REPORT: Steve Reed reports "the Panthers are still interested in" Jimmy Garoppolo

[poundaway]

 

[poundaway]

9 hours ago, ForJimmy said:

You have a strange notation that if a team makes one mistake they are destined to make mistakes over and over again. 

Actually you're the one with the strange notion that if QB moves on, he must suck.  I listed a bunch examples.  You then clung to team evaulation, and I pointed out how the 9ers have fncked up eval before.

JimmyG is a good QB.  Right now we have Sam, possibly the worst in the league, and 3rd round rookie.  JimmyG would be a much better mentor for Corral.

We will win more games with JimmyG.

 

[Mr. Scot]

1 hour ago, poundaway said:

Actually you're the one with the strange notion that if QB moves on, he must suck.  I listed a bunch examples.  You then clung to team evaulation, and I pointed out how the 9ers have fncked up eval before.

JimmyG is a good QB.  Right now we have Sam, possibly the worst in the league, and 3rd round rookie.  JimmyG would be a much better mentor for Corral.

We will win more games with JimmyG.

 

Quoting again from Jonathan Alexander's Observer article...

Garoppolo’s recent shoulder surgery, as well as his injury history, is a far greater concern for some within the organization. The Panthers want no part of his $26.9 million salary, and the 49ers haven’t shown a willingness to take to carry those payments in a trade.

[TLGPanthersFan]

4 hours ago, poundaway said:

Actually you're the one with the strange notion that if QB moves on, he must suck.  I listed a bunch examples.  You then clung to team evaulation, and I pointed out how the 9ers have fncked up eval before.

JimmyG is a good QB.  Right now we have Sam, possibly the worst in the league, and 3rd round rookie.  JimmyG would be a much better mentor for Corral.

We will win more games with JimmyG.

 

No he is not. He was carried by his team. 

[SizzleBuzz]

1 hour ago, TLGPanthersFan said:

6 hours ago, poundaway said:

Actually you're the one with the strange notion that if QB moves on, he must suck.  I listed a bunch examples.  You then clung to team evaulation, and I pointed out how the 9ers have fncked up eval before.

JimmyG is a good QB.  Right now we have Sam, possibly the worst in the league, and 3rd round rookie.  JimmyG would be a much better mentor for Corral.

We will win more games with JimmyG.

 

Expand  

No he is not. He was carried by his team. 

His record shows the exact opposite...

[ForJimmy]

7 hours ago, SizzleBuzz said:

His record shows the exact opposite...

Just like Teddy in Minnesota!  Let's try THAT again... 

[ForJimmy]

14 hours ago, poundaway said:

Actually you're the one with the strange notion that if QB moves on, he must suck.  I listed a bunch examples.  You then clung to team evaulation, and I pointed out how the 9ers have fncked up eval before.

JimmyG is a good QB.  Right now we have Sam, possibly the worst in the league, and 3rd round rookie.  JimmyG would be a much better mentor for Corral.

We will win more games with JimmyG.

 

But Jimmy G isn't the one wanting to move on.  His team wants to move on from him even if he wants to stay.  As Mr Scot just shared we don't want to pay his salary which is reflective of a good QB.  I wonder why that is???  In fact it doesn't look like ANY team is wanting to pay that salary for a subpar QB... 

[poundaway]

 The 9ers are 31-14 with JimmyG. Shanahan is 8-28 without JimmyG. They went to the Super Bowl and 2 NFC Championship games in the last 3 years.  He had the 9th highest passer rating at 98.7 last year. Higher than Mahomes, Herbert, Josh Allen, and Tannehill.

Naaah.  We're too good for him.

Whatever.

[ForJimmy]

49 minutes ago, poundaway said:

 The 9ers are 31-14 with JimmyG. Shanahan is 8-28 without JimmyG. They went to the Super Bowl and 2 NFC Championship games in the last 3 years.  He had the 9th highest passer rating at 98.7 last year. Higher than Mahomes, Herbert, Josh Allen, and Tannehill.

Naaah.  We're too good for him.

Whatever.

Lol look what happens in the playoffs.  They win but he shits the bed, they needed a blocked punt for a TD to get score so they could beat GB in which Jimmy had a QBR of 11.  Hell Sam could have gotten a rating of 11.  His win against Dallas 0 TDs 1 INT and under 200 yards passing.  He looked better against the Rams, but threw the game deciding INT to lose the game.  

Teddy's regular season passer rating was 94.9 last year landing him just a couple spots behind Jimmy.  Jimmy dinks and dunks/checkdowns just like Teddy (I think someone posted he was 29th in yards per attempt).  It gives them a good rating, but when the game is on the line they can't make the plays to win.  There is a reason why he is STILL available.  If he was so great we would all be wanting him and there would be a bidding war for him right now.  

We aren't "too good" for him.  It's just a waste of resources to trade for a mediocre QB that is basically Teddy 2.0 just to get a couple more wins.  We need to develop Corral or draft our next franchise QB next year. 

[poundaway]

2 hours ago, ForJimmy said:

  Jimmy dinks and dunks/checkdowns just like Teddy (I think someone posted he was 29th in yards per attempt). 

https://nextgenstats.nfl.com/stats/passing#average-completed-yards

He has the 13th LONGEST air yards per completion at 5.9, longer than  Herbert, Murray, Ryan, Brady and yes Bridgewater.

You can mindlessly hate the guy.  I don't care.  We will win more games with him.  The 9ers lose when he doesn't play. 

[ForJimmy]

On 5/22/2022 at 8:41 PM, CRA said:

Jimmy G - Average Intended Air Yards per pass attempt 

2021- 29th

2020 - 40th

2019 - 37th 

He is the king of checkdown offense.  It’s why the 49ers gave up 3 first round picks for a Trey Lance.  If Jimmy G was good….Trey Lance wouldn’t be in SF.  Especially not for 3 first round picks. 

We could of just kept Teddy this entire time.  Saved a bunch of draft picks.  

@poundaway

[X-Clown]

On 5/21/2022 at 2:56 PM, SizzleBuzz said:

You are what your record says you are...

...and the Jimmy-G man is a #winner.

Jared Goff was too….and yet the Rams couldn’t wait to that trade that “winner” for a “loser” like Matthew Stafford. 

[SizzleBuzz]

3 minutes ago, X-Clown said:

Jared Goff was too….and yet the Rams couldn’t wait to that trade that “winner” for a “loser” like Matthew Stafford. 

the begrudgers... (#FTB)

[ForJimmy]

15 minutes ago, poundaway said:

https://nextgenstats.nfl.com/stats/passing#average-completed-yards

He has the 13th LONGEST air yards per completion at 5.9, longer than  Herbert, Murray, Ryan, Brady and yes Bridgewater.

You can mindlessly hate the guy.  I don't care.  We will win more games with him.  The 9ers lose when he doesn't play. 

The Niners lose when the person that is backing up Jimmy G has to play correct.  You really like these stats out of context.  Who was their starting QBs in these loses?  Replace him with a capable QB and you could have a Rams/Stafford moment with that team.  I posted what CRA shared with us in this thread and Intended Air Yards Per Attempt.  

Do you care to comment on his playoff performances?  Winning one or two more games so Rhule can try to keep his job isn't the best play for the Panthers.  Jimmy is already on his 3rd team by age 30 and we would be number 4.  I don't hate him, but let's actually learn from our mistakes and not keep repeating them with other team's castoff QBs.  I don't hate Sam Darnold, but I understand he isn't the future of the Panthers and the same goes for Jimmy.