would you trade jonathan stewart...

[pantherclaw]

...for jason campbell and washington's second rounder?

Hell no. Stop the bleeding dude.

[King Taharqa]

[SnarkAttack]

Why in the hell would Washingon trade their starting QB and a second rounder for Stewart when they could just take a RB in the first or second round next year?

[pantherclaw]

Why in the hell would Washingon trade their starting QB and a second rounder for Stewart when they could just take a RB in the first or second round next year?

That's what makes any thread about trading a RB for a QB flat out stupid. The value of a good RB does not equal the value of a QB. Besides, campbell holds onto the ball way to long.

[King Taharqa]

This thread is nothing more than a Jonathan Stewart sneak diss thread. Fiz knows Campbell is a FA this offseason. What I want to know is what do people see in Campbell? Id be for bringing him in for a year as a "1 year stopgap" a la Peete, but long term answer? Sorry, not seeing it with him.

[BoilingPrestone]

The Redskins should fall all over themselves for that trade. That being said, we shouldn't entertain the idea. Most Skinz fans can't wait for Campbell to leave.

[grateflday]

This thread is nothing more than a Jonathan Stewart sneak diss thread. Fiz knows Campbell is a FA this offseason. What I want to know is what do people see in Campbell? Id be for bringing him in for a year as a "1 year stopgap" a la Peete, but long term answer? Sorry, not seeing it with him.

I think you bring in Campbell as a stopgap for 1, 2 or even 3 seasons if needed. I dont want the Panthers trading Smith or Stewart to get back into Rd 1. They should bring in Campbell, draft a QB in Rd 2, then even draft another QB in 2011 if you like one that year.

With Campbell as the Panthers QB they easily have 3-4 more wins this season. He would do well here, while the team grooms a young future replacement. Something this franchise should have been doing already!!! Escp when they saw a season lost when Jake got hurt a couple of years ago.

[Kevin Greene]

This thread is nothing more than a Jonathan Stewart sneak diss thread. Fiz knows Campbell is a FA this offseason. What I want to know is what do people see in Campbell? Id be for bringing him in for a year as a "1 year stopgap" a la Peete, but long term answer? Sorry, not seeing it with him.

Fiz would never do that.

Getting Campbell for a one year stop gap means you'll have something ready for 2011. We have nothing yet to go to.

But me thinks no way you'd get Campbell for one year. Whoever signs him will be commiting to multi years and lots of future cap dollars. Campbell=Panthers putting the teams future success on his shoulders for several years.

[PantherDude]

Time & time again, we should not trade Stewart. Look how we did with him scoring our only TD with how DeAngelo was out yesterday. You honestly could see Sutton or Goodson doing better if either were the starter in that game if Stewart was out like DeAngelo??

And Campbell? No way in hell are the Redskins going to get rid of him. I prefer Moore here than him.

[Jackofalltrades]

Wtf? No!

[grateflday]

............And Campbell? No way in hell are the Redskins going to get rid of him. I prefer Moore here than him.

Campbell is a free agent so it is not up to the Skins, unless they franchise him and there is no way that is happening. So it is up to Campbell and with the circus over in DC he just might want to move on.

[PantherDude]

Campbell is a free agent so it is not up to the Skins, unless they franchise him and there is no way that is happening. So it is up to Campbell and with the circus over in DC he just might want to move on.

But knowing how the Redskins love to pay too much (They pay Haynesworth $100 millions, you know. ), I won't be surprise if they give him a lot & he will stay. I just have a feeling that will happend.

[Pantherfan75]

lol

no

[Fiz]

sweet picture from icanhazcheezeburger brah really hammers your point home

Look how we did with him scoring our only TD with how DeAngelo was out yesterday. You honestly could see Sutton or Goodson doing better if either were the starter in that game if Stewart was out like DeAngelo??

yeah sutton sucked yesterday