Panthers' Stewart, Williams questionable for Thursday

[Dpantherman]

As always......This is an every week thing.

[nosuchthingasapanther]

I don't think DWill has taken a beating this season. He had the least amount of carries out of the top 10 RBs last season, he will be ok. Plus I don't think Fox is as dumb as Mike Smith to run him into the ground. Perhaps we get to see some Mike Goodson tomorrow?

i know i mentioned carries, but the punishment he's taken this season isn't necessarily based on more touches. outside of cedric benson, none of the top 10 backs in the league have touched the ball 200 times yet. he's on pace to have over 300 carries, but it's not excessive.

it's based on the obvious fact that he's been getting hit more often and harder than last season. that's a result of the better defenses he's running against.

[Mr. Scot]

Stewart's becoming our version of Tom Brady (constantly on the injury report).

[Wither]

Stewart's becoming our version of Tom Brady (constantly on the injury report).

Yet he still manages to shine. He won't last several years (in fact, I think D-Will will last longer), but he's still good.

i know i mentioned carries, but the punishment he's taken this season isn't necessarily based on more touches. outside of cedric benson, none of the top 10 backs in the league have touched the ball 200 times yet. he's on pace to have over 300 carries, but it's not excessive.

it's based on the obvious fact that he's been getting hit more often and harder than last season. that's a result of the better defenses he's running against.

He'll be alright. Injuries happen and the great ones come out of injuries shining (is Jake shining? lmao that's a matter of opinion I suppose).

[Mr. Scot]

Yet he still manages to shine. He won't last several years (in fact, I think D-Will will last longer), but he's still good.

I forget just how long Brady was "probable (shoulder)" but it was a while.

[OneBadassCat]

Personally I think Stewart's weekly injury report is just Fox bullshit.

[Wither]

Personally I think Stewart's weekly injury report is just Fox bullshit.

"He's got a scratch or two; we better throw him on the report."

[nosuchthingasapanther]

Personally I think Stewart's weekly injury report is just Fox bullshit.

isn't it obvious?

the first 9 games last season...113 carries for 383 yards @ 3.3 ypc

this season...98 carries 466 yards @ 4.8 ypc

the competition last season was softer than this one's, yet it's possible stewart will break 1000 yards on 200 touches or less.

he is definitely healthy.

[OneBadassCat]

isn't it obvious?

the first 9 games last season...113 carries for 383 yards @ 3.3 ypc

this season...98 carries 466 yards @ 4.8 ypc

the competition last season was softer than this one's, yet it's possible stewart can break 1000 yards on 200 touches or less.

he is definitely healthy.

Either that or Superman is wearing Kryptonite and still dominating.

[PantherDude]

I wonder if the injury report mean they have like sore muscles in part of their body that is hurting. It sound like than a serious injury that would make them not play. Kinda like a bad cramp. But then, maybe Fox is just messing around to make opposing teams we play have a different plan to beat us when we trick them that our players are playing.

[Wither]

I wonder if the injury report mean they have like sore muscles in part of their body that is hurting. It sound like than a serious injury that would make them not play. Kinda like a bad cramp. But then, maybe Fox is just messing around to make opposing teams we play have a different plan to beat us when we trick them that our players are playing.

The ultimate trickery:

Injured List

50 Anderson, James OLB ACT 6'2" 235 9/26/1983 4 Virginia Tech

7 Baker, Jason P ACT 6'2" 205 5/17/1978 9 Iowa

82 Barnidge, Gary TE ACT 6'5" 247 9/22/1985 2 Louisville

52 Beason, Jon MLB ACT 6'0" 237 1/14/1985 3 Miami (Fla.)

73 Bernadeau, Mackenzy G ACT 6'4" 308 1/3/1986 2 Bentley

96 Brayton, Tyler DE ACT 6'6" 280 11/20/1979 7 Colorado

91 Brown, Everette DE ACT 6'1" 256 8/7/1987 0 Florida State

55 Connor, Dan LB ACT 6'2" 231 11/2/1985 2 Penn State

71 Davis, C.J. G RES 6'2" 308 2/2/1987 0 Pittsburgh

58 Davis, Thomas OLB RES 6'0" 240 3/22/1983 5 Georgia

17 Delhomme, Jake QB ACT 6'2" 215 1/10/1975 11 Louisiana-Lafayette

53 Diggs, Na'il OLB ACT 6'4" 240 7/8/1978 9 Ohio State

11 Feeley, A.J. QB ACT 6'3" 220 5/16/1977 9 Oregon

42 Fiammetta, Tony FB ACT 6'0" 242 8/22/1986 0 Syracuse

20 Gamble, Chris CB ACT 6'1" 200 3/11/1983 6 Ohio State

30 Godfrey, Charles FS ACT 5'11" 205 11/15/1985 2 Iowa

33 Goodson, Mike RB ACT 6'0" 212 5/23/1987 0 Texas A&M

69 Gross, Jordan T RES 6'4" 305 7/20/1980 7 Utah

43 Harris, Chris SS ACT 6'0" 205 8/6/1982 5 Louisiana-Monroe

98 Hayden, Nick DT ACT 6'4" 292 2/4/1986 2 Wisconsin

45 Hoover, Brad FB ACT 6'0" 245 11/11/1976 10 Western Carolina

60 Irvin, Corvey DT RES 6'3" 302 5/3/1985 0 Georgia

44 Jansen, J.J. LS ACT 6'2" 256 1/20/1986 2 Notre Dame

80 Jarrett, Dwayne WR ACT 6'4" 219 9/11/1986 3 USC

95 Johnson, Charles DE ACT 6'2" 276 7/10/1986 3 Georgia

59 Johnson, Landon LB ACT 6'2" 232 3/13/1981 6 Purdue

67 Kalil, Ryan C ACT 6'2" 295 3/29/1985 3 USC

4 Kasay, John K ACT 5'10" 210 10/27/1969 19 Georgia

99 Kemoeatu, Maake DT RES 6'5" 345 1/10/1979 8 Utah

47 King, Jeff TE ACT 6'3" 260 2/19/1983 4 Virginia Tech

94 Leonard, Louis DT RES 6'4" 325 7/16/1984 3 Fresno State

92 Lewis, Damione DT ACT 6'2" 301 3/1/1978 9 Miami (Fla.)

5 Lloyd, Rhys K ACT 5'11" 231 6/5/1982 3 Minnesota

31 Marshall, Richard CB ACT 5'11" 189 12/12/1984 4 Fresno State

Martin, Charly WR ACT 6'1" 212 3/20/1984 0 West Texas A&M

23 Martin, Sherrod FS ACT 6'1" 198 10/12/1984 0 Troy

12 McCown, Josh QB RES 6'4" 215 7/4/1979 8 Sam Houston State

81 Moore, Kenny WR ACT 5'11" 195 2/19/1985 2 Wake Forest

3 Moore, Matt QB ACT 6'3" 202 8/9/1984 3 Oregon State

87 Muhammad, Muhsin WR ACT 6'2" 215 5/5/1973 14 Michigan State

41 Munnerlyn, Captain CB ACT 5'8" 186 4/10/1988 0 South Carolina

79 Otah, Jeff T ACT 6'6" 330 6/17/1986 2 Pittsburgh

90 Peppers, Julius DE ACT 6'7" 283 1/18/1980 8 North Carolina

72 Robinson, Duke G ACT 6'5" 330 10/10/1986 0 Oklahoma

88 Rosario, Dante TE ACT 6'4" 250 10/25/1984 3 Oregon

74 Schwartz, Geoff T ACT 6'6" 331 7/11/1986 1 Oregon

46 Smith, Kelvin LB ACT 6'2" 240 3/20/1984 2 Syracuse

89 Smith, Steve WR ACT 5'9" 185 5/12/1979 9 Utah

28 Stewart, Jonathan RB ACT 5'10" 235 3/21/1987 2 Oregon

22 Sutton, Tyrell RB ACT 5'8" 213 12/19/1986 0 Northwestern

97 Taylor, Hilee DE ACT 6'2" 250 7/18/1986 2 North Carolina

26 Teal, Quinton SS ACT 6'1" 187 3/8/1984 3 Coastal Carolina

75 Thomas, Hollis DT ACT 6'0" 340 1/10/1974 14 Northern Illinois

93 Tyler, Tank DT ACT 6'2" 306 2/14/1985 3 North Carolina State

68 Vincent, Keydrick G ACT 6'5" 325 4/13/1978 9 Mississippi

21 Wesley, Dante CB ACT 6'1" 210 4/5/1979 8 Arkansas-Pine Bluff

70 Wharton, Travelle G ACT 6'4" 312 5/19/1981 6 South Carolina

34 Williams, DeAngelo RB ACT 5'9" 217 4/25/1983 4 Memphis

65 Williams, Garry T ACT 6'3" 296 8/20/1986 0 Kentucky

27 Wilson, C.J. CB ACT 6'1" 195 4/2/1985 3 Baylor

[NewCat28]

I don't post here much.

We all know that the average fan can never evaluate a player's "health" by looking at an NFL injury report.

As a person close to Stew I want to say that you all have NO idea what he (or any other player) goes through to be on the field. But that's what a 1st rounder and highly paid athelete is supposed to do. Look at the big picture. He isn't missing games. He's hardly fragile or unproductive. He and D-Will are leading the league in tamdem rushing and get along great. Their relationship is real and not fabricated.

You reserve the right to criticize him for the "lingering" injuries, but you don't know all the facts and never will. Show respect for all of these guys because they will have some injuries long after the NFL.

Go Panthers!

[PhillyB]

I don't post here much.

We all know that the average fan can never evaluate a player's "health" by looking at an NFL injury report.

As a person close to Stew I want to say that you all have NO idea what he (or any other player) goes through to be on the field. But that's what a 1st rounder and highly paid athelete is supposed to do. Look at the big picture. He isn't missing games. He's hardly fragile or unproductive. He and D-Will are leading the league in tamdem rushing and get along great. Their relationship is real and not fabricated.

You reserve the right to criticize him for the "lingering" injuries, but you don't know all the facts and never will. Show respect for all of these guys because they will have some injuries long after the NFL.

Go Panthers!

i dont think anyone was criticizing him

[CharlotteBeer.com]

i dont think anyone was criticizing him

I was thinking the same.

We're just pointing out the obvious: he has been injured in some way since before he suited up in a Panthers uniform. It's definitely impressive that he can fight through those injuries and consistently play at a high level (which is why I'm not as worried about Stewart's injury as I am DeAngelo's -- we don't need two banged-up backs).