Kiper top 5 Bigboard(3 qbs)

[micnificent28]

"caption Will Anderson is one of the best pass rusher I have graded this past decade"

[t96]

We gotta start taking shots on highly rated QB prospects, even if it's at the expense of potentially missing out on a great player at another position. My plan would be to draft the best QB on our list this year, give him 2 years to show franchise QB ability and if he doesn't, rinse and repeat until we find a franchise guy.

[TheCasillas]

Starting to feel like the 2006 draft... two top 3 non qb talents and 3 top qbs... 

[pantherj]

 

[kungfoodude]

2 minutes ago, pantherj said:

 

Yes he is.

[pantherj]

Just now, kungfoodude said:

Yes he is.

He promised to retire if Pickles wasn't a successful NFL QB. He's still working.

[JawnyBlaze]

Oof. Makes me rethink my desire for Stroud if Kiper likes him…

[Ricky Spanish]

I see we are approaching "Mel Kiper is an idiot season".

As someone who absolutely loves the draft, I don't hate Mel. Mel helped make the NFL draft the spectacle it is. He's no more wrong or right than any other draft pundit out there. He was just the first. 

What he says is not gospel and is just his opinion. I will take in what he says and compare his notes and opinions to other draft guys to better shape my own opinion of prospects. It's ok to either agree or disagree with him. Doesn't mean you or him are stupid if the player ends up good or bad, just that you, like many, many GMs, are often wrong in the crapshoot that is the NFL draft. 

[pantherj]

CJ is the obvious pick imo because of his insane arm strength and decent accuracy. When CJ throws he's just kind of flicking the ball effortlessly a lot of the time, and the ball rockets down the field. It's crazy. CJ's throwing motion is kind of messed up, yet he's still able to get the ball where he wants it to go. Imagine if he fixes his throwing motion. He'll be amazing imo, assuming he can see the field. 

[kungfoodude]

4 minutes ago, Ricky Spanish said:

I see we are approaching "Mel Kiper is an idiot season".

As someone who absolutely loves the draft, I don't hate Mel. Mel helped make the NFL draft the spectacle it is. He's no more wrong or right than any other draft pundit out there. He was just the first. 

What he says is not gospel and is just his opinion. I will take in what he says and compare his notes and opinions to other draft guys to better shape my own opinion of prospects. It's ok to either agree or disagree with him. Doesn't mean you or him are stupid if the player ends up good or bad, just that you, like many, many GMs, are often wrong in the crapshoot that is the NFL draft. 

I believe there is a website that did does an annual draft breakdown that very clearly indicated Mel Kiper was in the middle to lower tier of TV draft analysts. 

Kiper stands out as a complete idiot for his wildly moronic takes in pretty obvious situations on occasion. Also, the Clausen situation definitely tarnished his reputation as it clearly showed he doesn't have much in the way of even journalistic integrity. 

[JawnyBlaze]

4 minutes ago, Pakmeng said:

He had Mahomes and Allen as his top qbs in their drafts. That was not following the general thinking. 

Yea I was joking. Allen was my favorite in his draft too, I just trust my own eyes and still prefer Stroud

[kungfoodude]

6 minutes ago, pantherj said:

CJ is the obvious pick imo because of his insane arm strength and decent accuracy. When CJ throws he's just kind of flicking the ball effortlessly a lot of the time, and the ball rockets down the field. It's crazy. CJ's throwing motion is kind of messed up, yet he's still able to get the ball where he wants it to go. Imagine if he fixes his throwing motion. He'll be amazing imo, assuming he can see the field. 

Making a QB "fix his motion" at this level, is likely to lead to a JaMarcus Russell level bust. 

You might be able to tweak things here or there but not many QB's reinvent their throwing motion in the NFL and even succeed after they try.

[ForJimmy]

2 minutes ago, pantherj said:

He promised to retire if Pickles wasn't a successful NFL QB. He's still working.

Pickles successfully got us Cam.

[Waldo]

3 minutes ago, kungfoodude said:

Making a QB "fix his motion" at this level, is likely to lead to a JaMarcus Russell level bust. 

You might be able to tweak things here or there but not many QB's reinvent their throwing motion in the NFL and even succeed after they try.

Allen and Mahomes say hello.

I think it's a safe rule to follow but the 2 best QBs in the NFL says there is a chance.