Ellis Williams write up Day 5. Baker vs Sam

[raleigh-panther]

 

Baker Mayfield vs. Sam Darnold, Day 5: Tracking Panthers quarterbacks at training camp

BY ELLIS L. WILLIAMS

[email protected]     5 hours ago

The pads came on for the first time on Monday as Carolina opened Day 5 of training camp. 

Coach Matt Rhule said he’d gain a better understanding of where quarterbacks Sam Darnold and Baker Mayfield were offensively once the second week of camp started. 

Mayfield and Darnold are competing to be the team’s starting quarterback and once again rotated reps. Darnold worked more heavily with the first team. Rhule said that will flip on Tuesday, similar to how the quarterbacks alternated last week.

Despite working mostly with the second team, Mayfield had his sharpest practice yet. 

Let’s dive deeper into their performances.

Baker Mayfield

Stats (unofficial): 10 of 12, 3 TDs 

Practicing in pads for the first time allowed Carolina to sprinkle in more runs. Because of that, Mayfield attempted twice as many throws as Darnold. Mayfield took advantage of each throwing opportunity by maximizing both his explosive throws and efficiency. 

There was a lot to like from No. 6. Early in practice, he hit second-year receiver Terrace Marshall on a comeback route down the right sideline. The 12-yard completion came via play-action. Mayfield is doing an excellent job controlling his eyes on dropbacks. His helmet stays down the middle until he’s ready to unload on his first read.

When Marshall opened, Mayfield snapped his head right and sniped a high and outside ball. Marshall extended, making the toe-taping diving catch. 

The duo wasn’t done. A few players later Mayfield hit Marshall on a deep over route for a gain of 25. Marshall started on the right of the formation and then worked over the linebackers and between a safety until Mayfield found him. It was the longest play of the day for Carolina’s offense. 

Mayfield’s effective day continued during the team’s red zone session. He threw touchdowns to Rashard Higgins and tight end Colin Thompson off play-action drops. He nearly scored with slot receiver Shi Smith but the pass was completed just short of the goal line.

Best throw:

His 25-yard completion to Marshall was textbook. Mayfield demonstrated sound patience and eye control standing in a messy pocket. However, his touchdown to Higgins popped too. Higgins started in the slot to Mayfield’s right. After a quick check, Mayfield took the snap. Higgins opened immediately on a quick slant and Mayfield delivered a precise ball high and in front of Higgins for an easy score. 

Notable mistake: 

Mayfield played cleanly on Day 5. After practice, he acknowledged his sloppy play from Saturday and made up for it with his most efficient practice yet. 

Sam Darnold

Stats (unofficial): 3 of 6, TD, Rush TD, Fumble

Coming into training camp, Darnold said his goal was to build upon each practice and steadily improve each day. It’s cliche but actually is the best way for a quarterback to handle an open competition. He did not do that on Monday, instead his opportunities were fumbled (once literally) by either his receivers not getting open against the Panthers’ No. 1 defense or him missing assignments. 

He showcased his athleticism on multiple plays, taking off when things broke down. During a red zone session, offensive coordinator Ben McAdoo even called a designed quarterback keeper which Darnold converted. Mayfield likely never gets that play called for him.

But six throws is not enough to win a day of practice amid a quarterback competition.

Best throw:

Darnold connected with Smith for a red-zone touchdown on a designed quarterback bootleg. Smith motioned across the formation and opened at the line of scrimmage as Darnold reached the perimeter. The smooth pitch-and-catch ended in Darnold and Smith congratulating each other in the end zone. 

Notable mistake: 

Darnold had two fumbles on Monday. After practice coach Rhule said Darnold’s second fumble was actually a forward pass intended for running back D’Onta Foreman. A fumble or not, Darnold failed to execute consecutive red-zone run plays. The confirmed fumble came via a read-option exchange with backup Spencer Brown. 

Who won the day?

Mayfield brought his best practice to Wofford College to start Week 2 of Panthers training camp. After practice, he admitted that the playbook is not “second nature” to him yet but he is making significant progress.

[top dawg]

5 minutes ago, raleigh-panther said:

 

Baker Mayfield vs. Sam Darnold, Day 5: Tracking Panthers quarterbacks at training camp

BY ELLIS L. WILLIAMS

[email protected]     5 hours ago

The pads came on for the first time on Monday as Carolina opened Day 5 of training camp. 

Coach Matt Rhule said he’d gain a better understanding of where quarterbacks Sam Darnold and Baker Mayfield were offensively once the second week of camp started. 

Mayfield and Darnold are competing to be the team’s starting quarterback and once again rotated reps. Darnold worked more heavily with the first team. Rhule said that will flip on Tuesday, similar to how the quarterbacks alternated last week.

Despite working mostly with the second team, Mayfield had his sharpest practice yet. 

Let’s dive deeper into their performances.

Baker Mayfield

Stats (unofficial): 10 of 12, 3 TDs 

Practicing in pads for the first time allowed Carolina to sprinkle in more runs. Because of that, Mayfield attempted twice as many throws as Darnold. Mayfield took advantage of each throwing opportunity by maximizing both his explosive throws and efficiency. 

There was a lot to like from No. 6. Early in practice, he hit second-year receiver Terrace Marshall on a comeback route down the right sideline. The 12-yard completion came via play-action. Mayfield is doing an excellent job controlling his eyes on dropbacks. His helmet stays down the middle until he’s ready to unload on his first read.

When Marshall opened, Mayfield snapped his head right and sniped a high and outside ball. Marshall extended, making the toe-taping diving catch. 

The duo wasn’t done. A few players later Mayfield hit Marshall on a deep over route for a gain of 25. Marshall started on the right of the formation and then worked over the linebackers and between a safety until Mayfield found him. It was the longest play of the day for Carolina’s offense. 

Mayfield’s effective day continued during the team’s red zone session. He threw touchdowns to Rashard Higgins and tight end Colin Thompson off play-action drops. He nearly scored with slot receiver Shi Smith but the pass was completed just short of the goal line.

Best throw:

His 25-yard completion to Marshall was textbook. Mayfield demonstrated sound patience and eye control standing in a messy pocket. However, his touchdown to Higgins popped too. Higgins started in the slot to Mayfield’s right. After a quick check, Mayfield took the snap. Higgins opened immediately on a quick slant and Mayfield delivered a precise ball high and in front of Higgins for an easy score. 

Notable mistake: 

Mayfield played cleanly on Day 5. After practice, he acknowledged his sloppy play from Saturday and made up for it with his most efficient practice yet. 

Sam Darnold

Stats (unofficial): 3 of 6, TD, Rush TD, Fumble

Coming into training camp, Darnold said his goal was to build upon each practice and steadily improve each day. It’s cliche but actually is the best way for a quarterback to handle an open competition. He did not do that on Monday, instead his opportunities were fumbled (once literally) by either his receivers not getting open against the Panthers’ No. 1 defense or him missing assignments. 

He showcased his athleticism on multiple plays, taking off when things broke down. During a red zone session, offensive coordinator Ben McAdoo even called a designed quarterback keeper which Darnold converted. Mayfield likely never gets that play called for him.

But six throws is not enough to win a day of practice amid a quarterback competition.

Best throw:

Darnold connected with Smith for a red-zone touchdown on a designed quarterback bootleg. Smith motioned across the formation and opened at the line of scrimmage as Darnold reached the perimeter. The smooth pitch-and-catch ended in Darnold and Smith congratulating each other in the end zone. 

Notable mistake: 

Darnold had two fumbles on Monday. After practice coach Rhule said Darnold’s second fumble was actually a forward pass intended for running back D’Onta Foreman. A fumble or not, Darnold failed to execute consecutive red-zone run plays. The confirmed fumble came via a read-option exchange with backup Spencer Brown. 

Who won the day?

Mayfield brought his best practice to Wofford College to start Week 2 of Panthers training camp. After practice, he admitted that the playbook is not “second nature” to him yet but he is making significant progress.

I expect day 2 tomorrow now. Thanks.

[Jackie Lee]

Ellis Williams the next Observer journalist to get poached by another city. Only person doing legit football write ups for this team

[raleigh-panther]

29 minutes ago, Jackie Lee said:

Ellis Williams the next Observer journalist to get poached by another city. Only person doing legit football write ups for this team

Yep

and  he is the one that said the Panthers needed to sign ‘Baker sooner rather than later’ and that made a lot of posters on here lose their minds 

lol

Edited August 2, 2022 by raleigh-panther

[Jackie Lee]

1 minute ago, raleigh-panther said:

Yep

and  he is the one that said the Panthers needed to sign ‘Baker sooner rather than later’ and that made a lot of posters on here lose their minds 

lol

And he covered the Browns before getting the job here, so he knows Baker is at a minimum an upgrade over Darnold. Even if the 2 had similar stats I'll take the guy that will talk poo and get his team hyped over ho-hum Darnold

[Adb6368]

This is the first thing I’ve read that has definitely names one looking better than the other. That is a good thing that is for the best. One of them needs to stand out. Anything but a definitive answer to this will only cause problems the first ounce of adversity that arises during the year 

[Jared Patterson]

Yes. Was told Mayfield looked good today and you guys know I am not a fan of both. Darnold needs to be moved somehow, someway. No point to still have him on the roster if you traded for another guy and that guy beats him out. Corral has looked plenty good to be the back up this year and Rhule isn't gonna cut his Temple boy. 

[RJK]

I get they want to practice it and make sure it’s blocked up right but you can hardly give darnold credit for rushing TD when the defense literally isn’t allowed to touch him.

[Jared Patterson]

Just because Baker looks better than Darnold doesn't mean a lot though, that's my overall point. Baker struggles w pressure severely. Luckily our oline has much improved if Rhule just gets Michael Jordan and Pat Assliein tf out of there.

[Jackie Lee]

If Darnold wants to turn into a safe check down QB we could have just kept Teddy. If it's gonna be another questionable season at least let us watch a gunslinger like Mayfield fight for his career out there, and if that's not working out let Corral finish the last few games

[4Corners]

Love Ellis 

[MillionDollarCam]

Hope Baker keeps it up, for what it’s worth he seems to rotate between good and bad seasons…

2018 - 27 TD’s & 14 INT’s, 93.7 QB rating - Baker played good ball but the Browns defense really poo the bed, not unheard of for a rookie QB to be turnover prone.

2019 - 22 TD’s & 21 INT’s, 78.8 QB rating - Baker’s turnovers kept the Browns from being competitive

2020 - 26 TD’s & 8 INT’s, 95.9 QB rating - Best year of Baker’s career, led the Browns to the playoffs

2021 - 17 TD’s & 13 INT’s, 83.1 QB rating - Between the turnovers, injuries, and all the commotion about whether or not Baker can be a franchise QB, this was probably his worst year

2022 - ??? - It seems it’s time for another Baker breakout year

[AlphabetsEnd]

16 minutes ago, MillionDollarCam said:

2019 - 22 TD’s & 21 INT’s, 78.8 QB rating - Baker’s turnovers kept the Browns from being competitive

Uh, no. That was the Freddie Kitchens year and the entire team, from coach on down, kept them from being competitive. 

[Verge]

Great write up @ellis. It will be great to have a QB who is not scared to take his time and take shots down the field.