REPORT: Steve Reed reports "the Panthers are still interested in" Jimmy Garoppolo

[poundaway]

3 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

When did I say you can't keep one that has requested a trade?  I said Russ and Stafford were traded because they requested it. 

What does that fuging matter?

[poundaway]

18 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

There are several. Here's one:

Back when Brady was a free agent two years ago he wanted to join up with the 49ers. They were his first choice before the Buccaneers ended up winning his favor. Alas, the 49ers elected not to pursue Brady after consideration. They decided that sticking with Jimmy Garoppolo, fresh off of a Super Bowl appearance, was the best move for them going forward. 

SI.com

It's one reason why many believe the "y'all are gonna stick with that motherf--ker" comment was referencing the 49ers and Garoppolo.

So we have an opportunity to get a QB that the 9ers considered better than Brady?

[ForJimmy]

Just now, poundaway said:

What does that fuging matter?

Why does it matter?  They were no longer interested in playing for their teams so they traded them for a return while they could.  Why would a team want a QB playing for them that isn't interested?  That's much different than a team telling a QB in his prime, they are no longer interested in him playing for their franchise and trying to trade him (with no results so far).  That's basically what we did with Teddy.  Do you think the Lions or Seahawks would have traded 3 first rounders to move up and take a QB then randomly put Stafford/Russ on the trade block?  ESPN and us fans would be so confused.  The Niners did it and no one batted an eye because we all know Jimmy G was their weakness.  Elite defense, strong running game and then your QB keeps throwing INTs in the playoffs.  Hmmm what can they do to make this team better???

[poundaway]

21 minutes ago, Mr. Scot said:

There are several. Here's one:

Back when Brady was a free agent two years ago he wanted to join up with the 49ers. They were his first choice before the Buccaneers ended up winning his favor. Alas, the 49ers elected not to pursue Brady after consideration. They decided that sticking with Jimmy Garoppolo, fresh off of a Super Bowl appearance, was the best move for them going forward. 

SI.com

It's one reason why many believe the "y'all are gonna stick with that motherf--ker" comment was referencing the 49ers and Garoppolo.

From your article:

While it was never totally clear who he referenced, you can't rule out that he was talking about Garoppolo and the 49ers since they were ones Brady was looking to sign at.

This is an opinion piece written by 9ers beat reporter addressing the rumors that Brady is considering coming out of retirement for the 9ers. He has no sources with Brady, and no evidence and admits that he doesn't know.  In fact he went on to write:

Ultimately, I believe Brady is done.

[ForJimmy]

4 minutes ago, poundaway said:

So we have an opportunity to get a QB that the 9ers considered better than Brady?

Yeah the NIners picked "that motherf******" and the following year were trading up in the draft to replace him while Brady won a championship.  We had an opportunity to sign Mitch, a QB that the Bears drafted over Mahomes and Watson.  These are mistakes made by teams...

[poundaway]

3 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

 Why would a team want a QB playing for them that isn't interested?

Cause they're good.  Ask Green Bay.

Edited May 22, 2022 by poundaway

[poundaway]

1 minute ago, ForJimmy said:

These are mistakes made by teams...

I'm confused.  I thought teams didn't make mistakes and if we can get JimmyG its because he sucks.

JimmyG>>>>Sam.  We will win more games with Jimmy. 

[ForJimmy]

Just now, poundaway said:

Cause they're good.  Ask Green Bay.

Are you talking about before or after they held an emergency meeting with the front office and Rodgers, restructured his contract, gave him the input he had been wanting then signed him to a huge contract he was wanting?  That's just GB making it right and giving him what he wanted.  Rodgers wants to be there now.

[poundaway]

2 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

Are you talking about before or after they held an emergency meeting with the front office and Rodgers, restructured his contract, gave him the input he had been wanting then signed him to a huge contract he was wanting?  That's just GB making it right and giving him what he wanted.  Rodgers wants to be there now.

Very good.

[ForJimmy]

1 minute ago, poundaway said:

I'm confused.  I thought teams didn't make mistakes and if we can get JimmyG its because he sucks.

JimmyG>>>>Sam.  We will win more games with Jimmy. 

You thought teams didn't make mistakes?  Jimmy G isn't that good and that's why he is STILL available and the Niners have been so eager to replace him.  Jimmy is better than Sam.  I agree with you there.  We can sign Foles right now as a FA who is better than Sam.  That's an extremely low bar to have...  

[poundaway]

7 minutes ago, ForJimmy said:

You thought teams didn't make mistakes? 

No you do.  The 9ers overpaid for Lance and are now committed to him as their starting QB.  Jimmy wants to start so they're going to let him go. 

Jimmy was 9th in PR (ahead of Mahomes) and 13th in QBR (one spot behind Burrow) last year.  Hes a good QB.  Sam is not.

We win more games with Jimmy.

[SizzleBuzz]

24 minutes ago, poundaway said:

No you do.  The 9ers overpaid for Lance and are now committed to him as their starting QB.  Jimmy wants to start so they're going to let him go. 

Jimmy was 9th in PR (ahead of Mahomes) and 13th in QBR (one spot behind Burrow) last year.  Hes a good QB.  Sam is not.

We win more games with Jimmy.

Preach ...

[ForJimmy]

30 minutes ago, poundaway said:

No you do.  The 9ers overpaid for Lance and are now committed to him as their starting QB.  Jimmy wants to start so they're going to let him go. 

Jimmy was 9th in PR (ahead of Mahomes) and 13th in QBR (one spot behind Burrow) last year.  Hes a good QB.  Sam is not.

We win more games with Jimmy.

If you think he is good that’s your opinion. I’ve seen him when his running game isn’t going and they need to use his arm and it’s gets bad. Check those stats for the postseason and watch what happens to them. It’s easy to dink and dunk when you have a great defense and the running game is going great. When they needed his arm he isn’t able to get the job done. It’s very similar to Teddy with the Vikings. I’d rather roll with Corral and if he isn’t the answer then draft one next year. If you want to try to trade for or sign another team’s cast off for the 3rd year in a row, then hopefully 3rd times a charm. I just don’t see it…

QBR has Tannehill and Wentz in the top 10 over him. These guys are behind great running offenses. When the games on the line they have proven they can’t get it done. 

Edited May 23, 2022 by ForJimmy

[CRA]

Jimmy G - Average Intended Air Yards per pass attempt 

2021- 29th

2020 - 40th

2019 - 37th 

He is the king of checkdown offense.  It’s why the 49ers gave up 3 first round picks for a Trey Lance.  If Jimmy G was good….Trey Lance wouldn’t be in SF.  Especially not for 3 first round picks. 

We could of just kept Teddy this entire time.  Saved a bunch of draft picks.