Who was the best Carolina Panthers player today?

[Ricky Spanish]

3 hours ago, The Huddler said:

people on dynastyFF reddit "concerned" about Marshalls speed getting caught..  

 

me response..

 

 

apparently my "take" wasnt too popular. 

What a name  

[CRA]

11 minutes ago, micnificent28 said:

I agree atleast on paper... we haven't just seen him run away from people like you have with elite speed like Samuel..Anderson because of his length looks more like a strider to me. He's fast don't get Me wrong it's good. 

But he isn't that Ted Ginn..Samuel.. tyreek hill division of top 5% NFL speed.

Guys like Samuel have that quick change of direction speed.  Robby more that straight line speed.  DJ IMO is the perfect mix. 

I don’t care Marshall got caught from behind.  He isn’t suppose to be that type dude. 

was a more surprised with Chubba 

[micnificent28]

11 minutes ago, CRA said:

Guys like Samuel have that quick change of direction speed.  Robby more that straight line speed.  DJ IMO is the perfect mix. 

I don’t care Marshall got caught from behind.  He isn’t suppose to be that type dude. 

was a more surprised with Chubba 

I think that's a different aspect... thats like acceleration plus speed. What I'm talking about is is my top gear is faster than 90% of the NFLs top gear. For me that line is around 4.3 lower end speed. I mean 4.4 is considered fast by nfl measures..  when you get below that then we are talking gaming breaking speed. Anderson 4.36 is very good.. 

But he seems like he builds up to that speed. Like a strider.... he isn't twitchy or I catch it and I'm gone..  he has to build up to it. 

[CRA]

5 minutes ago, micnificent28 said:

I think that's a different aspect... thats like acceleration plus speed. What I'm talking about is is my top gear is faster than 90% of the NFLs top gear. For me that line is around 4.3 lower end speed. I mean 4.4 is considered fast by nfl measures..  when you get below that then we are talking gaming breaking speed. Anderson 4.36 is very good.. 

But he seems like he builds up to that speed. Like a strider.... he isn't twitchy or I catch it and I'm gone..  he has to build up to it. 

Gotcha.  Yeah, 4.4 isn’t runaway from the field speed anymore.   Especially the way guys train to get their 40 time.  
 

Football speed vs timed 40 speed.  You can also have two guys with 4.4 speed and it also just looks different in a game. 

[micnificent28]

8 minutes ago, CRA said:

Gotcha.  Yeah, 4.4 isn’t runaway from the field speed anymore.   Especially the way guys train to get their 40 time.  
 

Football speed vs timed 40 speed.  You can also have two guys with 4.4 speed and it also just looks different in a game. 

Agreed..  thats what I was trying to say lol

[micnificent28]

10 minutes ago, CRA said:

Gotcha.  Yeah, 4.4 isn’t runaway from the field speed anymore.   Especially the way guys train to get their 40 time.  
 

Football speed vs timed 40 speed.  You can also have two guys with 4.4 speed and it also just looks different in a game. 

To add to that for comparison sake. Terrance Marshall JR was said to have run a 4.4... and a 4.38..... you see how that looked today...

[CRA]

1 minute ago, micnificent28 said:

To add to that for comparison sake. Terrance Marshall JR was said to have run a 4.4... and a 4.38..... you see how that looked today...

oh yeah, and there also is hand clocked times by coaches lol.  

[micnificent28]

2 minutes ago, CRA said:

oh yeah, and there also is hand clocked times by coaches lol.  

Which brought me to my question about robby Andersons time... was it hand clocked as well?

[trueblade]

3 hours ago, CPsinceDay1 said:

Hey if B.Zylstra caught half his passes that percent is near %75 completion rate...

Them two just couldn't connect for some reason...

And if some of the other receivers hadn't made nice plays to catch balls thrown behind them that percent would have been worse. 

We can play the hypothetical game all day long it won't turn PJ Walker into an NFL backup.

[CPsinceDay1]

Just now, trueblade said:

And if some of the other receivers hadn't made nice plays to catch balls thrown behind them that percent would have been worse. 

We can play the hypothetical game all day long it won't turn PJ Walker into an NFL backup.

But yet today he played just as good as any starter in the NFL would have, except maybe one who didn't play at all...

[trueblade]

1 minute ago, CPsinceDay1 said:

But yet today he played just as good as any starter in the NFL would have, except maybe one who didn't play at all...

You, my friend, watched a very different game than I did.

Edited August 16, 2021 by trueblade
forgot the word 'game'

[OldhamA]

29 minutes ago, micnificent28 said:

To add to that for comparison sake. Terrance Marshall JR was said to have run a 4.4... and a 4.38..... you see how that looked today...

He had a standing start and Carrie was going flat out. Still took 30 yards to track him down. 

[micnificent28]

2 minutes ago, OldhamA said:

He had a standing start and Carrie was going flat out. Still took 30 yards to track him down. 

That is not what happened here... if anything Marshall had more momentum than Carrie 

 

[TheCasillas]

This whole thing about Marshal getting run down… he could have just been gassed as well. I have a feeling you hit that dude in stride, he is gone.