What's worse: Saints going 16-0 or Panthers going 4-12?

[SCP]

Awesome!

[Matt Foley]

Oh when the Saints...go marching in

Oh when the Saints go marching in

How I want to be in that number

when the Saints go marching in

[SCP]

What has happened to you Meat? Did last nights speech have that big of an impact on you?

[Swarly]

4-12 season by far.. what makes people think that everyone will respect a 16-0 season if they fail in playoffs?

last time I checked, every single patriots game the announcers bring up their 16-0 season, and lead up to a "and then that loss to the Giants in the superbowl.."

Regular season doesn't mean SHIT if you don't get a championship out of it.

[PhillyB]

ugh, 16-0 Saints would be infinitely worse. the only way i'll see this season as any kind of success for the Panthers is if we notch that one loss in the Saints' W/L record.

"Undefeated!!!!!!! ...wait... ...Panthers. Damn."

[guyinchesapeake]

I'm not going to begrudge the success of another team. The 'Aints have been bad for so long that I have no problem with them tasting some success! I actually pull for the other division teams if they make the playoffs when we don't, we know them better than anyone, and vice versa. We haven't done anything this year, we haven't earned anything. They have. Let them enjoy it and go with it!

I think it would be quite intriguing if the 'Aints stay undefeated, and the Colts do too! Assuming that continued thru the playoffs, imagine THAT Super Bowl, with TWO undefeated teams! I don't think that's going to happen, I believe both teams will lose a game or two, if nothing else because they will face that "do you rest your starters?" dilemma over the last couple games or so of the regular season. But that would still be something to see, both teams undefeated in the SB!

[Jbro]

Why does one have to be worse then the other? Can they not just both suck?

[X-Clown]

I pick the Saints going 16-0, because really, what's the difference between 7-9, 6-10, 5-11, and 4-12? None of those records are going to make the playoffs (and they are likely where our team will end up) If anything a 4-12 record gets us a higher draft pick in the 2nd and other rounds to give us a shot at getting more impact players. To be clear, this is not the same as me saying that I want us to go 4-12 (since I know some people will read as such).

[Captroop]

I pick the Saints going 16-0, because really, what's the difference between 7-9, 6-10, 5-11, and 4-12? None of those records are going to make the playoffs (and they are likely where our team will end up) If anything a 4-12 record gets us a higher draft pick in the 2nd and other rounds to give us a shot at getting more impact players. To be clear, this is not the same as me saying that I want us to go 4-12 (since I know some people will read as such).

And once again, let me restate: ask a player if there is a difference between losing out and winning one or two games to end the season. If you had asked the 2001 Panthers in Week 13 if they would rather finish 1 and 15 or watch the Buccaneers win the Super Bowl, any of them would have traded their left nut for one more win.

[SCP]

Why does one have to be worse then the other? Can they not just both suck?

Then a poll would be pointless.

[Guest DrewBreesIsGod]

I would think that you going 4-12 would be worse than us going 16-0...I mean that would put you what, 12 games behind?

[X-Clown]

And once again, let me restate: ask a player if there is a difference between losing out and winning one or two games to end the season. If you had asked the 2001 Panthers in Week 13 if they would rather finish 1 and 15 or watch the Buccaneers win the Super Bowl, any of them would have traded their left nut for one more win.

But you're not asking players - you're asking Panther fans who post on the huddle. There is a difference.

[Gscottnc5]

I could care less if the Saints go 16-0. If they do they deserve it.

As far as their fans, If the Saints go 16-0, I will hate their fans even more because they don't know how to be modest.

[SCP]

I would think that you going 4-12 would be worse than us going 16-0...I mean that would put you what, 12 games behind?

This is why I hate you assholes. This is why I hope you lose.