Tom Brady is the BEST

[Mesmer]

I'm sorry but Brady will never be #1 for me. He's done a lot of amazing things in his career, but watching Matt Cassel run that offense just as well pretty much kills any argument of Brady as the best in my book.

[thefuzz]

Brady can probably lay claim to being the fourth best QB in the league, at best right now.

Peyton is a virtual god. There's no one else even in his class, Brady included.

Number two and number three right now would likely be a tossup between Brees and Favre. Brees is probably second in the end, but it's worth debating.

That puts Brady fourth, and you could make arguments for others challenging him even for that spot.

Peyton

Brees

Rivers

Favre

Brady

This year. And I am totally shocked to include Favre in that list.

[Brandon]

Peyton

Brees

Rivers

Favre

Brady

This year. And I am totally shocked to include Favre in that list.

Hell my list is less favorable...

P. Manning

Favre

Brees

Rivers

Rodgers

Roethlisberger

Brady

[King Taharqa]

Brady is still the best. Lets see what those other guys do in January first before we annoint them "gods" or better than Brady. There's still alot of football left to be played.

[Mr. Scot]

Peyton

Brees

Rivers

Favre

Brady

This year. And I am totally shocked to include Favre in that list.

Phillip Rivers. That's who I was forgetting.

[Davidson Deac II]

Brady is still the best. Lets see what those other guys do in January first before we annoint them "gods" or better than Brady. There's still alot of football left to be played.

You are comparing team accomplishments to individual ones. Don't get me wrong, I think Brady is one of the top two in the league with Manning being the other one. He is better than Brees, Rivers, or Farve. But Tom Brady never won a superbowl, the New England Patriots did. And Mark Rypien, Joe Theisman, and Doug Williams all started on teams that won superbowls. Marino and Fouts never won one. Yet I don't think you will find many who would argue that Mark Rypien is a better QB than Marino or Fouts.

[thefuzz]

Do you think that Brady, this season, is better than Rivers, Brees, and Favre?

[King Taharqa]

Do you think that Brady, this season, is better than Rivers, Brees, and Favre?

Regular season. Nope. But I trust Brady more than any of those other guys in the postseason. Favre has a long history of January meltdowns, and given how spotless he's looked so far, the law of averages is not in his favor. He's due for a 4 INT performance. Rivers is a good QB and has showns flashes, but he shouldnt be mentioned alongside Brady. Brees is playing lights out and is my favorite for the MVP right now, but same rules apply. History hasnt been favorable to him in January either. The same with Manning. He could very easily go out there and get knocked out in round 1 of the playoffs, making all the "god" talk seem a lil premature.

[Davidson Deac II]

Do you think that Brady, this season, is better than Rivers, Brees, and Favre?

Hard to pick during individual seasons, but maybe. Brady has thrown more than any of those three and yet has fewer int's than two of them. Farve and Brees have good running game to complement their game while New England is so so in that department.

[thefuzz]

Regular season. Nope. But I trust Brady more than any of those other guys in the postseason. Favre has a long history of January meltdowns, and given how spotless he's looked so far, the law of averages is not in his favor. He's due for a 4 INT performance. Rivers is a good QB and has showns flashes, but he shouldnt be mentioned alongside Brady. Brees is playing lights out and is my favorite for the MVP right now, but same rules apply. History hasnt been favorable to him in January either. The same with Manning. He could very easily go out there and get knocked out in round 1 of the playoffs, making all the "god" talk seem a lil premature.

Of all of those mentioned Rivers and Brady have by far been the best in the postseason....and yes, Rivers can be mentioned in the same sentence as Brady.

Check out wins, QB rating, TD/INT's...pretty much any stat/achievement and you will see what I am talking about.

[Cat]

Brady owns all.

:drool5:

[WhoDatJorts]

Brady owns all.

I believe that even Tom Brady himself will tell you that Drew Brees owned him on Monday Night Football.

[Cat]

I believe that even Tom Brady himself will tell you that Drew Brees owned him on Monday Night Football.

pssshhh

Bree's doesn't play defense and he has that nasty mark on his face.

[WhoDatJorts]

pssshhh

Bree's doesn't play defense and he has that nasty mark on his face.

That mark is where all of his powers come from.

And yeah, Brady doesn't play defense, but he didn't play offense Monday night either. 2 Delhomme-like interceptions and 0 TDs.