You're the GM. 2023 Panthers Re-draft

[SmokinwithWilly]

A little post draft fun since there's not much happening until TC. Most of us, myself included, are pretty critical of our GMs and say we knew better. So here's an opportunity that we can revisit later to see who really did know better. We've seen how the draft fell so change our picks. Now's the opportunity to put your redraft on the record. Of course there's trades, etc. but for the sake of simplicity, I'm just going to keep our picks. So here's mine. 

(1)Anthony Richardson - If we're going to swing for the fences moving up to 1, I go for the highest ceiling. Ideally I'd like to trade down to 2 and pick up the 24' 1st they offered Chicago and still take AR, but I'll go with the pick here. 

(39) BJ Ojulari - We needed an edge rusher opposite Burns and one was right there for the taking. 

(93) Kelle Ringo - CB is a need too. Can't rely on DJ and JH to stay healthy and Henderson is a liability. We need help and here it is. 

(114) Chandler Zavala - Like this pick and see no need to change it. always invest in your offensive line. 

(132) Tyler Scott - Fast, athletic WR that will add to our WR room. 

(145) Antonio Johnson - Safety is a need and AJ has a similar style to Chinn if we can't end up keeping him. 

That's what I'd do on a draft redo. The positions taken actually stay the same, but who and where is obviously different. So who's your picks? Who's going to be worth picking and who isn't? Obviously I'm going to support all our current picks and BY is our QB. Just a little something to do while we wait. 

[Daddy_Uncle]

I'll take our actual draft over that

[Santee_Panther]

Let’s not kid ourselves. The big move was the move up to one.

Young at one or Levis at 9 will be the question. (Plus all we gave up).

Edited May 1, 2023 by Santee_Panther
Misspelling

[carpanfan96]

Gotta take the scheme into the equation on player fit and such. 

[rodeo]

If I was the GM this is what I would have done:

Round 1: Bryce Young, QB

Round 2: Will Anderson, Edge

Round 3: Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR

Round 4: Devon Witherspoon, CB

Round 5: Paris Johnson Jr, OT

 

[WUnderhill]

3 minutes ago, rodeo said:

If I was the GM this is what I would have done:

Round 1: Bryce Young, QB

Round 2: Will Anderson, Edge

Round 3: Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR

Round 4: Devon Witherspoon, CB

Round 5: Paris Johnson Jr, OT

 

You’re hired.

[rodeo]

Just now, WUnderhill said:

You’re hired.

thank you, I don't know why people make this way harder than it needs to be, like just draft the best guys it's not that complicated

[Cdparr7]

1 hour ago, SmokinwithWilly said:

A little post draft fun since there's not much happening until TC. Most of us, myself included, are pretty critical of our GMs and say we knew better. So here's an opportunity that we can revisit later to see who really did know better. We've seen how the draft fell so change our picks. Now's the opportunity to put your redraft on the record. Of course there's trades, etc. but for the sake of simplicity, I'm just going to keep our picks. So here's mine. 

(1)Anthony Richardson - If we're going to swing for the fences moving up to 1, I go for the highest ceiling. Ideally I'd like to trade down to 2 and pick up the 24' 1st they offered Chicago and still take AR, but I'll go with the pick here. 

(39) BJ Ojulari - We needed an edge rusher opposite Burns and one was right there for the taking. 

(93) Kelle Ringo - CB is a need too. Can't rely on DJ and JH to stay healthy and Henderson is a liability. We need help and here it is. 

(114) Chandler Zavala - Like this pick and see no need to change it. always invest in your offensive line. 

(132) Tyler Scott - Fast, athletic WR that will add to our WR room. 

(145) Antonio Johnson - Safety is a need and AJ has a similar style to Chinn if we can't end up keeping him. 

That's what I'd do on a draft redo. The positions taken actually stay the same, but who and where is obviously different. So who's your picks? Who's going to be worth picking and who isn'tObviously I'm going to support all our current picks and BY is our QB. Just a little something to do while we wait. 

 1-Bryce Young (QB)

2- BJ Ojulari (Edge)

3. Nick Salvederi (T)

4. Charlie Jones (WR)

5. Karl Brooks (DL)

[csx]

Redrafts are typically based on seeing how the players perform.

Edited May 1, 2023 by csx

[Sean Payton's Vicodin]

OP we just had a solid month of mock drafts. Why continue the torture

[AndrewLaskoski]

I’d probably stick pretty close to the original draft besides trading up to spot 80.

1- Young (QB)

39- Mingo (WR) 

93-  Adebawore (iDL)

114- Zavala (OG)

132- Darius Rush (CB)

145- Robinson (S)

 

 

[rayzor]

i'm ok with the draft. 

biggest issue was getting a QB and we got the best one in the draft.

everything else is just gravy.

[MHS831]

8 hours ago, rodeo said:

If I was the GM this is what I would have done:

Round 1: Bryce Young, QB

Round 2: Will Anderson, Edge

Round 3: Jaxon Smith-Njigba, WR

Round 4: Devon Witherspoon, CB

Round 5: Paris Johnson Jr, OT

 

You forgot that you signed Dalton Kincaid as an UDFA. 

 

[MHS831]

I did a mock that exactly paralleled the actual draft, but nobody seemed to notice that.*

*Referring to the first pick only.