Would you trade one of our two 5th round picks for Minshew right now…..

[CPF4LIFE]

20 minutes ago, Moo Daeng said:

PJ?, the guy who was several times worse than Darnold when he got in? 3 of 14 PJ? 

Nah

Yes...the guy when he has had a full week to prepare as a starter is 1-0 with this team. Show me how many qbs are successful when they are thrown in at the end of games when defenses know you are passing and can just pin ears back and rush? PJ aint the answer but lets not act like he has gotten a fair shake when it comes to his failures. 

[Moo Daeng]

Right now it seems the best approach simply looking at the QB room would have been to draft Mac Jones and trade for Minshew or simply kept Bridgewater. I'm not sure if the Teddy bridge was too burned. Now it seems he was likely correct about Joe Brady.

 

 

Edited October 27, 2021 by Moo Daeng

[mrcompletely11]

 Minshew and Dillard for a 5th

[therealmjl]

1 hour ago, CPF4LIFE said:

Yes...the guy when he has had a full week to prepare as a starter is 1-0 with this team. Show me how many qbs are successful when they are thrown in at the end of games when defenses know you are passing and can just pin ears back and rush? PJ aint the answer but lets not act like he has gotten a fair shake when it comes to his failures. 

PJ is terrible, just like Darnold. Not even worth discussion.

And I can point to several backups who come in late in games and move the ball much better than PJ did. You are a Panthers fan, right? We've seen that story unfold on us countless times.

[kungfoodude]

Turd blending should be the name for what we have done building the offensive line.

[OhhhhCam]

2 5ths no! One 6th yes please 

[Khyber53]

I'd rather have the Minshew trade by far than what we'd be trading away to have Watson sit on our bench and our cap space. 

See if Minshew can come in and Jake Delhomme this team back into shape.

[t96]

15 hours ago, LinvilleGorge said:

If we weren't already short a 2nd and 3rd, I would. It's tank time now. 

There's no reason to tank. We might wind up sucking anyways but we need to start building a winning culture rather than worrying about draft position. No QBs next draft are can't miss prospects. This past draft was supposed to be one of the best QB drafts ever and they all suck so far and all their teams are bad. 

[LinvilleGorge]

6 minutes ago, t96 said:

There's no reason to tank. We might wind up sucking anyways but we need to start building a winning culture rather than worrying about draft position. No QBs next draft are can't miss prospects. This past draft was supposed to be one of the best QB drafts ever and they all suck so far and all their teams are bad. 

Winning culture...

That's what Rhule sold Tepper on. How's it looking?

The best way to build a winning culture is to build a winning roster. This roster we've assembled... oh wee mayne. Good thing we've gutted our draft capital to build it.

[frankw]

17 minutes ago, t96 said:

There's no reason to tank. We might wind up sucking anyways but we need to start building a winning culture rather than worrying about draft position.

If building a winning culture was the goal we've gone about it comically wrong. Six draft picks for Sam Darnold and three cornerbacks isn't doing anything to help that while our oline falls apart and we get blown out of the stadium by the Giants. It wasn't going to get significantly better in just one season yes but it should not have gone the other way. We are worse off than we were last year. That's mismanagement.

[CPF4LIFE]

1 hour ago, therealmjl said:

PJ is terrible, just like Darnold. Not even worth discussion.

And I can point to several backups who come in late in games and move the ball much better than PJ did. You are a Panthers fan, right? We've seen that story unfold on us countless times.

Lol....sure thing buddy. And you are right this aint even worth discussion. 

[KSpan]

For what purpose? This would be upping the ante with respect to baffling QB-related decisions.

[PootieNunu]

2 hours ago, frankw said:

If building a winning culture was the goal we've gone about it comically wrong. Six draft picks for Sam Darnold and three cornerbacks isn't doing anything to help that while our oline falls apart and we get blown out of the stadium by the Giants. It wasn't going to get significantly better in just one season yes but it should not have gone the other way. We are worse off than we were last year. That's mismanagement.

TBF, if we did not have injuries to our starting RB,MLB,CB,SS among other injuries here and there we would be a better team than we were last year and not sitting at 3-4. 

This team is not built for having multiple injuries to key players. We are one of the youngest teams in the league with little to no depth. 

 

[frankw]

7 minutes ago, PootieNunu said:

TBF, if we did not have injuries to our starting RB,MLB,CB,SS among other injuries here and there we would be a better team than we were last year and not sitting at 3-4. 

This team is not built for having multiple injuries to key players. We are one of the youngest teams in the league with little to no depth. 

 

Excuse me sir the Giants were also missing their starting rb and three wideouts but they blew the doors off us. The injury excuse isn't going to fly.

Edited October 27, 2021 by frankw