Ranking the NFCS Rosters

[Gerry Green]

Nobody disrespects the Panthers better than some of their own fans.

 

Fear of the past is strong in some of these people.

 

 

[frankw]

Good to hear the Panthers getting some love. It's nice to have Ryan Brees and now Brady out of the picture. If anyone thinks this might be an easy division though I would wait and see what the preseason brings. The Bucs could go either way but the Saints and Falcons will definitely test us.

[Harbingers]

Just now, mrcompletely11 said:

He’s played 0 snaps in the nfl.  I’m going to hold off on proclaiming what he is until he actually does it.   And where did I call him incompetent?

You said we need a competent QB. Then you doubled down with Dalton. Young is a competent QB. He meets all of the criteria of the statement. He has everything needed to have success himself. 

[Harbingers]

15 minutes ago, Smithers said:

I don’t agree.  Tampa’s O-line is trash.  They lost their top RB.  Their pass rush is below average.  And they have the worst QB in the division.

Mmmm but they still have the big pieces, and they have depth(at least of last year). I won’t start catching up on other teams rosters until 53 is set in August/September, too many variables to worry about out of the house stuff. What I know is our depth the past 3 years has been complete garbage and last year was no exception. Wilks was just about to coax a little more out of them and didn’t have as many injuries. As a complete roster going into the season from last season I’d go,

TB

NO =/> CAR

 ATL. 

Depth matters.

Edited May 10, 2023 by Harbingers

[mrcompletely11]

1 minute ago, Harbingers said:

You said we need a competent QB. Then you doubled down with Dalton. Young is a competent QB. He meets all of the criteria of the statement. He has everything needed to have success himself. 

He is not a qb competent yet.   He hasn’t taken one fuging snap yet.  He is totally unproven.  Goddamn some of you guys need to not get so fuging emotional defending him.   

[Harbingers]

Just now, mrcompletely11 said:

He is not a qb competent yet.   He hasn’t taken one fuging snap yet.  He is totally unproven.  Goddamn some of you guys need to not get so fuging emotional defending him.   

Like I said. You are confusing competent and unproven. 

[CamWhoaaCam]

7 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

He’s played 0 snaps in the nfl.  I’m going to hold off on proclaiming what he is until he actually does it.   And where did I call him incompetent?

So his college film didn't sell you on him at all?

 

Damn bro you are hard to please.

[LinvilleGorge]

Would you two idiots stop arguing over semantics and fuging up the thread already?

[CamWhoaaCam]

2 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Would you two idiots stop arguing over semantics and fuging up the thread already?

Linville from the top rope!

 

[ForJimmy]

I don’t understand why people think our roster is worse than Tampa and Atlanta’s outside if the QB? We split with these teams last year with terrible QB play and half of a coaching staff. I think we definitely got better as well. Brown, Burns, Horn, Chinn, and Shaq are as good of pieces as any defense in the division. Our OL is probably the best, Sanders is probably better than Tampa or NO’s RBs (with Kamara suspended), our WRs are pretty unproven outside of Thielen/Chark so we are probably last there but Hurst is mid-tier for TE (below ATL obviously). 

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

5 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

I don’t understand why people think our roster is worse than Tampa and Atlanta’s outside if the QB? We split with these teams last year with terrible QB play and half of a coaching staff. I think we definitely got better as well. Brown, Burns, Horn, Chinn, and Shaq are as good of pieces as any defense in the division. Our OL is probably the best, Sanders is probably better than Tampa or NO’s RBs (with Kamara suspended), our WRs are pretty unproven outside of Thielen/Chark so we are probably last there but Hurst is mid-tier for TE (below ATL obviously). 

I think Atlantas roster is heavily underrated. If their QB is halfway decent (big ask), they won't compete with the 49ers or Eagles but they will be in that 2nd tier of NFC teams with the Giants, Seahawks etc.

Tampa and NO rosters are old and bad.

[Gerry Green]

2 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

I don’t understand why people think our roster is worse than Tampa and Atlanta’s outside if the QB? We split with these teams last year with terrible QB play and half of a coaching staff. I think we definitely got better as well. Brown, Burns, Horn, Chinn, and Shaq are as good of pieces as any defense in the division. Our OL is probably the best, Sanders is probably better than Tampa or NO’s RBs (with Kamara suspended), our WRs are pretty unproven outside of Thielen/Chark so we are probably last there but Hurst is mid-tier for TE (below ATL obviously). 

 

I truly believe that most folks just can't let go of the past. Their fear of the past is stronger than their hope for the future.

 

Also, there are those that just have to be realists. But that's a whole different animal. lol

[PleaseCutStewart]

39 minutes ago, Harbingers said:

Mmmm but they still have the big pieces, and they have depth(at least of last year). I won’t start catching up on other teams rosters until 53 is set in August/September, too many variables to worry about out of the house stuff. What I know is our depth the past 3 years has been complete garbage and last year was no exception. Wilks was just about to coax a little more out of them and didn’t have as many injuries. As a complete roster going into the season from last season I’d go,

TB

NO =/> CAR

 ATL. 

Depth matters.

I think NO has the most complete team/depth outside of QB, and they actually got a solid QB this year.

Not sure how you have Tampa ranked #1 - the team lost their entire pass rush outside of Vea, is awful at half of their O-line spots (with no oline depth), and practially lost all of their secondary depth

The only positions I think they are strong at is WR (if Godwin can actually stay healthy), LB, and secondary (1 injury here severely changes that though). 

I wouldn't be surprised if Tampa is a seller at the trade deadline and finishes last in the division.

[CamWhoaaCam]

5 minutes ago, Sean Payton's Vicodin said:

I think Atlantas roster is heavily underrated. If their QB is halfway decent (big ask), they won't compete with the 49ers or Eagles but they will be in that 2nd tier of NFC teams with the Giants, Seahawks etc.

Tampa and NO rosters are old and bad.

Who is underrating Atlanta's roster?

 

They have been getting praise all offseason for their moves and draft. Their only weakness is QB. They literally have the skill positions on offense. They improved that defense tremendously.