QB Controversy

[Varking]

2 minutes ago, CPsinceDay1 said:

Carolina All Day... Clearly there's something in the air against PJ, who's a member of the Carolina Panthers...I mean so many threads concerned with the backup QB, why, because it shows the lack of faith in Sam Darnold...once again passing on Fields, and now releasing Will, let's me know how much faith it is they have in PJ vs. how much they in Sam Darnold...like @CRA has stated they're not bringing in any QB, and it's because they don't want any real competition for Sam Darnold.

Darnold is a bargain chip...he was meant for insurance always...a decent backup..or trade bait should a certain QB legal problems disappear...had it been Fields,Darnold,PJ...there would be no Horn...and PJ possesses the same skill set as Fields so the understanding if Darnold sucks, homerun with PJ... Phillip went undrafted...off and on the colts...PJ is a baller from the XFL...who knows what it takes to fight to get where you are...

 

So as a Panthers fan for 6

 

PJ and Fields aren’t really comparable. I believe PJs pro day 40 is closer to Darnold than it is to Fields. Fields faced more pressure than any other QB this preseason on his drop backs (49% of his drop backs were under pressure) and he didn’t shrink to a miserable 41% completions. 

 

 It’s not against PJ only. The year before it was against Grier. When you play like trash you should be cut or the position should be upgraded. If Sam goes down, our season is over. 

Pray for 14 to stay healthy and develop. We need to upgrade at backup QB. Grier would be minimally better than PJ anyway. Neither one of them are winning us games. They can only hope to not be the cause we lose,  it they won’t ever be why we win. 

Panther fans don’t root and hope for the starter to go down just so the backup can get reps and prove he’s not starting material. 

[Jon Snow]

1 minute ago, Varking said:

PJ and Fields aren’t really comparable. I believe PJs pro day 40 is closer to Darnold than it is to Fields. Fields faced more pressure than any other QB this preseason on his drop backs (49% of his drop backs were under pressure) and he didn’t shrink to a miserable 41% completions. 

 

 It’s not against PJ only. The year before it was against Grier. When you play like trash you should be cut or the position should be upgraded. If Sam goes down, our season is over. 

Pray for 14 to stay healthy and develop. We need to upgrade at backup QB. Grier would be minimally better than PJ anyway. Neither one of them are winning us games. They can only hope to not be the cause we lose,  it they won’t ever be why we win. 

Panther fans don’t root and hope for the starter to go down just so the backup can get reps and prove he’s not starting material. 

Except during the Clausen season.  You might even have to include the Weinke season as well.

Your premise is theoretically correct but there are always outliers. 

[glenwo2]

You still here, @CPsinceDay1? 

That's odd.

I thought you were getting settled at your new home JetNation?   

Edited September 1, 2021 by glenwo2

[CPsinceDay1]

1 minute ago, glenwo2 said:

You still here, @CPsinceDay1? 

That's odd.

I thought you were getting settled at your new home JetNation?   

When Darnold gets benched, are you still going to be here???

[glenwo2]

9 hours ago, Tinamedina said:

 

Only difference is sam has been a starter longer. that is literally it, oh, and pj walker is more athletic and mobile. More confident.

There is so much wrong in this statement, I can only point and laugh :

[glenwo2]

2 minutes ago, CPsinceDay1 said:

When Darnold gets benched, are you still going to be here???

When PJ gets released, are you still going to be here??? 

[mwright350]

3 minutes ago, glenwo2 said:

When PJ gets released, are you still going to be here??? 

Just look for the brand-new account stumping for Armanti Edwards to be brought back to start at QB.  That'll be him.

Edited September 1, 2021 by mwright350

[CPsinceDay1]

8 minutes ago, glenwo2 said:

When PJ gets released, are you still going to be here??? 

Really thought you'd be gone when Will left

[glenwo2]

^^^ That makes no sense whatsoever but you do you.

[NanuqoftheNorth]

Gotta believe the chances of PJ getting picked up off waivers would have been less than Will's.

If Rhule hoped to keep both backup QBs, his bias for his former college players may have betrayed him this time.

[Jon Snow]

2 minutes ago, NanuqoftheNorth said:

Gotta believe the chances of PJ getting picked up off waivers would have been less than Will's.

If Rhule hoped to keep both backup QBs, his bias for his former college players may have betrayed him this time.

If true he will learn soon enough.  

[CRA]

8 minutes ago, NanuqoftheNorth said:

Gotta believe the chances of PJ getting picked up off waivers would have been less than Will's.

If Rhule hoped to keep both backup QBs, his bias for his former college players may have betrayed him this time.

Will got a 2% chance.  PJ got a 1% chance.  Whatever it actually is, I almost think any conversation that involves  PJ/Grier is splitting hairs.   

What we needed to of done is not go all in on Sam Darnold.   Darnold is the underlying reason everyone is so passionate about this pointless debate.    If we were going this route, we should of brought in two guys IMO.  So you bring in Darnold and Mitch T.  Or Darnold and Menshew.   Let them compete.  Increase your odds. 

[CPsinceDay1]

2 minutes ago, CRA said:

Will got a 2% chance.  PJ got a 1% chance.  Whatever it actually is, I almost think any conversation that involves  PJ/Grier is splitting hairs.   

What we needed to of done is not go all in on Sam Darnold.   Darnold is the underlying reason everyone is so passionate about this pointless debate.    If we were going this route, we should of brought in two guys IMO.  So you bring in Darnold and Mitch T.  Or Darnold and Menshew.   Let them compete.  Increase your odds. 

Hence....THE QB CONTROVERSY of 2021....we are now left with no choice but PJ

 

...you kno, in case, Sam Darnold doesn't pan out

 

[NanuqoftheNorth]

2 minutes ago, CRA said:

Will got a 2% chance.  PJ got a 1% chance.  Whatever it actually is, I almost think any conversation that involves  PJ/Grier is splitting hairs.   

What we needed to of done is not go all in on Sam Darnold.   Darnold is the underlying reason everyone is so passionate about this pointless debate.    If we were going this route, we should of brought in two guys IMO.  So you bring in Darnold and Mitch T.  Or Darnold and Menshew.   Let them compete.  Increase your odds. 

Yeah, seeing how little Darnold and Menshew cost to pickup by their respective teams, there is a good argument to be made for creating a more competitive situation in Carolina.

Though isn't that what Denver has been attempting to do for years now?