Best Value: Joseph Charlton

[jayboogieman]

1 hour ago, 45catfan said:

It's the yin/yang of the Carolina Panthers.  We can't excel at one position without equally sucking at another.  Everything must balance!

[thefuzz]

1 hour ago, t96 said:

Remember how worried we were about punter after Brad Nortman left? Nippleshorts panic traded for Andy Lee and then he got hurt anyways and didn't even play a full season. Palardy took over and showed he was clearly the real deal and held it down as a well above average punter for several years. Then tore his ACL and lost his job to Charlton who is a total boss.

 

Why can't we have the same good fortunes at kicker as we've had at punter?

We did....Kasay.

[Moonstone]

1 hour ago, t96 said:

Nippleshorts panic traded for Andy Lee

4th round pick at that lol. Though Andy was a good punter for us, he was booming them punts and with a good placement too. I remember after the first few games that Andy was one of our best players.

[Ocpanthertew714]

1 hour ago, Daddy_Uncle said:

I like the way to watch charlotte kick he good to kick good

[t96]

32 minutes ago, Moonstone said:

4th round pick at that lol. Though Andy was a good punter for us, he was booming them punts and with a good placement too. I remember after the first few games that Andy was one of our best players.

Yeah he's a good punter and he's been good for the Cardinals since we cut him. But giving up a 4th for a punter who was already one of the highest paid was just a poor decision. We even had Palardy on the roster that offseason before trading for Lee I believe. Palardy and Charlton have shown that you can get punters for dirt cheap undrafted and have them still turn out to be very good, should've just gone that route from the start once Nortman left.

 

41 minutes ago, thefuzz said:

We did....Kasay.

Yeah but since then, not so much... And even he came up short in the biggest game we asked him to play. Still convinced we win that SB in OT if not for the out of bounds KO.

[thefuzz]

1 hour ago, t96 said:

Yeah he's a good punter and he's been good for the Cardinals since we cut him. But giving up a 4th for a punter who was already one of the highest paid was just a poor decision. We even had Palardy on the roster that offseason before trading for Lee I believe. Palardy and Charlton have shown that you can get punters for dirt cheap undrafted and have them still turn out to be very good, should've just gone that route from the start once Nortman left.

 

Yeah but since then, not so much... And even he came up short in the biggest game we asked him to play. Still convinced we win that SB in OT if not for the out of bounds KO.

Yea, K's been pretty rocky around here for a spell.

Either bad, or overpaid, or inexplicably cut.

[Castavar]

An elite punter matched with a great defense can be so frustrating for opposing teams. You're always having too drive the field 80+ yards against a stifling defense. That poo wears down the opposing team throughout the course of a game. 

[Basbear]

This is why you dont spend draft picks on STers.....ESPECIALLY LS!!! 

[FearTheCats]

He’s come a long way since his meme worthy shank during Training Camp last year.