Why not both?

[WarPanthers89]

33 minutes ago, therealmjl said:

Amazing. Will be stealing this asap and using in the future. Sorry in advance 

[RJK]

They must have no faith in TMJ. Maybe he can be traded before his value plummets

[Sub Zero]

1 minute ago, RJK said:

They must have no faith in TMJ. Maybe he can be traded before his value plummets

Yeah that doesn’t mean that at all..

[RJK]

Just now, Sub Zero said:

Yeah that doesn’t mean that at all..

It doesn’t not mean that at all either. 

[therealmjl]

8 minutes ago, WarPanthers89 said:

Amazing. Will be stealing this asap and using in the future. Sorry in advance 

I stole it from someone on Twitter 

[Hoenheim]

Is this really news? They're the 2 dudes we met with last week

[Sub Zero]

12 minutes ago, RJK said:

It doesn’t not mean that at all either. 

Really ??

alright let’s step under the learning tree for a moment…

1. WR room is thin in the 1st place anyway.. After trading DJ you we’re adding 2 to 3 WR form the beginning.. Fitt literally said this..

2. The Room lacks experience.. Not good for a Rookie QB.. Adding Theilen and Chark at least gives you 2 WR in the room with “years” of starting experience..

3. Context in the situation - Due to the old regime TMJ got little play time so this his only real time going into a season getting real reps.. Chark has a large injury history.. And bringing in a rookie in a weak WR class isn’t something you can depend on getting a day 1 starter from.. So covering all your basis is the best way to further in sure a stable environment for a rookie QB..

4. Weak draft and weak FA class means you need to throw a lot of dart at the board.. Plain and simple..

None of this is a detriment to TMJ but more about having options and not putting your eggs in 1 basket.. Which is smart moves to make when you’re trying to develop your franchise number 1 pick..

Edited March 19, 2023 by Sub Zero

[Ricky Spanish]

[tukafan21]

I like Thielen as he'd be a good slot safety valve for a rookie and would be a great vet presence in the WR room to teach these guys how to be pros, particularly TMJ and whichever WR we draft in the 2nd.

But I just don't see the need for Chark, he's similar to TMJ and very injury prone, just not someone I'd like to see us target as I don't think he brings enough value to us right now.

[frankw]

Do it.

[Camp Fodder]

11 minutes ago, Hoenheim said:

Is this really news? They're the 2 dudes we met with last week

Yea because I thought we were out on Thielen

[Camp Fodder]

33 minutes ago, TLGPanthersFan said:

I have a feeling a WR will be what the second rounder is. 

If we could snag both we could go pass rusher there 

[Tr3ach]

1 minute ago, tukafan21 said:

I like Thielen as he'd be a good slot safety valve for a rookie and would be a great vet presence in the WR room to teach these guys how to be pros, particularly TMJ and whichever WR we draft in the 2nd.

But I just don't see the need for Chark, he's similar to TMJ and very injury prone, just not someone I'd like to see us target as I don't think he brings enough value to us right now.

Other than saying theyre both tall, i dont think tmj and chark have much else at all in common.

[CamWhoaaCam]

1 minute ago, tukafan21 said:

I like Thielen as he'd be a good slot safety valve for a rookie and would be a great vet presence in the WR room to teach these guys how to be pros, particularly TMJ and whichever WR we draft in the 2nd.

But I just don't see the need for Chark, he's similar to TMJ and very injury prone, just not someone I'd like to see us target as I don't think he brings enough value to us right now.

Disagree with this.

 

While Chark is injury prone he is still a high end #2 WR who is still in his prime.

 

Thielen had a great career but he's 33 and trending towards more of a #3 WR. He has also had the opportunity of having single coverage because he played with Justin Jefferson. He won't have that here in Carolina.

 

If I had to choose between the 2 give me Chark.