Should Mike Vick Join Panthers?

[Sam Mills Fan]

I don't think Jake has EVER had a game as good as Quinn had this week.

[Mr. Scot]

lol cosby FTW

Appreciated.

Now will someone please lock this silliness before it gets any dumber?

[Sultan33g]

I don't think Jake has EVER had a game as good as Quinn had this week.

look jake sucks...I agree...but Michael vick? are you seriously saying this? I had alot of respect for you until you said we should have signed michael vick...

[Sam Mills Fan]

What did Jake do when he played a defense as bad as Detroit's? Against Tampa Bay, he threw one touchdown, two picks, and was 9 of 17 overall for 65 yards. TB has allowed the third-most touchdowns through the air in the league.

[88 Bronco]

Unreal, simply unreal.

We have the worst starting quarterback in the league and you guys are STILL too afraid to entertain the notion that we passed up someone that would have performed better than he has done.

With Jake Delhomme on November 24th, we have the worst starting quarterback in the league and no chance at the playoffs. Are you saying that the same would have been true if Vick had been the starter from Opening Day on?

Seriously guys, I thought we were past this.

I am aware of the QB problems, but bringing in a guy who was a lacking as a passer BEFORE missing two years of football to replace a guy who is has been struggling really bad seems a lot like replacing an 87 Tempo with a 90 Cavalier.

[Sultan33g]

What did Jake do when he played a defense as bad as Detroit's? Against Tampa Bay, he threw one touchdown, two picks, and was 9 of 17 overall for 65 yards. TB has allowed the third-most touchdowns through the air in the league.

you win jake sucks...but ......nevermind I give up....

[Sam Mills Fan]

It's not just Vick specifically. I'm not much of a Vick fan really, but I understand that even he would be a better option than Jake Delhomme. So would Brett Favre, a league MVP candidate this year that we passed on. So would Chad Henne/Joe Flacco/Brady Quinn, other quarterbacks that we've passed on lately.

[X-Clown]

You guys honestly think that Vick would have played more poorly than Jake has this season? No starting quarterback in the league can currently say that they've played worse than Jake has, I find it highly unlikely that Vick would.

You're a moron if you think Jake is the ONLY problem with this team and is the sole reason that we are not making the playoffs which is what your initial post was insinuating. What have you seen Vick do this year as the third string quarterback in Philly that suggests he would be our savior? I'm eagerly awaiting this response.

[Sultan33g]

It's not just Vick specifically. I'm not much of a Vick fan really, but I understand that even he would be a better option than Jake Delhomme. So would Brett Favre, a league MVP candidate this year that we passed on. So would Chad Henne/Joe Flacco/Brady Quinn, other quarterbacks that we've passed on lately.

I dont agree

[88 Bronco]

It's not just Vick specifically. I'm not much of a Vick fan really, but I understand that even he would be a better option than Jake Delhomme. So would Brett Favre, a league MVP candidate this year that we passed on. So would Chad Henne/Joe Flacco/Brady Quinn, other quarterbacks that we've passed on lately.

In the same way that watching your house burn down with your family trapped in it is a better option than being in there with them.

[Sultan33g]

In the same way that watching your house burn down with your family trapped in it is a better option than being in there with them.

harsh but good analogy

[88 Bronco]

harsh but good analogy

Thanks

[X-Clown]

I love by the way, how overly emotional SMF characterizes anyone who takes issue with his complete knee jerk posts based upon what he saw other quarterbacks do on SportsCenter two days ago as someone who is backing Jake Delhomme as our starting quarterback.

[The NFL Shield At Midfield]

Nobody here is prepared for how truly breathtakingly awful we would be with Vick as a starter on this team. What do you people advocate doing with Vick as the starting quarterback on this team, running the triple option or something? He's horribly inaccurate, can't pass with anything resembling touch, and locks onto his targets. Don't we already have one of those?