would you trade jonathan stewart...

[Fiz]

Child please, if you took a vote would it... yes or no, majority of the vote would be yes

appealing to the intelligence of the carolina panther fanbase

A BOLD STRATEGY

All that matters is a W and leading your team to that.

the trent dilfer school of quarterbacking

Unless you have record breaking stats, then you have an argument. And in this case, neither happened

ahh yes, it's either abject failure due to one play or a free pass due to record breaking performances

nothing in between

black and white world

dialectics

you are literally dennis hopper from apocalypse now

[beastson]

I guess thats the end of the argument right there

But back to the original thread question

NO!!!

[PhillyB]

[Wither]

As much as I hate (love) to say it, I have to agree with Fiz.

I'm not saying Campbell is "good" but I think he'd be a great pickup in FA (which is another matter entirely from what Fiz is talking about, by the way).

[Saint J]

do you guys realize how low a RB's value is? if you have a good o-line you can plug any scrub with RB next to his name and he can have sucess. unless you have a truly special talent(Peterson, Williams, Johnson) then you can easily deal your RB without regrets. even a game manager type of QB like campbell has a sh*t ton more value than stewart. i mean look at us, we build a dominant o-line and we can plug in UDFAs like Bell and Thomas and have sucess.

[Fiz]

manager type of QB like campbell has a sh*t ton more value than stewart.

bu bu bu we dwafted him

i mean look at us, we build a dominant o-line and we can plug in UDFAs like Bell and Thomas and have sucess.

the success of the saints running game has a lot more to do with the dominance of brees than anything else

if you think brees could go out and the saints could still line up and run effectively you're gay as hell

[Saint J]

carl nicks and jahri evans have more to do with it although brees has as well, they're destroying everyone not named haynesworth.

[frash.exe]

do you guys realize how low a RB's value is? if you have a good o-line you can plug any scrub with RB next to his name and he can have sucess. unless you have a truly special talent(Peterson, Williams, Johnson) then you can easily deal your RB without regrets. even a game manager type of QB like campbell has a sh*t ton more value than stewart. i mean look at us, we build a dominant o-line and we can plug in UDFAs like Bell and Thomas and have sucess.

it's kind of a common panther fan mentality

you see years of watching Fox try to push a brittle marginally talented RB to be his running game staple and seeing him constantly hammertime side step behind the offensive line and lose 2 yards every other play have given them the illusion that good backs are very hard to come by.

[Wither]

carl nicks and jahri evans have more to do with it although brees has as well, they're destroying everyone not named haynesworth.

And yet they almost lost to the Washington Redskins. *Barely manages to type that due to laughing.*

[Saint J]

uhh, did you miss the everyone not named haynesworth part?

[Wither]

uhh, did you miss the everyone not named haynesworth part?

No, I didn't. I just ignored it because Haynesworth is not the reason they almost lost.

[Saint J]

what does the saints being in a tight game have to do with carl nicks or jahri evans?

[Punisher]

A Saint fan derailing a thread to talk about the Saints. Gee.

[jpniner]

IF trading Stewart meant we could draft Bradford/McCoy/Clausen, whoever falls to middle/late First Round....worth it?