Does being a heisman QB guarantee success in the pros..

[PanthersGOATFan336]

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dazn.com/en-US/news/amp/american-football/top-10-recent-heisman-winning-quarterbacks-where-does-joe-burrow-land/8io3d5vs3qgx1s2ayt97lqwkt

10. Johnny Manziel

9. Sam Bradford 

8. Robert Griffin III

7. Marcus Mariota

6. James Winston

5. Baker Mayfield

4. Kyle Murray

3. Joe Burrow

2. Lamar Jackson 

1. Cam Newton

While Newton, Jackson and Burrow have had some success a lot of these QB's leave a lot to be desired which leads to the question..why have so many heisman QB's not had success at the pro level? 

Edited April 20, 2023 by PanthersGOATFan336

[KSpan]

3 minutes ago, PanthersGOATFan336 said:

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.dazn.com/en-US/news/amp/american-football/top-10-recent-heisman-winning-quarterbacks-where-does-joe-burrow-land/8io3d5vs3qgx1s2ayt97lqwkt

10. Johnny Manziel

9. Sam Bradford 

8. Robert Griffin III

7. Marcus Mariota

6. James Winston

5. Baker Mayfield

4. Kyle Murray

3. Joe Burrow

2. Lamar Jackson 

1. Cam Newton

While Newton, Jackson and Burrow have had some success a lot of these QB's leave a lot to be desired which leads to the question..why have so many heisman QB's not had success at the pro level? 

Since 1999, the 13 Heisman winners have combined for three Pro Bowl selections, two of which belong to Carson Palmer.

Cam himself has 3 PB selections...?

[jayflip]

[Wundrbread33]

Because college stats and the prestige of the school you went to matter for awards, but don’t matter for transitioning to the pros. 
 

It’s more complicated than that. 
 

Also, Bryce Young is a damn good football player. 

[PanthersGOATFan336]

3 minutes ago, KSpan said:

Cam himself has 3 PB selections...?

Had to remove that, article was a bit dated

[ForJimmy]

Does putting up great numbers at OSU guarantee success? Let’s dive into that too.

-joking 

[pantherclaw]

Not at all. 

[ForJimmy]

You could make an argument for it helping recently with Jackson, Burrow, Cam, and Murray but back in the day it more associated with QBs struggling in the NFL.

[WUnderhill]

What a strange question to ask. Who would ever say that being a Heisman QB guarantees success in the pros?

Didn’t you say in your last thread that you were done until draft day or something along those lines? We get it, you don’t like Young…

[CamWhoaaCam]

No it doesn't guarantee success considering most Heisman winners are QB's. That's award is basically the best QB on a great team award. There are plenty of QB's who have been better QB's in college than the Heisman winners and they get punished because they play on lesser talented teams.

 

The Heisman is basically a award for power 5 schools which is usually the best QB with a top ranked team.

[PanthersGOATFan336]

2 minutes ago, WUnderhill said:

What a strange question to ask. Who would ever say that being a Heisman QB guarantees success in the pros?

Didn’t you say in your last thread that you were done until draft day or something along those lines? We get it, you don’t like Young…

If you can't contribute you can always keep scrolling 

[WUnderhill]

Just now, PanthersGOATFan336 said:

If you can't contribute you can always keep scrolling 

You didn’t answer my question. Who said being a Heisman QB guarantees success in the pros?

If you can’t handle being called out for your constant stream of anti Bryce Young threads, stop making them…

[PanthersGOATFan336]

Just now, WUnderhill said:

You didn’t answer my question. Who said being a Heisman QB guarantees success in the pros?

If you can’t handle being called out for your constant stream of anti Bryce Young threads, stop making them…

why have so many heisman QB's not had success at the pro level? 

That's from the OP...again if you don't want to contribute

And let me look to make sure...NOPE I didn't include any if this drafts names in the op either..seems like you're just reaching for whatever you can

[ForJimmy]

1 minute ago, PanthersGOATFan336 said:

why have so many heisman QB's not had success at the pro level? 

That's from the OP...again if you don't want to contribute

And let me look to make sure...NOPE I didn't include any if this drafts names in the op either..seems like you're just reaching for whatever you can

Recently that has changed.  Lamar, Cam, Burrow, and Kyler all found success.  Catch up with the times!