Fanbase Temperature Gauge: Who do you like and who do you want? (4/21/23)

[KatsAzz]

On 4/23/2023 at 10:42 AM, Mage said:

Bryce Young is going to be a great Panther.

Bryce Young certainly has lots of talent. I just hope he makes a quick adjustment to the NFL and helps get the Panthers get off to a good start this season.

[Krovvy]

I love Richardson's potential, but I'm more than okay with Bryce Young, as other than size he has it.

The safest bet is that Young will probably play well in the NFL. I think he has a shot of being a Drew Brees like quarterback, with more creativity in his play. Anthony Richardson is a freak of nature and as a bet I wouldn't mind the Panthers taking, but I understand why they would choose Young over him.

[Kentucky Panther]

I’ve been on the Stroud train since the beginning. But I accepted it was probably going to be Young a few weeks ago. So I’ve been hyping myself up for him since. 
 

Im happy with Young and he will be our pick. 

[rodeo]

Even after I decided I'd be okay with Young, I still wasn't totally sold on him, mainly because all the highlights I'd seen were of him scrambling and that didn't really impress me because a lot of that would have been sacks in the NFL.

It wasn't until I started watching long form videos like that QB School guy who actually breaks down his regular non-scrambling throws that I started actually getting excited for Bryce. He's going to be a fantastic player.

[Hogan]

This is a response to several who are saying the Richardson has the highest ceiling and can be developed. I have no idea how good he will be. But I am sure of one thing: elite accuracy cannot be developed. It's God given. He may develop into a really good NFL QB. But he will never have elite accuracy.

[byob1013]

Young is able to compensate mentally for what he can't physically. Not many of the "prototypically sized" alternatives have been deemed as very intelligent or capable of processing to his extent. I feel if Stroud did what Young did with the talent and vice versa maybe things would be different, but it is hard to overlook the offense run at OSU and talent at WR. 

[poundaway]

 

I was swayed by the overall sentiment that there was little difference between BY and the bigger QBs and that it wasn't worth his smaller frame, until I watched the tapes.  Watching his tape and the other QB's tape, I think it would be a mistake to pass on Young.

[CRA]

I'll be happy with Young or Stroud.  Don't care at this point.  I'll be unhappy with anything else at #1. 

[Icege]

I'm good with any of the top guys being the guy tbh. Frank Reich, Jim Caldwell, Thomas Brown, and Josh McCown are infinitely more knowledgeable about football then I will ever be. They have my full trust.

[CBird]

Give me AR.  I know some folks might poo poo, but I want the longest highest success in my game.  Sure Young and Stroud are more polished and accomplished right now, but look at the coaching and surrounding cast they had……..Give me AR all day.  I don’t want to see us picking #1 again for many many years.  Let’s Go!

[Icege]

I'm getting more and more excited the closer we get to the draft. Should Corbett + Christensen heal quick, a lot of upgrades have been made to a team that late in the season had a shot to win the division.

First, addition by subtraction when it came to Rhule and most of his assistants. Reich, Brown, and Evero are better than Rhule, McAdoo, and Snow. Lost Foreman and Moore, but gained Sanders, Chark, Thielen, and Hurst. A rookie QB has a shot in this division.

Eager to see what the team does after #1. Plenty of needs on both sides of the ball, though I'd like to see them come out with an edge rusher or a defensive lineman. A linebacker possibly

 

[Mr. Scot]

6 hours ago, CBird said:

Give me AR.  I know some folks might poo poo, but I want the longest highest success in my game.  Sure Young and Stroud are more polished and accomplished right now, but look at the coaching and surrounding cast they had……..Give me AR all day.  I don’t want to see us picking #1 again for many many years.  Let’s Go!

"Longest success" doesn't generally come from a quarterback like Richardson.

[CBird]

Hey Mr.Scott I hear you, the running does wear down quarterback, but so do concussions and other injuries from being small.  I am a panther fan so I will pull for whoever they pick.

[CPcavedweller]

If we don't take Stroud I want Levis.

Neither are happening so wtf ever. Levis is going to be a very good NFL player.