Should Mike Vick Join Panthers?

[Sam Mills Fan]

You guys honestly think that Vick would have played more poorly than Jake has this season? No starting quarterback in the league can currently say that they've played worse than Jake has, I find it highly unlikely that Vick would.

[Johnny Rockets]

Why go for Vick when you could trade for Kevin Kolb? IMO Kolb looked much

better than Vick.

I think the panthers could trade Goodsen for Kolb, or Kolb and a draft pick for Stewart.

I am not sure you realize what the Eagles have invested/planned for Kolb.

[Sultan33g]

You guys honestly think that Vick would have played more poorly than Jake has this season? No starting quarterback in the league can currently say that they've played worse than Jake has, I find it highly unlikely that Vick would.

ummm

[Mr. Scot]

Why are people bashing this idea? Sure, the kid's a moron, but if we had signed Vick in the offseason and given him control of the offense, we'd have a better record than 4-6 right now and would still be in the playoff chase.

Highlighted the correct part.

And yeah, let's give "control of the offense" to a guy who always needed 'one more year' to learn the West Coast Offense

(Boomer Esaiason once said, regarding this notion, "How hard is it to learn to throw a slant?")

I love when people suggest our offense would be 'unstoppable' with Vick mixed in. With no passing threat, it would be quite easily stoppable (not that much different than what we have now, really).

[88 Bronco]

You guys honestly think that Vick would have played more poorly than Jake has this season? No starting quarterback in the league can currently say that they've played worse than Jake has, I find it highly unlikely that Vick would.

Pick me pick me. I think Vick would have done worse. The only receiver he could find consistantly was larger than any receiver we have, and that was before his extended sabbatical from football. The few pass attempts of his I've seen this year make Delhomme look like a lock for the pro bowl.

[Sam Mills Fan]

JaMarcus got benched. He's not starting any longer.

[88 Bronco]

JaMarcus got benched. He's not starting any longer.

And Vick would be too.

[Sultan33g]

JaMarcus got benched. He's not starting any longer.

umm ya and thats why jake should have...o wait...

[Sam Mills Fan]

Unreal, simply unreal.

We have the worst starting quarterback in the league and you guys are STILL too afraid to entertain the notion that we passed up someone that would have performed better than he has done.

With Jake Delhomme on November 24th, we have the worst starting quarterback in the league and no chance at the playoffs. Are you saying that the same would have been true if Vick had been the starter from Opening Day on?

Seriously guys, I thought we were past this.

[Scrumtrilescent]

I am not sure you realize what the Eagles have invested/planned for Kolb.

The future, Conan?

[Mr. Scot]

JaMarcus Russell is no longer starting because he was giving away the snap count.

Opposing defenses knew as soon as he said "Hey Hey Hey" it was time.

[Sam Mills Fan]

Brady Quinn just got off a game where he threw for four touchdowns and zero interceptions. He did that with absolutely nothing to work with anywhere on the offense.

Brady Quinn >>>>>>>> Jake Delhomme

[Sultan33g]

JaMarcus Russell is no longer starting because he was giving away the snap count.

Opposing defenses knew as soon as he said "Hey Hey Hey" it was time.

lol cosby FTW

[Sultan33g]

Brady Quinn just got off a game where he threw for four touchdowns and zero interceptions. He did that with absolutely nothing to work with anywhere on the offense.

Brady Quinn >>>>>>>> Jake Delhomme

lol have u seen the detroit lions defense? good try buddy