what former Panther do you wish had succeeded while in Carolina?

[panthersphan]

Keyshawn Johnson

[ricketycricket]

jovan haye

[megadeth078]

Dan Morgan of course

[panthers55]

Taye Biddle.

Loved me some Taye Biddle.

[Cavscout]

Blake Brockermeyer

[Jangler]

Not David Carr.

I thought about him, I actually would have liked him to have played better.

[cookinbrak]

Fred Lane

[Ncstatefan]

Carter and Morgan

[Murph]

Most of the names listed so far would be in the top 20 if we were doing a ranking. For me it was Jeffers. He was special to watch when he was on fire.

[mwandmw]

I have to agree with the folks who said Dan Morgan... Nobody gave what Morgan gave. He never quit, probably much to his demise... He was also great with kids and represented the organization positively. What more could he have done that he had control over????

[damo md panthers fan]

I'm going to say Deshaun Foster. He had so much promise coming out of college. He had a kick ass super bowl season, and then the fat lady sung on his career with us. He was a flash in the pan. A close second would be Justin Hartwig. He just blew ass while he wsa here. In tennessee he was awesome, hell he's kickin ass in Pittsburg. Why football gods WHY?

[Steel Panther]

Rae Carruth. He COULD have been our FIRST "Steve Smith", but blew with bad character and poor judgment. The potential was great, though.

[GRWatcher]

Timmy B. and Dan Morgan for sure. Watching TB was like watching DeAngelo now .... anytime he touched the ball, you held your breath expecting something big to happen.

Our lb's are now the heart and strength of our defense, I wouldn't trade any one of them for any other player in the NFL now. But I sure do miss Mark Fields. He had a nose for being in the right place at the right time. He almost always was able to contain Vick and any other scrambling qb all by himself. He was smart and he was fast. Jon Beason reminds me of Fields many times.

[Zod]

There is one correct answer here.

That answer is Keary Colbert.

If Colbert was a legit 2nd option, we would have won the 2005 superbowl. Seattle would not have been able to put 4 guys on Smitty and render us helpless in the NFC champ game.

/thread.