McCaffrey

[Jackie Lee]

1 minute ago, Mr. Scot said:

Three touchdowns, one rushing, one receiving and one passing. He’s responsible for all but three of the 49ers 24 points so far.

I agreed with the trade, and still do, but McCaffrey in a Shanahan offense is a nightmare for opposing defenses.

Yeah he's not why we lost today, he never whined about how we used him, we got a good return on the trade. Good for both parties

[ForJimmy]

2 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Three touchdowns, one rushing, one receiving and one passing. He’s responsible for all but three of the 49ers 24 points so far.

I agreed with the trade, and still do, but McCaffrey in a Shanahan offense is a nightmare for opposing defenses.

I'm curious to see if he will make it all season healthy being used like that as well.  The man definitely has some mileage on him....

[Peon Awesome]

The trade was a win-win-win scenario. Win for the Panthers getting trade capital in a rebuild and making opportunities to better develop their other offensive playmakers. Win for the 49ers getting an otherworldly talent and having the coaches to make the most of his abilities. Win for my fantasy football team that drafted McCaffrey with the first pick. Everyone comes out on top.

[Castavar]

Y'all do know that a trade can be a win-win for each team involved right? We all knew he was going to go ape sh*t with Shanahan and his RB friendly scheme. But I'm still happy with our draft compensation. Only thing is you've made it to where you'll have to deal with the 49ers for the foreseeable future if you want a shot at a superbowl because you traded him within your conference lol

[frankw]

6 minutes ago, GOAT said:

hahaha damn and we thought the panthers overused him.

I'm not at all surprised Shanahan is getting this production out of him that's why he's one of the most successful young coaches. But he definitely won't last the season when he is leading the team in touches by a mile. Seen this story before. Eventually you need other playmakers. This stuff is great for his fanboys but they likely aren't winning a Super Bowl running an offense that way.

[Mr. Scot]

Just now, Jackie Lee said:

Yeah he's not why we lost today, he never whined about how we used him, we got a good return on the trade. Good for both parties

McAdoo isn’t perfect but hes been better without Rhule in charge.

It would have been nice to see him under these new circumstances, but hey…

 

[jbland]

1 hour ago, Snake said:

McCaffrey will finally get the press and recognization s he deserves in SF. That was never going to happen here. 

If we could win games he would. As long as we’re irrelevant, agreed. 

[Mr. Scot]

2 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

I'm curious to see if he will make it all season healthy being used like that as well.  The man definitely has some mileage on him....

That’s the big question.

[poundaway]

I wouldn't be surprised  he  tears up the rest of the season and next, and the 9ers go to the playoffs.

 

 

 

[Move the Panthers to Raleigh]

1 minute ago, Castavar said:

Y'all do know that a trade can be a win-win for each team involved right? We all knew he was going to go ape sh*t with Shanahan and his RB friendly scheme. But I'm still happy with our draft compensation. Only thing is you've made it to where you'll have to deal with the 49ers for the foreseeable future if you want a shot at a superbowl because you traded him within your conference lol

I don’t we would have gotten a better deal from an AFC team

[Proudiddy]

7 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

Three touchdowns, one rushing, one receiving and one passing. He’s responsible for all but three of the 49ers 24 points so far.

I agreed with the trade, and still do, but McCaffrey in a Shanahan offense is a nightmare for opposing defenses.

I said the same about the trade.  Despite his unique talents, he is still primarily a RB, snd eventually they fall off a cliff, they rarely ever continue producing at a high level into a third contract, and we honestly had lost how to use him properly under Rhule and McAdoodoo.  And then there was the possibility that his body already is or will be breaking down soon, as most RBs do.  So, it was best to get value and move on.

I also said seeing him in Shanahan's offense was going good be insane, and it only took a little over a week to come to fruition.  It's fun to see it, but it also hurts a little knowing what could've been.  But I still think RB is just not a position to prioritize unless you feel it's the one big missing piece to get you over the hump - as Foreman has shown, RB production is also easily replaced, regardless of who they're replacing, even if it doesn't quite look the same.  

So yeah, a part of me misses seeing CMC at his best like this, but it was the best move for the long-term.

[Mr. Scot]

Just now, Move the Panthers to Raleigh said:

I don’t we would have gotten a better deal from an AFC team

The only AFC team that was in on the trade didn’t offer anything close.

[Catsfan69]

3 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

McAdoo isn’t perfect but hes been better without Rhule in charge.

It would have been nice to see him under these new circumstances, but hey…

 

It would have been nice to see him with Boseman and this now blocking offensive line.

[ForJimmy]

If was a good trade for a RB.  Our staff couldn't get that production from him and our cheap vet RB just had over 100 yards and several TDs.  We put up 34 points on offense.