]

2 hours ago, Harbingers said:

You said we need a competent QB. Then you doubled down with Dalton. Young is a competent QB. He meets all of the criteria of the statement. He has everything needed to have success himself. 

He is a competent college qb.  We won't know how good of an NFL qb he is until he starts playing.  

[Varking]

3 minutes ago, Davidson Deac II said:

He is a competent college qb.  We won't know how good of an NFL qb he is until he starts playing.  

We knew Trevor was a competent QB…. In college. Year one in the NFL did not make him look competent. Let’s not crown guys before a single pro snap. Everyone is pooing a dude here who had a sane take of waiting to call him competent lol. 

[Gerry Green]

3 hours ago, Varking said:

We knew Trevor was a competent QB…. In college. Year one in the NFL did not make him look competent. Let’s not crown guys before a single pro snap. Everyone is pooing a dude here who had a sane take of waiting to call him competent lol. 

 

IMO, there are 2 ways this is going to go. 1. Bryce is Bryce, and we are a competitive team from the get go. 2. Um... I don't really see a 2. This team is set up for success.

 

Divisional Champs, Roty, Coach of the Year. If this isn't the time of year to see that?

 

Edit to add; If, by chance, Bryce fails. Well, I guess we start all over again eh?

Edited May 11, 2023 by Gerry Green

[TheMostInterestingMan]

6 hours ago, Day1PanthersFan said:

They basically said we are the best piece of trash in the garbage can 

 

After the last few years, I’ll take it

[Gerry Green]

5 hours ago, CamWhoaaCam said:

Who is underrating Atlanta's roster?

 

They have been getting praise all offseason for their moves and draft. Their only weakness is QB. They literally have the skill positions on offense. They improved that defense tremendously.

 

Part of me is going to be a little scared at responding to you, cuz you tend to scare me.

 

If, and it's a big if, that D, and that QB can get their crap together? They just may be an interesting team.

[Eric4280]

3 hours ago, Varking said:

We knew Trevor was a competent QB…. In college. Year one in the NFL did not make him look competent. Let’s not crown guys before a single pro snap. Everyone is pooing a dude here who had a sane take of waiting to call him competent lol. 

You are Stroud guys. Had we taken him you wouldn’t have the same “wait and see” proclamation to call him competent.. be real. Also, Trevor had Urban Meyer…. We’re gonna call year one a mulligan. Had Trevor walked into this coaching wonderland and a plethora of number 2 WR and a top ten OL, I’m sure he’d have succeeded. Every situation is different and this setup is perfection for any rookie.

 

Now for the rest of the division. I think we need to start taking a bull by the horns approach to possible dominance. Saints have a few pieces but man, are they aging. Kamara at full health is a shell. Jordan/Davis/ even Lattimore aren’t getting any younger. Michael Thomas will be fun for the 55 snaps he plays. The teams not putting fear into anyone.

 

Tampa has maybe the worst OL in the nfl and well how the ENTIRE team approach changes after losing the best QB of all time. They stumbled to the finish line with Tom and even though he wasn’t perfect at that stage in his career, he was still Tom Brady compared to Kyle Trask and Baker..

 

Falcons are real fun on madden and to talk about. We did this for 5 years. Have elite crap everywhere else besides Qb. The only defensive moves of significance I see are Onyemata and maybe Okudah. Bates is damn near the most overrated player in the nfl. My brother is a die hard Bengals fan and was exponentially more upset in losing Bell.

[Gerry Green]

13 minutes ago, Eric4280 said:

You are Stroud guys. Had we taken him you wouldn’t have the same “wait and see” proclamation to call him competent.. be real. Also, Trevor had Urban Meyer…. We’re gonna call year one a mulligan. Had Trevor walked into this coaching wonderland and a plethora of number 2 WR and a top ten OL, I’m sure he’d have succeeded. Every situation is different and this setup is perfection for any rookie.

 

Now for the rest of the division. I think we need to start taking a bull by the horns approach to possible dominance. Saints have a few pieces but man, are they aging. Kamara at full health is a shell. Jordan/Davis/ even Lattimore aren’t getting any younger. Michael Thomas will be fun for the 55 snaps he plays. The teams not putting fear into anyone.

 

Tampa has maybe the worst OL in the nfl and well how the ENTIRE team approach changes after losing the best QB of all time. They stumbled to the finish line with Tom and even though he wasn’t perfect at that stage in his career, he was still Tom Brady compared to Kyle Trask and Baker..

 

Falcons are real fun on madden and to talk about. We did this for 5 years. Have elite crap everywhere else besides Qb. The only defensive moves of significance I see are Onyemata and maybe Okudah. Bates is damn near the most overrated player in the nfl. My brother is a die hard Bengals fan and was exponentially more upset in losing Bell.

 

So...after all that? How you calling it? 

 

Panthers (If Bryce plays well. If he falters? Well things can change can't they?)

NO  

Atl

TB

 

Call it my way too early to call it prediction.

[onmyown]

Meh…the NFCS is a poo show and yes the first franchise to pull it’s head out of it’s ass or recover will probably have a nice run.

that said, I really don’t care. I’d like to see a team that can compete with any NFL team or at least the rest of the NFC vs. three other (awful) teams…

tired of seeing the panthers look like a pee wee team vs. legit teams…like say oh I don’t know the atrocious Bengal game last year. 

like that’s a perfect example of how far off the panthers are from a championship caliber team.