Riddle me this?

[Mike in Raleigh]

3 hours ago, Varking said:

I’m 100% on board that he is our guy. But I won’t gaslight myself into believing he doesn’t have these flaws. 

Everyone has flaws. If one or the other of these guys didn't have flaws, there wouldn't be a debate. It boils down to how the coaching staff feels they can best address the issues and ultimately,  it's their decision.  Going on and on about it doesn't solve a thing. The coaching staff isn't looking at these threads thinking "You know "Joe blow" over here makes a good point. Let's do that." At the end of the day it's a crap shoot. Always has been. 

[Shocker]

5 hours ago, Gerry Green said:

 

We were told Bryce had the best line in college. Yet he still has to run around to make plays.

 

Bama WRs are still some of the best in college. Give me a break on no talent.

 

Plenty of QBs get the ball out. Why can't Bryce. Maybe scheme him a better O next time?

His OL last year was not great at all.  Neither were his WRs.  Jesus, homework man

[ForJimmy]

1 hour ago, stan786 said:

I don’t think there is anyone on this site that can make me laugh as consistently as you do. This is high level stuff.

My favorite is still Tom Brady breaking tackles!

[Eric4280]

5 minutes ago, Shocker said:

His OL last year was not great at all.  Neither were his WRs.  Jesus, homework man

People are lazy yet passionate, it’s amazing.

[ForJimmy]

33 minutes ago, rippadonn said:

I knew Kyle Trask was a second rounder, everyone knows that's a hard road in itself. Kyle Trask is 3yrs deep now competing for the job.

Matt Corral is one Bryce Young away from starting foreverrrrr.

They just signed Baker to start over Trask just like he did over Corral. Baker starting over your guys is a bad look. Also Corral can’t stay healthy. You are concerned about Young’s durability while Corral was injured in college and couldn’t make it through the preseason last year. 

[mrcompletely11]

Just now, Eric4280 said:

People are lazy yet passionate, it’s amazing.

Recruiting rankings

2019 Bama #1

2020 Bama #2

2021 Bama #1

 

Poor bryce its amazing to know he did so much with so little

[Eric4280]

Just now, mrcompletely11 said:

Recruiting rankings

2019 Bama #1

2020 Bama #2

2021 Bama #1

 

Poor bryce its amazing to know he did so much with so little

Name. Which. Bama. WR. You. Want. Us. To. Draft.

[top dawg]

4 hours ago, Varking said:

Wrong. 

For those who want to keep saying this, watch these two videos:

Clip after clip of throwing dudes open under pressure while having to move AND throwing dimes. Throws Bryce Young has never made. 

And you can watch below to see where Young struggles. 

Both guys have their pluses and minuses but somehow Stroud has developed this weird reputation he doesn’t move around, make dudes miss, and that his guys are just wide open. This past season Alabama WRs were more wide open than OSU WRs. Stroud constantly threw the ball into tight windows. Which translates to the NFL. Young does not. 

 

Young threw into tight windows plenty. Come on, dude.

[Aussie Tank]

Just keep hating on our fun size more athletic Peyton Manning. 

[Martin]

3 minutes ago, Eric4280 said:

Name. Which. Bama. WR. You. Want. Us. To. Draft.

I think Ohio State had a better offensive line up. Alabama had a much better defense, nobody is questioning that. Everyone is questioning that Young was surrounded by scrubs and no names.

Which teams that Alabama played this year had a better roster than Alabama outside of Georgia? Would love for you to answer that question.

[rippadonn]

6 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

They just signed Baker to start over Trask just like he did over Corral. Baker starting over your guys is a bad look. Also Corral can’t stay healthy. You are concerned about Young’s durability while Corral was injured in college and couldn’t make it through the preseason last year. 

Baker will be limping off to the sidelines soon enough. Or sucking, just like he did here after YOU and the Baker Boys filled up the huddle with the same foolish hopium you pump into BY.

Both not elite. Good eye.

[Martin]

3 minutes ago, Aussie Tank said:

Just keep hating on our fun size more athletic Peyton Manning. 

Love that description of Young, a more positive spin of what we hope he will become. Well done!

[96Bravo]

I'll be honest. I keep watching play after play of both Stroud and Young from one game after another. Really in hopes that I'll fall in love with Young's style. 

He's very elusive. I like that. Despite his size, I'm not too worried about his durability. He can turn an ugly play into a brilliant one. Great poise.

But when I watch Stroud I see a QB that just makes it "look easy". He's also clearly poised. Smooth, quick release.  Beautiful ball placement.  Regardless of what some test suggests, he clearly processes defenses quickly and effectively with his progressions. 

Some think Stroud isn't fiery enough. I say he's just stone cold out there. Maybe he's Iceman to Young's Maverick. 

[ForJimmy]

1 minute ago, rippadonn said:

Baker will be limping off to the sidelines soon enough. Or sucking, just like he did here after YOU and the Baker Boys filled up the huddle with the same foolish hopium you pump into BY.

Both not elite. Good eye.

Yep he is not elite and signed to start over Trask. What does that make Trask? How is Carson Strong? Who also had durability concerns just like Corral.