Jump to content
  • Welcome!

    Register and log in easily with Twitter or Google accounts!

    Or simply create a new Huddle account. 

    Members receive fewer ads , access our dark theme, and the ability to join the discussion!

     

What’s your 2023 QB big board (including Corral)


Wundrbread33
 Share

Recommended Posts

40 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

I think you would have to agree though that the damn near microscopic number of reps he got in camp would have made it difficult for just about anybody to look good.

I'm not just talking about his play. I'm talking about simply looking like he athletically belonged. He looked like a guy who was simply overwhelmed by being on the field with better athletes. I didn't see any traits translating for him. That's the thing about guys who belong. Even if everything around them is shot you can see signs. I didn't see any signs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, DaveThePanther2008 said:

Thanks, you beat me to it.  

I don't doubt we'll draft a QB but that's all I will agree to.  I think Corral will have a TRUE QB competition if we do. 

The problem is Corral is going to be a year ahead of any of these rookies when they actually get here. He will have the advantage which makes another QB less likely. They intend to develop him. They said that. People weren't listening. It's just the same fan drool over QBs when they get the top pick, which we haven't.

If Corral beats the in coming QB we've passed on perhaps a star DE or whoever and wasted that pick. They do have a lot of capital in multiple picks so IF it's Levis and that's who they want, who knows, or they could use those extra picks/players to get two picks in the first or second.

The Rhule school of "competition" in the NFL is a farce. Everyone should know who's starting, if you don't, you're Matt Rhule and not the 31 other NFL coaches.

 

 

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

I'm not just talking about his play. I'm talking about simply looking like he athletically belonged. He looked like a guy who was simply overwhelmed by being on the field with better athletes. I didn't see any traits translating for him. That's the thing about guys who belong. Even if everything around them is shot you can see signs. I didn't see any signs.

Isn't that kind of what you'd expect a rookie with no practice reps to look like though?

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

You have an example of an injured 3rd qb competing with a highly drafted rookie qb?   

An injured QB that has as many good traits as any highly drafted rookie QB.  It's your opinion and though I respect it, it's not how things will play out.

You have no idea how a new coach will evaluate Corral, nor do I, but the fact that we drafted him but our inept coach failed to give him a real opportunity makes it difficult to decide.

I'm not saying Corral is any better than those in this draft but I am saying he will be evaluated as one of these picks.  Of course, his injury status will have a bearing on it but he'll get a chance to compete, when healthy.   You also need to be reminded that the true competition doesn't start until training camp.  OTA's and minicamps offer very little contact.

We're just going to have to agree to disagree because I'm not changing your approach and you're not going to change mine. 

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

You have an example of an injured 3rd qb competing with a highly drafted rookie qb?   

You do this a lot; where you speak in absolutes and ask people to go above and beyond to show proof of things that ultimately don’t matter anyway. 
 

If you spoke in probabilities then the conversation is fine, but you don’t do so. 
 

The Tom Brady example is tiresome, but useful because everyone knows about it. 
 

A fan could have been excited about Tom in the 6th round, and another fan could oppose them saying “How many QB’s in the 6th round have lasted in the league at all let alone won a Super Bowl. Short list. Therefore Tom won’t be anything.”

And then he did it. The past can be fun for conversation, but it doesn’t really matter. Like Ohio St. quarterbacks suck in the NFL…until one doesn’t. 
 

Being “realistic” would be saying, “it’s highly unlikely that Corral, coming off an injury with, likely, a new coach, would get a chance on this team.”

Not absolutes. 
 

The closest thing to an absolute, is that you, and me, aren’t as knowledgeable as we think we are. 

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, DaveThePanther2008 said:

An injured QB that has as many good traits as any highly drafted rookie QB.  It's your opinion and though I respect it, it's not how things will play out.

You have no idea how a new coach will evaluate Corral, nor do I, but the fact that we drafted him but our inept coach failed to give him a real opportunity makes it difficult to decide.

I'm not saying Corral is any better than those in this draft but I am saying he will be evaluated as one of these picks.  Of course, his injury status will have a bearing on it but he'll get a chance to compete, when healthy.   You also need to be reminded that the true competition doesn't start until training camp.  OTA's and minicamps offer very little contact.

We're just going to have to agree to disagree because I'm not changing your approach and you're not going to change mine. 

The new coach will evaluate corral as a 3rd rounder who cannot even practice until august.  Not just my opinion but fact.   

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, rippadonn said:

If Corral beats the in coming QB we've passed on perhaps a star DE or whoever and wasted that pick. They do have a lot of capital in multiple picks so IF it's Levis and that's who they want, who knows, or they could use those extra picks/players to get two picks in the first or second.

Totally agree.

This is where the HC (Wilks or someone new) will have to truly evaluate the 2023 class against Corral's traits.  They may choose to go with that elite position over a QB and take a QB at 32. 

It's a dilemma that Rhule put us in by treating Corral the way he did.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, LinvilleGorge said:

Again, in simply taking about how he physically looked out there, not play. He didn't look like he belonged in terms of physical tools.

I get what you're saying. I just think it's hard to judge anything significant about him given the circumstances.

Again, I wouldn't pass on drafting a quarterback, but I really don't think we truly know much of anything about Corral.

Edited by Mr. Scot
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Wundrbread33 said:

You do this a lot; where you speak in absolutes and ask people to go above and beyond to show proof of things that ultimately don’t matter anyway. 
 

If you spoke in probabilities then the conversation is fine, but you don’t do so. 
 

The Tom Brady example is tiresome, but useful because everyone knows about it. 
 

A fan could have been excited about Tom in the 6th round, and another fan could oppose them saying “How many QB’s in the 6th round have lasted in the league at all let alone won a Super Bowl. Short list. Therefore Tom won’t be anything.”

And then he did it. The past can be fun for conversation, but it doesn’t really matter. Like Ohio St. quarterbacks suck in the NFL…until one doesn’t. 
 

Being “realistic” would be saying, “it’s highly unlikely that Corral, coming off an injury with, likely, a new coach, would get a chance on this team.”

Not absolutes. 
 

The closest thing to an absolute, is that you, and me, aren’t as knowledgeable as we think we are. 

I tend to form my opinions on things that have or haven’t happened in the past consistently.   A second year injured player beating out a highly drafted rookie qb is unheard of.   It’s not the norm and most certainly not how coaching staffs handle a top rookie.  There is no competition it’s just all about getting the qb up to speed.   Hanging your hat and forming opinions on aberrations is not a good way to go through life.    the data is the data.  
 

Edited by mrcompletely11
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, mrcompletely11 said:

The new coach will evaluate corral as a 3rd rounder who cannot even practice until august.  Not just my opinion but fact.   

So without knowing who will be the head coach, who will be the coordinator/QB coach, what offense they prefer to implement, never speaking with Fitt or Morgan, nor the scouting department…

 

This is a fact?

  • Pie 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Wundrbread33 said:

So without knowing who will be the head coach, who will be the coordinator/QB coach, what offense they prefer to implement, never speaking with Fitt or Morgan, nor the scouting department…

 

This is a fact?

The fact is he is hurt and cannot practice until aug.  it doesn’t matter who the coach is.   That’s a fact.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, mrcompletely11 said:

I tend to form my opinions on things that have or haven’t happened in the past consistently.   A second year injured player beating out a highly drafted rookie qb is unheard of.   It’s not the norm and most certainly not how coaching staffs handle a top rookie.  There is no competition it’s just all about getting the qb up to speed.   Hanging your hat on and forming opinions on aberrations is not a good way to go through life.    the data is the data.  
 

At least you admit that when you speak in absolutes, that’s just how you convey your opinions. It’s a rather abrasive way to do so, but now I know the baseline. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


  • PMH4OWPW7JD2TDGWZKTOYL2T3E.jpg

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Even 49ers/Dophins type offense requires a quarterback to complete high school throws, which Bryce simply can't do. 
    • The bolded paragraph basically confirms that our players know what most fans have also known for quite sometime: Bryce is the problem.   Panthers lose, but there’s a different vibe since Andy Dalton replaced Bryce Young Joseph Person CHARLOTTE, N.C. — When Joe Burrow and a desperate Cincinnati Bengals team were putting up touchdowns quicker than department store Christmas displays in late September, you figured the Carolina Panthers were headed toward Blowout City. Down 31-14 late in the third quarter, another Panthers team — like the one from a few weeks ago — would have folded up, eaten a 30-point loss and tried to beat the traffic out of Bank of America Stadium. Instead, the Panthers scored on consecutive possessions, handed Burrow his first interception of the season and pulled within a touchdown midway through the fourth quarter. And while the Panthers didn’t hand Burrow a fourth loss to start the season, they at least kept things competitive Sunday before falling 34-24. And when you’re coming off a 2-15 season and just benched last year’s No. 1 pick two games into this one, that will have to suffice. “I don’t call it a moral victory. A loss is a loss,” cornerback Jaycee Horn said. “But at the end of the day, you could feel the vibe that we’re getting better as a team. Can’t deny that. We’re gonna find a way to shake back and go out there next week and get a dub.” Carolina coach Dave Canales speaks with QB Andy Dalton during the game Sunday as Bryce Young looks on. (Bob Donnan / Imagn Images_ The most obvious difference is at quarterback, where Andy Dalton wasn’t as on-point as he was in Vegas but still turned in a “solid day” at the office, as first-year coach Dave Canales called it. Canales isn’t asking Dalton to do too much: Get the Panthers in the right play, try to hit the first read and don’t put the ball in jeopardy. Whether it’s lingering effects from his 62-sack rookie season or something else, those are things Bryce Young wasn’t doing as the Panthers started 0-2 while being outscored 73-13. And when the quarterback isn’t playing well, it has a way of sucking the energy out of an entire organization. But there was a different feeling Sunday at Bank of America Stadium, where the Panthers went toe-to-toe with an AFC team that has a franchise quarterback and playoff expectations. Also of note: No fans were seen with bags over their heads or heard chanting for the owner to sell the team. Progress. “I think something flipped,” right guard Robert Hunt said. “We’re just trying to win some games. Guys are clicking. We never felt out of it today. We were saying the whole time, ‘We’re about to go down and win this game.’ Unfortunately, it didn’t go our way.” What flipped is the quarterback, though players don’t want to call out Young because they like him and voted him a team captain less than a month ago. Plus, they might need him if something in Dalton’s 36-year-old body stretches or snaps the way it did Sunday for veteran linebackers Shaq Thompson and Josey Jewell. But Canales has indicated he plans to ride Dalton as long as he’s producing, much like rookie receiver Xavier Legette rode his imaginary horse — inspired by his actual horse named Dolla Bill — back to the sideline Sunday following his first career touchdown. Legette’s performance against the Bengals personified where the Panthers (1-3) are nearly a quarter of a season into the Canales/Dan Morgan era. The former South Carolina wideout, drafted with the last pick in the first round, caught six passes (matching his total from the first three games) for 66 yards and the TD. But he also had two of the handful of drops by Panthers receivers and tight ends, a couple of which came in key spots (Diontae Johnson in the end zone on the first drive; Feleipe Franks on a fake punt that would have extended a drive). The roster might not be teeming with Pro Bowlers, but there is talent here. Like Legette, it’s about cleaning up the details. “I wouldn’t really say it’s a healthy loss because the two drops that I had, that’s the difference between winning and losing,” Legette said. “If I would have made those plays, we would have been able to stay on the field and maybe get a touchdown to win the game.” GO DEEPER Bengals top Panthers 34-24 for first win of season: Takeaways There were other examples of those little things that usually separate the winners and losers on Sundays: • Shoddy tackling on a pair of Cincinnati touchdown receptions, including a pitiful showing on a Ja’Marr Chase 63-yarder in which Xavier Woods, Charles Harris and Troy Hill all whiffed. • The offensive line failing to deliver Chuba Hubbard into the end zone on three tries from 2 yards or closer (sandwiched around that fade to Johnson on second-and-goal). • Pass rushers that never sacked Burrow and barely made him sweat, the one exception being a Jadeveon Clowney pressure that forced Burrow into a poor throw that Woods intercepted. • Nick Thurman jumping offside on third-and-4 after the Panthers had climbed back within a TD. • All those drops, including two deep balls that ticked off Johnson’s fingertips. “I’ve just gotta have those, gotta come down with those,” Johnson said. “It comes down to the details. What could I have done better to get more separation or (win) at the catch point?” The sooner the Panthers hammer out the fine points, the better. Because while there are some upcoming games they could steal, beginning next weekend in Chicago, the post-Munich portion of the schedule could get ugly, especially if the injury news on Thompson is bad. In the meantime, the uber-positive Canales will keep preaching process … and progress. That was his message Sunday. “For me just talking to the team, encouraged that our football continues to improve,” he said. “But we’ve gotta finish and we have to execute. And it all starts with me as the head coach.” It starts with the head coach and the quarterback. And if nothing else, the Panthers are in better shape than they were two weeks ago. Dalton was a workmanlike 25-of-40 for 220 yards with two touchdowns and an interception. The pick came in the first half when Trey Hendrickson beat Ikem Ekwonu and hit Dalton’s arm as he was releasing. It also looked like Dalton could have stepped up more in the pocket; Canales said he’d have to see the film. Like many of his teammates, Dalton said the mojo around the team is different, even if it didn’t result in a win Sunday. “I definitely feel it. I think just what this team has been through the last several years, I mean, we were in this game until the very end,” Dalton said. “I think for us, it’s like, all right, how can we change that? When we get to be in these moments where we have a chance to win — go drive down and win the game.” (Top photo of Diontae Johnson: Matt Kelley / Getty Images)
    • Holy poo, 2023 may be our worst draft ever.
×
×
  • Create New...